oL` Breakon down the street farm has mare lame has a mare gone lame

I understand there have been countless threads on this , people will say oh not again or are you serious ? I've seen countless arguments from both side of the coin but never really got an answer ,at least an answer to my question and at least give a chance too let me understand why or why not ...

Sarah - Why did you really like her and why did you save her / why didnt you like her and did you refuse too save her ?

Save Sarah or Luke who would you pick , save Sarah or Kenny who would you pick , save Sarah or Jane who would you pick , save Bonnie or Sarah who would you pick , save Nick or Sarah who would you pick , save Sarah or Mike who would you pick , save yourself or sacrifice yourself for Sarah what's your choice ....????

I'm wondering if everybody would love Sarah as much if she got Kenny or Luke killed , I'm wondering if you would love her as much if she gotton Clementine bit? I'm not trying too make people hate or turn against her , I'm just wondering why so many of you loved her so much and I'm wondering why others were against her so much .....p.s. I'll have you all know I talked Sarah into escaping from the trailer and also I sent Jane down too try and save her , but deep down inside I knew if she didn't (eventually) snap out of it ' I knew she would not last long nor would I risk myself or another saving her over and over again ..... if you have energy too reply too this thread , don't argue or fight. It's only intended for opinion

I salute you if you had the energy too go over this one last time .... and if you don't , well .... hope you liked the tittle :-0

Comments

  • wow you must really hate sarah

    Piggs posted: »

    Save Sarah or Luke who would you pick Luke. save Sarah or Kenny who would you pick Kenny. save Sarah or Jane who

  • Save Sarah or Luke who would you pick

    Luke.

    save Sarah or Kenny who would you pick

    Kenny.

    save Sarah or Jane who would you pick

    Jane.

    save Bonnie or Sarah who would you pick

    Bonnie.

    save Nick or Sarah who would you pick

    Nick.

    save Sarah or Mike who would you pick

    Mike.

    save yourself or sacrifice yourself for Sarah what's your choice

    Save myself.

  • Sarah - I liked Sarah because she was Clementines only possible friend around her age, Clementine is bothered by Sarah's death even if you aren't as much as a friend to her. I think thats because she wonders if she will end up bitten like Duck or ripped apart like Sarah. I saved her because you are going to need LOTS of help living in an apocalypse and anyone can be useful to a group. Also a chain of events is the only thing that causes death so I wouldn't blame just one person.

  • In the end if Sarah suggested it I would most likely live on if it came down to it.

    Sarah - I liked Sarah because she was Clementines only possible friend around her age, Clementine is bothered by Sarah's death even if yo

  • I liked her and saved her because I don't solely identify with asshole characters who do horrible things and call it "survival" as justification, to put it bluntly. Really, there's nothing to dislike about Sarah unless you have a weird point of view on "weakness" in a zombie apocalypse, something this game/show/comic draws a lot of, or just don't like kid characters unless they're adults in children's bodies or just creepy little sociopaths. Her situation was understandable and her childish outlook may have been a detriment but through no fault of her own.

    It's hard enough living in an apocalypse as someone who doesn't have issues that go beyond just day-to-day shit you see, let alone someone like Sarah who had a condition long before the world went to hell. And even then, she still sought to know what was really going on despite Carlos' objections, and wanted to learn to survive and be Clementine's friend. Whether you like her or not, that's incredibly admirable.

  • I liked Sarah because she was innocent and naive, something that Clem was back in Season 1. I saved her every chance I got because I felt bad for her.

    Sarah or Luke? - I would go after Sarah because I know Luke can handle himself, hell, he handled himself for 4 days when Carver kidnapped the group.

    Sarah or Kenny?- Kenny, he's my bro and I would do literally anything to help him.

    Sarah or Jane? Same reasoning with not saving Luke. Jane can most def take care of her and Sarah'll need some coddling before she's able to help herself.

    Sarah or Mike? - Sarah, not to say I don't like Mike, because he is pretty cool.

