Carl (Comics) vs Clementine

edited November 2014 in The Walking Dead

Who would win in a one on one fight between carl and clementine in an open environment with a bunch walkers around like the envirement where clementine fought winston. Carl from the comics.

Comments

  • edited November 2014

    Hmm...Now which Carl are we talking about? Modern day television or comic? Prison-Era Carl? Early Alexandria-Era Carl? Atlanta Carl? Also which Clementine? Season One or Season Two?

    Oh and do they have any weapons at all?

  • Well it's difficult. I mean if they both have guns, one can just shoot the other. If they had to resort to melee (Let's say Carl has a knife like Janes and Clementine has a hatchet) - I would imagine Clementine would win. Mainly due to the fact she is intelligent and smarter than Carl, she can easily lead him into some walkers.

    -Kenny posted: »

    Carl from the comic at both of there time mabye a gun for each and some melee weapons and walkers can kill them

  • Carl from the comic at both of there time mabye a gun for each and some melee weapons and walkers can kill them

    HarjKS posted: »

    Hmm...Now which Carl are we talking about? Modern day television or comic? Prison-Era Carl? Early Alexandria-Era Carl? Atlanta Carl? Also which Clementine? Season One or Season Two? Oh and do they have any weapons at all?

  • edited November 2014

    Comic Carl is good but I think Clem has an edge. So her.

  • Well it wouldn't really be a fight, it'd just be based on who shot first. But if they were sticking to melee weapons such as Janes Knife for Carl and Clementines Hatchet for Clem. Clementine would win, she's a lot smarter and would lead Carl into walkers, and since his anger would overtake him, he wouldn't really be thinking clearly.

    -Kenny posted: »

    Carl from the comic at both of there time mabye a gun for each and some melee weapons and walkers can kill them

  • Why must we always have a "x vs y" fight thread?

    Alt text

  • Because we have this thirst for blood of fictional characters.

    It's like gladiator fights, We want them to and therefore THEY SHALL FIGHT TO THE DEATH!

    :P

    Why must we always have a "x vs y" fight thread?

  • The gif won't load up on my phone and I keep thinking its dirt.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.