So I guess the Kenny haters condone what Jane did?

191012141525

Comments

  • sorry for writing,it's not good

    Rockworm posted: »

    ummm. what?

  • edited September 2014

    Which one is pizza and which one is ice cream?
    I sided with neither. Then i was going to rewind, but i thought it was too big of a choice to just change it after learning jane's trick. I've rewinded for smaller choices before, i don't know i didn't for that one.
    So, i'll probably do things differently in my second playthrough.

    Rockworm posted: »

    Are you me? This feels like something I would say!

  • I have no idea lol. You must be siding with brussel sprouts! :P

    Rylee posted: »

    Which one is pizza and which one is ice cream? I sided with neither. Then i was going to rewind, but i thought it was too big of a choice t

  • edited September 2014

    Seriously, I can't go every other discussion without someone blindly insulting my intelligence or implying that I'm too biased to reason with. Its so annoying.

    ALIENANGIE posted: »

    Now thats a childish comment. I'm not a massive Kenny fan. But because I have defended his actions over the last few episodes, I have been c

  • edited September 2014

    I agree with everything you said except hating Kenny. I don't hate him. I just hate the shoehoring of him back into the game. His sacrifice to try and save Ben was a perfect end for him! Instead he forces himself back into the narrative so that other characters never got a chance. Why should I care about these new people? Kenny is back that's all that matters. And it just got worse as the season progress. It stopped being he's back to he's the focal point. To finally you're flat out agreeing with him automatically. The most frustrating part of the season was siding with him while watching him get more and more crazy. Jane's trick at the end was so utterly pointless to me because I could see what Kenny was turning into. I was ready to leave him! But no Kenny! Kenny guys!.... I loved this season but Kenny playing such a big role as to make it all about him even more than it was about Clem really bothered me. And this is coming from someone who likes Kenny!

    Eguro posted: »

    Well... I did like the game, but it was far inferior to season 1 in my eyes, and a lot of that is due to Kenny returning. He simply took

  • Kenny didnt mind getting people killed even before, Jane didnt want to kill anyone, who hadnt done harm to her. Kenny obviously is more psycho and Jane.

    lartenc posted: »

    jane tried to kill kenny too,they had same chance for that!!!!! you shot kenny so you let your clem to become these: friend killer bec

  • than why you hate carver????? carver was right about some clems

    zykelator posted: »

    Well thats the problem with Kenny fans, you dont think rationally, you act on silly things called emotions. People like you would end up dea

  • for the first playing time how do you know that he will thank you ???

    it's not good reason.also he was dying,what you wanted him to say????

    Rockworm posted: »

    Than why did he thank me for stopping him?

  • Exactly my thoughts.

    Rockworm posted: »

    So was I! We toads think alike! But I played Clem as someone who always sees the best in people and give them a 2nd chance. I was furious

  • you've your thoughts and i've mine

    Rockworm posted: »

    Sorry but you're not going to guilt me into feeling bad for stopping Kenny from killing someone else.

  • edited September 2014

    Kenny didn't want to kill Larry, leaving the woman to die wasn't a stupid plan it would give them time to take supplies and help other people, Kenny regretted killing Jane, Kenny felt sorry for Ben once Ben explained himself, Kenny put Ben out his misery so Ben wouldn't have to suffer, Kenny is not a manipulative liar like Jane.

    zykelator posted: »

    Kenny didnt mind getting people killed even before, Jane didnt want to kill anyone, who hadnt done harm to her. Kenny obviously is more psycho and Jane.

  • why do we blame our selves for our choices????

    it's simple:

    if there was the best choice,the game couldn't attract us like this

    i suggest not to do this

    i'm off now!!!!

  • jane shoves her too

    Rockworm posted: »

    It was SOOOOOOOOOOOOO not that simple. You Kenny fans are acting like this is a simple black and white matter. I shot Kenny because I felt

  • Sorry, but Jane was my best friend, not Kenny. No way I was going to let Kenny kill her without her explaining herself.

    Kenny chose to attack a person who had a knife, after that person put the knife down. Kenny is stronger than Jane, and they both knew it. There's a reason why Kenny waits until Jane put the knife away and let go of the handle to charge, and that's because they both knew that the knife was her only chance of coming out on top.

    What was Jane supposed to do? Let Kenny grab her and do whatever he wanted with her? Her choices were to be at Kenny's "mercy" or use the knife, and once the fight started neither one was going to back down or think calmly. You can't have a conversation with someone that is swinging at you. Since Kenny started the fight, he's the one I'm going to stop.