    Bonnie or Sarah? - Bonnie. Only because I feel worse for Bonnie than I do Sarah. Bonnie first, accidentally killed kill Leland's wife and he either abandoned her or died, not sure. Then she winds up with Carver and just falls into the wrong crowd, getting Walter killed in the process. He was one of the few who showed her a kindness in a cruel world. So I would save Bonnie.

    Sacrifice myself for Sarah? - This one is tough, I love Clem but I wanted Sarah to survive so she could grow up and better herself. If given the option I would drag them both from the fire, so to speak.

  • Nah, I'd just save every member of the group over her. She's a bit of a liability, after all.

    wow you must really hate sarah

  • "O'l Breckon down the way thinks his mare's gone lame, but that ain't nothing new."

    Get the quote right.

  • We all know how the quote goes , I was joking around , take it easy bud

    "O'l Breckon down the way thinks his mare's gone lame, but that ain't nothing new." Get the quote right.

  • I'd save Sarah, all those other people can survive on their own, when I make a promise I tend to keep if I can, Sarah couldn't survive on her own because everyone sheltered her and treated her as a liability, so she became one, I would save Sarah over everyone else because she needs the most help and out of all those people, Sarah was really the only true friend to Clementine.

    Down vote me Sarah haters.... oh wait....

  • Your thread title doesn't seem to have anything to do with your content; it's a little confusing.

  • edited August 2014

    Luke/Sarah=Luke

    Kenny/Sarah=Kenny

    Nick/Sarah=Nick

    Bonnie/Sarah=Bonnie

    Mike/Sarah=Mike

    Jane/Sarah=Jane

    Clementine/Sarah=Clementine

    Sarah is a liability and will put people in danger of being killed trying to protect her. Carver said it best "killing one to save many is part of survival".

    And If you can't make the "hard decisions" then she will end up getting you killed too.

  • I'd save Sarah.she's nice and is Clem's friend in my canon.but if I had to save Clem,I would.to Lee,she was the world to him and it was kids first himself last.I have mixed opinions now,but Sarah should live.but,clementine would have been a wasted character if she were to die.

  • Agreed 1000%

    Piggs posted: »

    Nah, I'd just save every member of the group over her. She's a bit of a liability, after all.

  • edited August 2014
    • Luke/Sarah= Sarah. Luke screwed up pretty bad this time.

    • Kenny/Sarah=Sarah. Kenny is practically a more violent version of Sarah at this point.

    • Nick/Sarah= Um, I dunno :(. I guess Sarah, as that's probably what Nick would want.

    • Bonnie/ Sarah= I feel like Bonnie would want me to save Sarah. So Sarah.

    • Mike/ Sarah.= I can't imagine Mike somehow being in a situation where it would be one or the other. Anyway, I feel like he would want me to save Sarah. So Sarah.

    • Jane/ Sarah=Sarah. Jane just ditches us. It wouldn't even matter if she died.

    • Clementine/ Sarah= Clementine. Sorry, but there is no way I'm going to willingly sacrifice myself. I'd try to save you, but if there is an 100% I would die, I wouldn't take it. If I tried to save her, but ended up getting dying due to some accident, then that's different.

  • I think you mean 6001%

    Go get em Nappa

    Agreed 1000%

  • I did make a mistake. I agree 9000!!!!%

    I think you mean 6001% Go get em Nappa

  • kenny is a violent 15 year old girl lol ok

    Spooch posted: »

    * Luke/Sarah= Sarah. Luke screwed up pretty bad this time. * Kenny/Sarah=Sarah. Kenny is practically a more violent version of Sarah at t

  • It's the way he acts. He just mopes around and yells at people. Sarah just moped around.

    doggywoggy posted: »

    kenny is a violent 15 year old girl lol ok

  • Hey Vegeta, *8001

    I did make a mistake. I agree 9000!!!!%

Sign in to comment in this discussion.