*SPOILER IN TITLE* Killed off too early? -Luke-
SPOILERS FROM BEGINNING!
The one thing i'm incredibly p*ssed about is have no backbone leading into season 3. By this I mean that in all the endings I feel that Clem is abandoned and essentially alone, Kenny and jane could die and therefore will, meaning that Clem will at some point in season 3, and pretty early on I guarantee you that, will be without any main characters. I feel Luke could have filled this void, if Bonnie had fell in and Luke was kept alive, he could be incorprated into every ending, think about it..
It could of easily been scripted, they crash, everyone meets up at the place apart from luke, fighting starts and then clem makes her choice to shoot, who to kill etc.
Then Luke comes stumbling towards Clem and asks whats happening. Then the choice carry on from there:
1) Clem entering the place with Luke and Kenny sacrificing himself,
2) Clem Luke & Kenny leave w/ the baby
3) Clem Luke & Jane return to carvers place
4) Clem and Luke leaving Jane
5) Clem killing both and leaving with Luke
Luke shouldn't of been killed off for no reason, Luke had such great potential for character development, the devs wanted the early shock factor, but I'm left nothing but disappointed with the devs to be honest, really wasted an opportunity for a lee type relationship which I felt coming on. If they hadn't of been so goddamn trigger happy on killing Luke, they could have killed him later on in season 3 which would of had a much greater impact, I felt deflated when Luke died, but not absolutely distraught like I did for Kenny or Lee. They could have waited with Luke who I was just beginning to bond with in the same way I bonded with Lee, and then killed him off for a big shock factor in season 3. But nope, I feel they really missed an opportunity. Also I feel like Clementine, in my opinion is abandoned now, Kenny and Jane could die and therefore logic dictates they will. So in season 3 when tat does happen we'll be with a whole new group of nobodies. So if Luke hadn't of been killed off, we would of had 1 main character carrying over to season 3 and it would just feel right, starting all over again with new people makes me feel like everything was in vain.
Mike was the only character who couldn't possibly die though, so i goddamn hope he and Clem meet up again, asap.
Comments
Clem lowers her gun, having made the shot that ended the lives of both Kenny and Jane, she picks up baby AJ to continue on her journey of survival...
...and then out of nowhere Luke appears, "Yo, what happening?"
You are an expert writer
They definitely should hire you .After this ep it may be time to clean house at TellTale headquarters .
I know. And then Carley will show up and also Jane acually es Molan
No that's from the top of my head, your attempt at mocking me was from a misinterpretation of the way I suggested it to happen. When I said about Luke turning up I meant about him being just on the edge of the treeline seeing Clementine end the fight and then periodically the wind and snow thins enough for clementine to see luke from the corner of her eye standing from a distance frozen by shock as to whats unfolded. Or have Luke get out the car with Kenny and look for diesel then they all end up in the same place dont they? Possibly have him knocked unconscious by something during the fight, he' sitting down resting due to his leg when a shelf falls and knocks him unconscious from Jane and Kennys scrap and then have him awake in time for him to stumble out in the background drearily saying "wait...stop" and then our decision takes place, we shoot Kenny or not..I never claimed to be an expert writer, but its not that difficult to have luke in the same place, merely having him get out of the car with Kenny solves your problem with him spontaneously showing up. I'm just voicing my opinion on something and suggesting an alternative route for the story which for me would've suited the game better for myself. I dont see why you two feel the need to take such a hostile stance for no apparent reason. Think that helps to clear up any clear plot errors you wanna point out
Got a job thanks. Doing pretty well in life at the moment as well. Got my GCSE results, 4A*'s 7A's and a B in Astronomy which I took 2 years early. So I think being a cleaner is a little under me considering I plan on doing astro-physics at university & am already through some of my a level revision books before i've started A levels...
and got signed for a mens football 1st team when I was 15... ahaha
No that's from the top of my head, your attempt at mocking me was from a misinterpretation of the way I suggested it to happen. When I said about Luke turning up I meant about him being just on the edge of the treeline seeing Clementine end the fight and then periodically the wind and snow thins enough for clementine to see luke from the corner of her eye standing from a distance frozen by shock as to whats unfolded. Or have Luke get out the car with Kenny and look for diesel then they all end up in the same place dont they? Possibly have him knocked unconscious by something during the fight, he' sitting down resting due to his leg when a shelf falls and knocks him unconscious from Jane and Kennys scrap and then have him awake in time for him to stumble out in the background drearily saying "wait...stop" and then our decision takes place, we shoot Kenny or not..I never claimed to be an expert writer, but its not that difficult to have luke in the same place, merely having him get out of the car with Kenny solves your problem with him spontaneously showing up. I'm just voicing my opinion on something and suggesting an alternative route for the story which for me would've suited the game better for myself. I dont see why you two feel the need to take such a hostile stance for no apparent reason. Think that helps to clear up any clear plot errors you wanna point out