Those who think Clem wasn't controllable enough
You're all right. She's not fully controllable. But how much control do you want over a game ( Going on it's script ) that mostly consist of choosing dialogue? It's not like Lee was fully controllable either. Plus, she's an 11 year old girl. It should be the adults in her survival group the have the majority say in what they do or where they go. Someone that age probably wouldn't want to or even be afraid to do so. Were also taught to respect our elders so it kinda comes naturally. No one would take her seriously anyways because she is still maturing and developing and just the number 11 makes people not really listen to her when it comes to a big decision. A perfect example of this is when the group is locked inside Carver's truck and when you have the option to say "Kenny is right, we have to do something," Carlos replies "Clem, the adults are talking." Once Clem is a teen ( Maybe 14-16 ), then that's when should start having some real "control" over what we want her to do