If Sarah wasnt determinant...

Do you think she could've lasted until season 3?

  1. She had to run from the gun fight, she might've frozen up and got shot OR she could've done her amazing running
  2. She had to cross the ice, she could've done that
  3. She had to face her fear of walkers
  4. She had to not left with Bonnie and Mike - Bonnie cared alot about her so she might've asked her to leave with her
  5. Survived the snow storm with Jane or Clem - she could've got lost or eaten

Comments

  • I bet it would've been determinant if Sarah stays with you or leaves with Bonnie. Or maybe she would've got shot by Arvo either way. Fucking Arvo.

  • It may sound bad but in ep 5 I often found myself thinking man Sarah just couldnt have done any of this. I practically could see her freezing up on the ice or running in a panic like Arvo did.

    In reality I think she would have died in the storm, if she got seperated

  • edited September 2014

    No, but I think she definitely could have had a more meaningful death.

  • i think she would probably have been shot by the Russian at the beginning of episode 5

  • If the writers wasn't so lazy make the other characters improve that well... just to kill them off so sudden coz wether bor not it's gonna happen that way..

  • In the beginning of the episode Bonnie is shuffling around with the medicine's. She's not sure which one to use on the infected wounds.

    After having been quiet since the gunfight Sarah gets up and explains which one is the correct one, she helps Bonnie with fixing up Luke and then Clementine with fixing up Kenny, both of them thanks her and finally she smiles again.

    During the camp fire she will sit quietly but listen to the others conversation, when Clem goes to her she talks about her father as a dead person for the first time.

    Sarah: "He's not coming back is he?"

    Clem: "No." - "He is still with you" - "He's dead." - "..."

    Clem: "You should remember him for the good things and try not to think about his death."

    Sarah: "This man, Lee, do you still think about him?"

    Clem: "Always." - "It's hard to forget." - "I try not to." - "..."

    Clem: "He saved me and died trying to save me, just like your dad."

    Sarah: "I don't think I can ever learn to shoot. Not really."

    Sarah looks towards Bonnie's bag which contained the medicine.

    Sarah: "But I can... honour him? Become a doctor?"

    Clem: "A doctor would be useful." - "I think he would have liked that." - "If that is what you want." - "..."

    Sarah either gets seperated from the group in the snow storm and meets them after Kenny or Jane is dead, or goes with Mike & Bonnie, depending on if she considered Clementine her friend or not. In season 3 she's seen with a book about medicine if she stayed with Clementine's group.

  • To be honest I would have liked if she'd been able to survive ep4 and ep5. But she would have had to make some rapid progress in order to do so. I don't think she'd make it farther than the confrontation with the russian group, in the state we last saw her in.

  • I don't know if Sarah would've survived the season. I'd of loved it if she could've gotten away with Mike and Bonnie so we never see her die :( I'd of trusted Bonnie to take of her.

    Although, ditching a shot kid out in the door leaves much up to debate now.

  • Totally a sweet girl and the way she went was horrible. It really upset me that such a nice (yes weak in the world) died being torn apart by zombies. Such an awful way to go.

    Lahkesis posted: »

    No, but I think she definitely could have had a more meaningful death.

  • She'd probably have gotten along with Arvo.

    I really wish she hadn't been hated by the developers. They wound up creating a character who I sympathized with more than even the protagonist, and whose safety I was concerned about more than the rest of her group. The wasted potential of characters like Carlos, Nick and Sarah bother me precisely because I was more interested in their storylines than Kenny or Molly 2.0.

  • That would be pretty cool If you were her friend, she went with you. If you weren't her friend, she went with Bonnie.

    ClennyJr posted: »

    I bet it would've been determinant if Sarah stays with you or leaves with Bonnie. Or maybe she would've got shot by Arvo either way. Fucking Arvo.

  • If Kenny wasn't there, it may have been interesting (and no less absurd than Clem's uber-competence) if the doctor's daughter was responsible for overseeing AJ's birth.

  • I wish she could have made it to Wellington. She obviously wasn't cut out for living in the apocalypse but if she'd made it to Wellington she could have at least had a normal ish life.

  • I saw ans awesome AU where Sarah survives, snaps out of it and becomes a doctor of the group. And she even wears checkered shirts, like her father did. It would be very great. And it could also show an evolution of her character.

  • edited September 2014

    A Season 2 where Kenny died in Savannah and Sarah became Clem's companion would have been so promising...

    I saw ans awesome AU where Sarah survives, snaps out of it and becomes a doctor of the group. And she even wears checkered shirts, like her father did. It would be very great. And it could also show an evolution of her character.

  • It probably would.

    Bokor posted: »

    A Season 2 where Kenny died in Savannah and Sarah became Clem's companion would have been so promising...

  • I think that she would be killed at the start with the Russians... or sometime after it, i really would have liked to see more of her... even if it was only two seconds after the start. Killing her two times in the same episode really annoyed me.

  • It would almost be heart wretching if instead of "go for baby" "go for cover" it was "go for baby" or "pull sarah down." Even if she'd die regarless :o

    IcyFlame posted: »

    I think that she would be killed at the start with the Russians... or sometime after it, i really would have liked to see more of her... even if it was only two seconds after the start. Killing her two times in the same episode really annoyed me.

  • I felt like Sarah's death was bullshit just like all of the other season 2 characters. I felt she was supposed to last longer than she did but Telltale said "Fuck it".

  • Probably would I still felt that Kenny survived was bullshit and he should had died in that alley.

    Bokor posted: »

    A Season 2 where Kenny died in Savannah and Sarah became Clem's companion would have been so promising...

Sign in to comment in this discussion.