    Also, if you do nothing, Jane will welcome the family at Howe's so your point that she ignores new people and is solitary is demonstrably wrong. Being around Clem helped her grow and learn to trust people again.

    lartenc posted: »

    jane tried to kill kenny too,they had same chance for that!!!!! you shot kenny so you let your clem to become these: friend killer bec

  • are you serious???? do you even think??? wow

    zykelator posted: »

    She doesnt try to brainwash into thinking Kenny is a bad guy, She set up situation where Kenny showed that he is a bad guy. Obviously her or

  • yes he did. he brought all those Russians to the group. he has all those fuckers blood, including her sister, and luke, cuz that limited lukes mobility and basically didn't say about a way around.

    prink34320 posted: »

    After Kenny accused her of being selfish and mocked her for her decision to be left alone. Jane asks Clementine to bring Kenny back from

  • When did Kenny ever say he regretted killing Larry? I thought that was one thing he was adamant about.

    J-Master posted: »

    Kenny didn't want to kill Larry, leaving the woman to die wasn't a stupid plan it would give them time to take supplies and help other peopl

  • I could say the same to you. What was the point of your pointless comment?

    jamex1223 posted: »

    are you serious???? do you even think??? wow

  • lol sure

    zykelator posted: »

    Well thats the problem with Kenny fans, you dont think rationally, you act on silly things called emotions. People like you would end up dea

  • Dont read them dude lol

    maxbear29 posted: »

    I swear to Christ if I read 1 more god damned post about Jane doing wrong and Kenny being a saint, or Kenny being a murderer and Jane being

  • Kenny got more people killed than Jane... Get your facts straight

    Jane was repeatedly encouraging Clem to let people die. She did it with Sarah, she did it with Luke, and had she been around for more deaths she would've probably kept saying "It's too late, give up." Oh yeah I want my Clem to be with her.

  • Well good picture but it dont fits with kenny^^ Also Jane was a friend too.

  • He didn't want to do it, but he thought he needed to do it in order to save both Lee and Lily, he gives his sincere apologies right after he did it.

    KCohere posted: »

    When did Kenny ever say he regretted killing Larry? I thought that was one thing he was adamant about.

  • I loved that scene too. I thought it was very cute and funny.

    maxbear29 posted: »

    I totally see where you are coming from. I agree he took up too much screentime and overshadowed other characters, but still, I adored the g

  • Well she firts tryed to defense herself. And even if it happend in a moment, doesnt make it right man.
    So it seems u had no problem with Lilly killing Carley? or Carver killing Reggie? Or The stranger killing Lee?

    lartenc posted: »

    sorry for writing,it's not good

  • A loyal test. Are you srsly?

    lartenc posted: »

    for the first playing time how do you know that he will thank you ??? it's not good reason.also he was dying,what you wanted him to say????

  • I stand by my choice. Don't regret it at all. I hope we get to see more of that scenario.

    lartenc posted: »

    why do we blame our selves for our choices???? it's simple: if there was the best choice,the game couldn't attract us like this i suggest not to do this i'm off now!!!!

  • Oh, sorry, didn't catch the post you were replying to. My bad. Yeah, it's clear she had killed people before, just not someone that wasn't a threat to her.

    Echopapa posted: »

    That's not my point. The guy I was replying to had said Jane NEVER killed anyone, regardless of wronging her or not.

  • Did you seriously say " just because there is evidence, you can't prove that she intended to do so"? She is the one that started the fight in the truck, and she purposely left clem at the truck when she was setting up her whole plan. Jane wanted top fight Kenny, she wanted to kill him too. She is a psycho that had her own agenda and pushed it onto clem to turn her against kenny. Kenny was in the right, so I let him kill her.

    RavenTDA posted: »

    No she put it away to make herself not so obvious. If she was too obvious that she wanted to kill him, Clem wouldn't forgive her or side wit

  • I'm not so sure about that, but I wont argue the point. I just wanted to know what you meant.

    J-Master posted: »

    He didn't want to do it, but he thought he needed to do it in order to save both Lee and Lily, he gives his sincere apologies right after he did it.

  • edited September 2014

    I have discovered when you are in the truck talking to Kenny, and if you disagree with him about lee coming to save her he tells Clem he should slap her. this just gives me more evidence that Kenny could potentially hurt Clem one day. He's Threatening her now, imagine what could happen down the road. This just convinced me what Jane did holds more merit. Kenny could possibly hurt Clem and Jane wanted to show her this.

