›

Would You trade Lilly for Kenny?

Lord_EAALord_EAA
in The Walking Dead

So i was watching a walkthrough of season 1 and the question hit me.

If given the choice would anyone trade Kenny's spot to Lilly?

( Keep in mond this not only would involve Lilly being in 2-5 no matter the choice but also various attempts at having a good relationship with Lilly.)

Comments

  • InGen_Nate_KennyInGen_Nate_Kenny Moderator
    edited January 2015

    No. Kenny doesn't kill innocent people because out of anger. (but he does hunches!) EDIT: I totally forgot Larry. Jane I don't consider a hunch.

    I hate Lilly. I hated her in A New Day, I hated her in Long Road Ahead.

  • TheWolfOfTheDeadTheWolfOfTheDead
    edited January 2015

    No. Kenny doesn't kill people because of hunches.

    Alt text Alt text

    InGen_Nate_Kenny posted: »

    No. Kenny doesn't kill innocent people because out of anger. (but he does hunches!) EDIT: I totally forgot Larry. Jane I don't consider a hunch. I hate Lilly. I hated her in A New Day, I hated her in Long Road Ahead.

  • supersagigsupersagig

    And in Starved for Help?

    InGen_Nate_Kenny posted: »

    No. Kenny doesn't kill innocent people because out of anger. (but he does hunches!) EDIT: I totally forgot Larry. Jane I don't consider a hunch. I hate Lilly. I hated her in A New Day, I hated her in Long Road Ahead.

  • supersagigsupersagig
    edited January 2015

    In season 1 , no. But i will change Kenny returnin in S2 with Lily :P

  • InGen_Nate_KennyInGen_Nate_Kenny Moderator
    edited January 2015

    Oh lol. I totally forgot. I don't really consider that a hunch. More of an anger response. Plus what Jane did end up lying so...

    TheWolfOfTheDead posted: »

    No. Kenny doesn't kill people because of hunches.

  • TheWolfOfTheDeadTheWolfOfTheDead
    edited January 2015

    Oh thanks for reminding me of that lol

    supersagig posted: »

    And in Starved for Help?

  • InGen_Nate_KennyInGen_Nate_Kenny Moderator
    edited January 2015

    Oops, posted again.

  • InGen_Nate_KennyInGen_Nate_Kenny Moderator

    Meh. I guess so. I felt Larry wasn't going to live because a defibrillator would have been needed. CPR doesn't fully save someone. I

    supersagig posted: »

    And in Starved for Help?

  • NeophyteRadglareNeophyteRadglare
    edited January 2015

    Hmmm...Yeah, why not.

    She had more of a close relationship with Clementine than Kenny ever did, because Kenny had no interaction with her at all from what I can remember and Lilly gave her hair-ties. Which doesn't seem like much but it's still better than nothing. And if Lee helps kill Larry she'll still protect Clem at the dairy farm, which is more than I can say about Kenny who will determinantly refuse to help Lee look for Clementine if he doesn't take his side enough. But there's also Lilly's shooting of Doug or Carley which probably damaged their relationship, in the dream, Lee will ask Clementine if they should have let Lilly stay and 'I don't think so' was a possible answer.

    So yeah, I think I would have traded them, as long as the writers didn't favor her and have her hog all the screentime with a repeated arc like they did with Kenny.

  • Lord_EAALord_EAA

    Why?

    Also btw Super i pmd you about something

    supersagig posted: »

    In season 1 , no. But i will change Kenny returnin in S2 with Lily :P

  • Lord_EAALord_EAA
    edited January 2015

    Lets be honest they probably would have

    They would haver he be saved by a sergeant or some other Father like figure to keep her semi-sane till ep 4 then they would do something similar to sarita. Then they would make her kenny like

    NeophyteRadglare posted: »

    Hmmm...Yeah, why not. She had more of a close relationship with Clementine than Kenny ever did, because Kenny had no interaction with her

  • supersagigsupersagig

    Yep , i see it :P

    Lord_EAA posted: »

    Why? Also btw Super i pmd you about something

  • Kenny_Is_AliveKenny_Is_Alive

    Hell no.

  • Poogers555Poogers555

    Alt text

  • ash2ashesash2ashes
    edited January 2015

    Yes, definitely. The only con, imo, would having to see her die on screen :C

  • -Kenny-Kenny

    Alt text

Sign in to comment in this discussion.