›

Does anyone think this would have been more powerful?

DillonDexDillonDex
edited September 2014 in The Walking Dead

If Jane died on the lake, and Kenny and Luke ending up fighting later on - and you had to choose between killing one of them?

Then you could have either, say, returned to Carver's or the Cabin with Luke.

Or (just like the Kenny endings) gone to Wellington.

Or just take A.J and leave them both. Do you think that would have been much better? (I do...)

And what do you think the percentage would be for that choice? I reckon about

Protector: Who did you choose?
62% of players shot Kenny
30% of players shot Luke
8% of players left the fight

Comments

  • ABigBadWolfABigBadWolf
    edited September 2014

    I would have preferred a Kenny VS Luke, but I don´t think Luke would ever do what Jane did so I don´t know how that could´ve gone. Maybe a save one of them kind of situation.

    I´d have chosen Luke, anyway.

  • clementinewalkerclementinewalker
    edited September 2014

    I dont think Luke would hide the baby and start a fight with Kenny he isnt just that kind of a guy, maybe if walkers attack them and you have to choose who you want to save. In that case i would save Luke.

  • LingvortLingvort

    I would've chosen Kenny either way, but I would've given it a bit more thought, since I liked Luke way more than Jane.

  • GoldenPaladinGoldenPaladin

    LUKEFOREVER

    Luke was my favorite, I would have chosen to save him immediately.

  • SimplySimply
    edited September 2014

    I would have loved if Luke made it till the end since his death seemed quite 'cheap' and for shock value, but I don't think I could see him attempting to murder Kenny, I mean he hated Carver, yet was still against killing him, I believe that even if Kenny provoked Luke lots that Luke wouldn't have fought with Kenny/ tried to murder Kenny. But I could see an ending where Luke and Kenny argue in the car constantly then Kenny gets out like he does in the actual episode and Clementine skids the car but this time Luke helps Clementine out of the car and Clementine holds Aj but they get separated from Luke then Clementine comes across Kenny and Kenny might think Luke left Clementine and Aj so when he see's him an argument breaks out Kenny might say 'You never cared about the group, all you care about is yourself.' and because the group meant so much to Luke he might get mad and say 'You never cared about your family, you moved on to Sarita didn't you?' or something like that Kenny might get so angry he holds Luke at gunpoint and you have the option to let Kenny kill Luke or to shoot Kenny yourself...

    I don't know I can't think :3

  • Saltlick123Saltlick123

    Even though it would have been predictable it's what all the build up was going towards, The Jane/Kenny decision was way too easy for me

  • BlueShadiwBlueShadiw

    Luke to me doesn't seem like the guy that would even consider Jane's tactics.

    "There's always one bad seed rocking the boat. I don't think Luke could've ever been that guy..." -Bonnie

    But if it did go to that, I would surely take more time to choose between the two, since I actually like Luke better than Jane.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.