›

The Most Difficult Choices You've Had In TWDG

KennysucksKennysucks Banned
in The Walking Dead

Out if both season one and season two, what were the most difficult choices you had to make? For me personally it was deciding to tell Nick about Matthew or not, I like Luke and wanted to follow up with his plan but I like Nick a lot as well and I couldn't lie to him. Another was robbing Arvo, I have a lot of compassion and I felt really bad just looking at how desperate the kid was but then Jane reminded me that we need those meds, but overall I couldn't steal from him so I told Jane to back off and we let him go

Comments

  • Flog61Flog61
    edited August 2014

    I struggled over telling Walter the truth or lying.

    I also struggled between choosing Nick or Pete.

    Apart from that, decisions were automatic reactions. Taking blame for the photo, sitting with Luke, giving myself up to carver, not watching carver get slaughtered, agreeing to go through the ticket booth etc, I just instinctively did what I felt right.

  • KennysucksKennysucks Banned

    Same here for the instinctivly did what was right part

    Flog61 posted: »

    I struggled over telling Walter the truth or lying. I also struggled between choosing Nick or Pete. Apart from that, decisions were au

  • AraronAraron
    1. Sitting with Luke or Kenny. I spent 5 minutes at the paused screen for such a simple choice. :P
    2. Telling Walter the truth and my opinion about Nick. (Was silent....it did not end well.)
    3. Robbing or not robbing Arvo. (Didn't Rob him)
      We'll see what's in store for episode 5.
  • EchopapaEchopapa

    Which table to sit at.

  • DragonleafDragonleaf
    edited August 2014

    The only two hard decisions for me were stealing from Arvo, and deciding whether or not to chop Sarita's hand. Everything else was easy for me, like watching Carver die, sitting with Kenny, saving Pete, (I don't have anything against Nick, I just really like Pete.) etc.

  • theonystheonys
    edited August 2014

    On my first playthrough I didn't tell my group about the bite. It was a hard decision for me, and now I don't know what I was thinking about, but then, I felt so worried about Clem, I was afraid that if group will know, they might not let me go save her. Like tell me that I was dangerous for everyone now, that I should stay until they'll find out what to do with me.

  • Poogers555Poogers555

    Alt text

  • Michael7123Michael7123

    The hardest choice I've had in a while is easily shooting rebecca or calling for help.

    In my mind, i felt like the choice would equal :

    (shoot rebecca) save the baby, but start a shootout.

    or

    (call for help) don't start a shootout, but the baby dies.

  • WeavoidWeavoid
    edited August 2014

    Deciding which table to sit at left me thinking for a while but in the end I sat with Kenny. To be honest, I'd rather go back and sit with Luke, but I think I'm okay. Besides, I don't rewind. I also thought for a while about whether I steal the pills from Arvo. I stole from the stranger in Season 1 as Lee, but Clementine disagreed with me. Deep down I regretted stealing, so as Clem I decided not to. Amid the Ruins had some pretty good choices, besides the ticket booth one, which was pretty obscure.

  • TwisteeTwistee

    It has to be the table for me. >.<

  • dinofiredinofire
    edited August 2014
    • Luke or Kenny Table (I sat with Kenny)
    • Leave/Convince Sarah (I wanted to save her, but thought Jane/Luke would get bit/die if you continued to convince her)
    • Robbing Arvo (I wanted to take a few bottles, not all of them, but no option for that)
    • Helping Kenny kill Larry (I helped)
    • Save/kill ben ( I saved him)
  • Nikolaj-11Nikolaj-11

    Aiding Kenny in the murder of Larry and letting Clem shoot Lee are the ones that come to mind for me.

    Mostly I've been staying truthful, loyal to Kenny and honest; so when it came to lying, stealing or a vs. Kenny situation I was usually in the clear with my choices, though Kenny's made that peace of mind challenging lately... :p

  • Wolf_13Wolf_13

    Cutting Lee's arm or not.

  • Frost5218Frost5218

    *Luke or Kenny- table scene.

    *Kill both St.John brothers (didn't want to scare Clem)

    *Kenny or Lilly- Larry scene

    *Which zombies to screw up in Lee's bad ass killing spree ;)

  • stitchfan08stitchfan08

    saving nick or pete I picked nick since pete was bit and I freaked out

  • Telling-a-taleTelling-a-tale

    Alt text

  • gimmeseason2gimmeseason2
    • Deciding whether or not to steal from the abandoned car in season 1 (stole)
    • Deciding to shoot Lee or leave him to die (shot him)
    • Stealing from Arvo (stole)
  • o0HeaDShoT0oo0HeaDShoT0o

    For me, in Season 2, these were my toughest choices to make.

    *Who to sit with at dinner

    *Telling Walter the truth or lie

    *Telling Bonnie about Luke

    *Speaking up about the stolen radio

    *Take or return the meds

  • Just_another_walkerJust_another_walker

    For season one it was whether to help Lily revive Larry or help Kenny kill him.
    Season two was whether to cut off Sarita's arm or kill the walker

Sign in to comment in this discussion.