›

would your choice be the same if jane was luke

MrNiceWalkerMrNiceWalker
in The Walking Dead

luke shouldnt have drown. but what if he replaces jane during the fight over the baby? would you still let kenny die or let kenny live? or change your choice?

Comments

  • ian715ian715

    contrary to what the game was trying to make me do... i never really cared for Luke. So, just as i let Kenny kill Jane, i would let Kenny win over Luke. Kenny is my man

  • BeautifulBanjoBeautifulBanjo

    Eh...I doubt Luke would've been dumb enough to pretend the baby was dead, but if he did...

    I still would've let Kenny stab him

  • Saltlick123Saltlick123
    edited August 2014

    I would still Let Kenny live...

  • Alive_ClemAlive_Clem

    I would still shoot Kenny, tbh.

  • quinnicsquinnics

    I would save Luke.

  • CleverettCleverett

    If Luke had lived instead, I would have probably gone with Luke 2/3 times, instead of one Clem shooting Kenny, the other not being able to pull the trigger, and the third letting him kill Jane and then shoot Kenny.

    I wish Luke had lived. So much. ;_;

  • SupernovaeHollaySupernovaeHollay
    edited August 2014

    I would... cry for 30 minutes as I pause the game and throw down the controller. I would write down a list of pros and cons for each man, and then decide...

    So... I would save Luke.. BUT Luke wouldn't have done what Jane did, Luke wouldn't have criticized Kenny the way she did in the car, and wouldn't hide a damn baby in a car to provoke Kenny. I see it more as maybe Luke actually did get the baby killed on accident, and Kenny would flip out. I wouldn't let Kenny kill Luke though.

  • CrystalrainCrystalrain

    I wouldn't let anyone kill Luke.

  • RobojeevesRobojeeves

    The only reason that I shot Kenny was that he started the physical part of the fight and he was about to murder someone. To be honest, I killed him more for his sake than for Jane. That wouldn't have changed if it had been Luke, except that the decision would have been easier and the ending would be happier. I'm glad that Jane made it though, because she needs Clementine. My Clementine's goal is to bring out the best in everyone before the inevitable takes them away.

  • HERO_1000HERO_1000

    If Luke provoked Kenny into fighting the same way Jane did then I would've felt very betrayed and let Kenny kill him.

    If however Luke wasn't provoking Kenny and was trying to settle things peacefully(and he lost the baby for real, wasn't pretending) and kenny jumped on him and tried to kill him..........I dunno, it's really hard. I might kill kenny. It's probably the only situation in which I MIGHT kill kenny.

  • bazenjibazenji

    I would have let "What's-his-face, the long-haired dude who's not Kenny but wishes he was" die.

  • LilacsbloomLilacsbloom

    I'd of saved Luke, but I would've still would've found it hard to shoot Kenny because I care for them both.

    Jane on the other hand...[kicks her down the stairs] touch and go with her honestly x_x

  • zeke10zeke10

    Kenny left me to die in 103 so....Luke

  • AreUFuckingKiddingMeAreUFuckingKiddingMe Banned

    I'd still choose to shoot that mad psycho dog without hesitation.

  • Strat-rockerStrat-rocker

    I would save Luke it was his birthday.

  • RigtailRigtail
    edited August 2014

    The difference between Luke and Jane is that I'm not really a fan of her character. I actually like Luke. It would have been a much harder decision, but overall I still would have picked Kenny to live.

  • JayroenJayroen

    That would have been a real sucky choice yea, but like I said before thanks for making it an easy dicision for us telltale :)

Sign in to comment in this discussion.