Did you help Luke?
I didn't ... only because I'd watched a play through before I played and they went to help him. I wanted to see if there was a better outcome this way. And maybe if stupid Bonnie had listened to him. There would have been!
Still saying that, even though I loved Luke. His death sequence when you go to help him didn't upset me. Yet the one where you leave him does. Maybe because I felt I really had a chance of getting him out of there...
RIP Luke...Happy birthday. .. :'-(
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I covered Luke, I knew that too much weight would crack the ice and that if Bonnie hadn't gone to help him, he could've been alive.
Nope. I didn't because I didn't want Clementine to fall in, and do I regret it. Somewhat. I miss Luke though, but I was surprised by his death since I believed it'd be Luke vs Kenny not Luke vs Jane.
I went to help him because I knew that he would do the same for me.. And that way he gets to save you from that walker for one last time.
His death surprised me too...though I'm glad it wasn't Luke V's Kenny. I guess it was kind of obvious as soon as he mentioned it was his birthday. I loved how he kept smiling at Bonnie
I wish he had lived a little longer...If he had to die I wish it has been in a Doug/Carley situation with Mike and Bonnie stealing the truck. I can just see him now. Running out to to help Clem. Trying to talk sense into everyone, and Arvo killing him...
would've had more impact imo. I thought I'd really miss him. Instead I was more like... "Oh shit...Luke... oh...we're in the cabin!"
I tried to help him... Oh well. He dies anyway.
Yea I kept whacking the ice untill Clem fell in herself, too bad he was already gone by then, natually that skank Bonnie that I didn't care anything about climbs out and survives.
Logically, nobody should have ever gone near Luke. The ice was far too thin for two people.
However, I knew that he would die either way before playing (I was spoiled) so I went with the death that was slightly more heroic. He saves Clementine by grabbing the walker that would have gotten her.
I shot the walkers that were approaching him to buy him time as he requested and tried to break through the ice to let him surface, nearly drowning/ succumbing to hypothermia in the process
But apparently that didn't count as helping him.
I listened to him. Plus putting more weight on all ready cracking ice seemed insane.
I tried to help him by going to him. I thought Clem could have a chance since she indeed weights the least. Well, didn't really work out. Luke's last action was to save my ass from a walker, then sink along with it.
Playing again.....and damn. RIP Luke... :-(
I just had to go to him. I wanted to do... something!
Kinda illogical that Jane and Bonnie can easily run over the ice after saving Clem!
I went to help Luke, because I honestly didn't know what to do, and it was my gut reaction as soon as I saw "help" or "cover", I went for help. Plus I was scared he would die either way, and I thought if Luke's going to die, I'm not letting him die without trying to get him myself. I knew shooting the walkers was probably the smarter option, but I wasn't sure if he could pull his leg out himself and thought Clem might have a chance since she was lighter too. I don't regret my decision though, because he died a hero for me, and I prefer his death if you try to save him.
I really didn't want to risk getting him killed, so I covered him
instead, thinking (and hoping) he'd pull himself out.
I was so pissed off at Bonnie for trying to help him even
though they all knew the ice was too thin.
I'm sure he would have survived if Bonnie sticked to the
goddamn plan!
I checked his official status afterwards and I was devasted
to find out he dies either way