  • cuz your point is wrong moron, "she didn't know Kenny would get this violent" uhh yeah she fucking did she did that FOR THAT EXACTLY. all that shit was just to prove a "point" everyone gets blinded by Kenny hate they don't see the shit for what it really is. she tricked EVERYONE. even after they crashed or slid the truck he fuckin asked jane if she was ok, when he could've just jumped to say " IT'S AJ OK" not giving a shit about jane. even though that's not a lot, it shows that he still had, or still had little conscious of caring for her, even if it was a tiny bit. and what does jane do, oh lets fucking leave right away he is out of the truck lets leave. and don't bring that bullshit that im blind because im a Kenny fan, guess what I wanted to shoot him first, I didn't play it first cuz TT fucked me on that one but that's another shit, I was yelling to stop Kenny option, I couldn't see well on the screen and I was too focus on the fight, but I knew Kenny needed to be stopped AT THAT moment. but then everything came out and I knew jane fucked me, fucked everyone and cause me to kill someone I loved. and again ill say to you like I said to many, I guess you love getting lied to, because that is all I get from people who defend jane.

    zykelator posted: »

    I could say the same to you. What was the point of your pointless comment?

  • I see it like this. Jane lied yes bad on her but she proved her point. If somthing did happen to the baby you know how Kenny would react. You cant say he would do anythig diffrent.

  • yeah bad fucking Kenny wanting to save his own SON over some kid that didn't see he walkers around. and save lily who was worse than him at that point and keep her there were it was a danger to the WHOLE group and kids. he wanted to leave behind arvo who brought all the Russians that wanted to steal all their shit and wanted to leave behind a useless piece of shit that basically caused the whole groups death. yeah fucking Kenny is a devil... lol fucking A man these people's way of thinking lol

    zykelator posted: »

    "Just goes on trying to brainwash Clem into believing he's some evil person." We all know that Kenny was evil person. He wanted to kill B

  • Kenny already took Duck to safety, but he didnt come back to help Lee save Shawn. What about all the other people Kenny has gotten killed? Dont they mean anything to you Kenny fans?

    Kenny is just huge prick

    ps. i played both seasons last night and it only made me hate him more. Maybe you should too, so you remember how fucking annoying he was in season 1, before he became violent maniac.

    jamex1223 posted: »

    yeah bad fucking Kenny wanting to save his own SON over some kid that didn't see he walkers around. and save lily who was worse than him at

  • yea I was mad at Kenny for that. " you know what I sacrificed that day" I was like motherfucker ypu didn't sacrifice shit, your whole fucking family is dead what did you sacrifice beside your life that you didn't even want to live anymore. but I understood he also got mad cuz clem kinda was ungrateful for what lee did, now THAT MAN DID SACRIFICE EVERYTHING. and he loves Lee and looked up a lot, depending how you played lee, so I guess he got mad that clem wasn't fully thankful that what they did(from kennys view)

    MosesARose posted: »

    I have discovered when you are in the truck talking to Kenny, and if you disagree with him about lee coming to save her he tells Clem he sho

  • Ew

    Rockworm posted: »

    I have no idea lol. You must be siding with brussel sprouts! :P

  • Arvo didn't cause Luke's death. Bad luck, the walkers, poor survival skills and Bonnie killed Luke.

    Ice is treacherous under the best of circumstances. Lots of people in the real world die because ice they thought was safe turned out not to be. It's hard to judge when ice can safely be crossed. There's no reason to believe Arvo knew the ice was too thin. In fact, it wasn't, since everyone but Luke had no trouble. Had the ice been really dangerous, more people would have fallen through.

    Luke still could have pulled out if the walkers hadn't been adding to the pressure to move quickly. And had Bonnie not moved closer to try and help, but stayed back and covered him as he asked, he might have had time enough to pull himself clear. And if the whole group had crawled through the ice, which is a safer way to cross ice you're not sure about, instead of walking upright, it wouldn't have broken in the first place.

    So no, Arvo didn't kill him, unless you can point to any evidence that supports your claim that he knew the ice was too thin, aside from Kenny jumping to that conclusion. In fact, no one else thought Arvo was to blame.

    And even if he was guilty, kicking the shit out of him was wrong. Causing someone pain to feel better is a sick way to behave, and only encourages a person to be more and more violent, as it associates being violent with feeling good.

    lartenc posted: »

    if jane knew that,she wouldn't be dead. arvo cause luke death,do you want to ignore it??? are you arvo apologist????he tricked the group and......(i hope you played the game)

  • It's not that she was ungrateful, it was more like she wished he didn't risk his life to save her. Remember Clem blames herself for Lee's death. I can understand her wishing he didn't come in save her, because she thinks he'd still be alive.

    jamex1223 posted: »

    yea I was mad at Kenny for that. " you know what I sacrificed that day" I was like motherfucker ypu didn't sacrifice shit, your whole fuckin

  • It's not that she was ungrateful, it was more like she wished he didn't risk his life to save her. Remember Clem blames herself for Lee's death. I can understand her wishing he didn't come in save her, because she thinks he'd still be alive.

    jamex1223 posted: »

    yea I was mad at Kenny for that. " you know what I sacrificed that day" I was like motherfucker ypu didn't sacrifice shit, your whole fuckin

This discussion has been closed.