S3 Predictions and S2 ending?
Honestly. I started off (and still am) a die hard kenny-ending fan.
But I kind of weighed the options, and both were right in some ways and wrong in the others. Both had ups, both had downs, both are open to discussion as to why they're so good or so bad. Though I prefer the Kenny ending, the Jane ending seems fine in a way. I just can't picture a world in TWD without Kenny. He's been me pal since s1. And some people weren't cool with Kenny in s1. It all falls down to what YOU think.
Clem is you, Lee was you, you can't say what they WOULD have done, because they would have done what you would have done. And both endings are great
BUT I am worried that neither choice will follow through so much through the 3rd season. Will they simply kill of whichever person (or no person) you chose in the same way like they did with the Carley/Doug scenario? If they do go through and don't just lazily kill one or the other off, i'll give them the props of the universe. More work on their part with VA and stuff, but in the end it'd be worth.
So please Telltale, make our decision actually MATTER unlike the decision to cut of Lee's arm or not. Go the extra mile and make whoever you chose not get shot in the first episode and opening up into the same story line either way.
Comments
All this assuming that it is a direct continuation of Clementine's story. For all we know, we could be Christa (I personally think she's dead, but that's not the point) next season. Telltale will get a lot of shit if the endings are ignored and all lead the same path, but knowing them, that's likely what they would have to do if we are Clementine again.
I have no way of proving this but I think that handling the intervening time with DLC so that we are all on the same page by season 3 will be their choice. Who knows what their "trying something different for season 3 means"? Since disregarding your choices is what they usually do maybe they will matter now.