Which episode did you dislike the most and why in Season 1 or 2
I disliked the carver episode. I thought it was slow while I was playing it and i felt a bit unnecessary at the time. At the end of the game I realized its relevance, but as I was playing it, I really didn't like it.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
In Season 1, my least favorite was the first episode(I got it for free.) I liked it, but not enough to get the rest. Then my friend Cody was telling me about how awesome the rest of the episodes were, so I went with it.
In Season 2, I my least-favorite was "Amid the Ruins. I felt like none of my choices changed a damn thing.
Season 1: A New Day
Season 2: Amid The Ruins
Season 1- No Time Left. The writing was the weakest of the first season, but still stronger than most of season 2's episodes.
Season 2- In Harm's Way. Amid the Ruins probably pissed me off more at the time, but in the end, In Harm's Way squandered every bit of potential Carver and the cabin group might have had. Amid the Ruins was just the aftermath of that debacle.
Season 1: Around Every Corner. I didn't care for Molly, and the episode felt extremely slow.
Season 2: Amid the Ruins. Bad writing and lots of wasted potential.
Season 1: A New Day
Season 2: All That Remains
Season 1: Around Every Corner/A New Day on replays. Long Road Ahead initially.
Season 2: In Harms Way followed by Amid the Ruins.
Overall: Amid the Ruins.
I can forgive a bad villain. I can't forgive wasted character potential.
Season 1: No Time Left.
Season 2: No Going Back.
Season 1: 400 days cause you only pay for it so they can get their cameo appearance in in harms way
Season 2: amid the ruins cause no one gives a damn bout your choice
Both of the first episodes. They just felt like they dragged on for so long and that nothing interesting was happening...
Season 1: A New Day
Season 2: All That Remains
Beginnings are always a little boring for me.
And the Second Episodes are my favorites
Season 1: A New Day
Season 2: All that Remains
In Season 1 I disliked starved for help the most. I didn't like the writing of that episode, because you could tell from the start that the St. Johns are up to no good and you get multiple hints that they are cannibals. The ending with the car felt like a deus ex machina. There wasn't much going on despite the obvious, that's why this is my least favourite episode of season 1.
I liked season 2 a lot more than season 1 but the one episode that dissapointed me was in harms way. I still think that Carver as an antagonis was underdeveloped and poorly written. And since he is in a certain way the driving factor in this episode the episode as a whole suffers.
Long Road Ahead for being way too long and having way too much backtracking, and Amid The Ruins for just generally being a mess.