What were your choices in the Walking Dead Season 2? Please comment below :)

edited February 2015 in The Walking Dead

EPISODE 1

Q. Did you save Christa, or leave Christa?
A. I saved Christa. 83.8% (More Players)

Q. Did you kill the dog, or spare the dog?
A. I killed the dog. 81.6% (More Players)

Q. Did you accept Nick’s apology, or reject it?
A. I accepted Nick’s apology. 89.9% (More Players)

Q. Did you give water to the dying man who tried to kill Christa, or leave him?
A. I left the dying man behind and did not give him water. 33.3% (Less Players)

Q. Did you save Nick, or Pete?

A. I saved Pete. 56.8% (More Players)

EPISODE 2

Q. Did you take the blame for Sarah’s photo, or lied?
A. I lied to Sarah and did not take the blame. 60.5% (More Players)

Q. Who did you sit with at dinner, Luke, or Kenny?
A. I sat with Kenny. 67.8% (More Players)

Q. Did you tell the truth to Walter about Matthew, or lie?
A. I told the truth about Matthew. 74.9% (More Players)

Q. Did you persuade Walter into forgiving Nick, or not?
A. I persuaded Walter into forgiving Nick. 84.3 (More Players)

Q. Did you leave to find Kenny, or surrender?

A. I left to find Kenny. 76.9 (More Players)

EPISODE 3

Q. Did you help Sarah with her work, or not?
A. I helped Sarah with her work. 80.2% (More Players)

Q. Did you tell Bonnie about Luke?
A. I told Bonnie about Luke. 51% (More Players)
Q. Did you admit to steal the walkie talkie, or try to hide it?
A. I tried to admit I stole. 42.2% (Less Players)

Q. Did you watch Kenny kill Carver, or leave?
A. I watched Kenny kill Carver. 68.3% (More Players)

Q. Did you cut off Sarita’s arm, or kill the walker?

A. I cut off Sarita’s arm. 82.7% (More Players)

EPISODE 4

Q. Did you leave Sarah at the trailer park to die, or save her?
A. I left Sarah at the trailer park to die. 20.7% (Less Players)

Q. Did you rob Arvo, or leave him alone?
A. I robbed Arvo. 44% (Less Players)

Q. Did you crawl through the ticket booth, or chicken out?
A. I crawled through the ticket booth. 86% (More Players)

Q. Did you hold the baby, or refuse?
A. I held the baby. 92.9% (More Players)

Q. Did you shoot Rebecca, or shout for help?

A. I shot Rebecca. 62.2% (More Players)

EPISODE 5

Q. Did you protect the baby, or go for Luke?
A. I protected the baby. 84.2% (More Players)

Q. Did you ask to leave with Mike, or refuse?
A. I refused. 98% (More Players)

Q. Did you shoot Kenny, or leave Jane to die?
A. I shot Kenny. 52.8% (More Players)

Q. In the end, were you alone, with Jane and the family, with Jane, with Kenny, or at Wellington?

A. I was with Jane. 10.4% (Lowest amount of Players)

Comments

  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1
    ---- I saved christa
    ---- I killed the dog
    ---- I accepted Nick's apology
    ----- I gave water to the dying man
    ---- I saved Nick

    Episode 2
    ---- I took the blame for the photo
    ---- I sat with Kenny
    ---- I told the truth about Matt
    ---- I persuaded to save Nick
    ---- I surrendered to Carver (on my original playthru)

    Episode 3
    ---- I helped Sarah (on my original playthru)
    --- I didn't tell bonnie about Luke
    --- I tried to tell the truth about the talkie
    --- I watched kenny kill carver
    --- I hacked and axed Sarita

    Episode 4
    ---- I slapped some sense into Sarah( on my original playthru)
    --- I didn't steal from Arvo (on my original playthru)
    ---- I let that bitch crawl thru
    --- I held Aj
    --- I shot Becky

    Episode 5
    ---- I got Aj
    --- I didn't ask to leave with Mike
    --- I covered Luke
    ---- I let kenny kill jane
    ---- I was with Kenny and Aj

  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1

    I saved Christa

    I killed the dog.

    I accepted Nick’s apology.

    Didn't give the dying man water

    SAVED UNCLE PETE!

    Episode 2

    I took the blame for Sarah

    I sat with Kenny

    I told the truth about Matthew.

    Walter forgave Nick

    I left to find Kenny.

    Episode 3

    I helped Sarah with her work.

    I told Bonnie about Luke.

    I attempted to admit I stole

    I watched Kenny kill Carver.

    I cut Sarita’s arm off

    Episode 4

    I saved Sarah

    I left shitbird 2.0 alone thinking that if we left him alone he would spare us in the future......

    I crawled through the ticket booth.

    I held the baby.

    I shot Rebecca.

    Episode 5

    I protected the baby.

    Didn't ask to go with Mike.

    Let Kenny Kill Jane

    Decided to stick with Kenny (Because I doubt Wellington will work out)

  • Episode 1

    I tried to help Christa.

    I killed the dog.

    I accepted Nick's apology.

    I refused to give him water.

    I went with Pete.

    Episode 2

    I took the blame for the photo.

    I sat with Kenny.

    I told Walter the truth.

    I convinced Walter to forgive Nick.

    I went to go look for Luke and Kenny.

    Episode 3

    I helped Sarah with her chores.

    I didn't tell Bonnie about Luke.

    I tried to hide the theft.

    I stayed to watch Carver die.

    I cut off Sarita's arm.

    Episode 4

    I got Sarah to leave the trailer park.

    I refused to steal from Arvo.

    I crawled through the ticket booth.

    I held the baby.

    I called for help.

    Episode 5

    I went to go help AJ.

    I went to go help Luke.

    I refused to go with Mike.

    I let Kenny kill Jane.

    I decided to stay with Kenny.

  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1

    • Tried to help Christa
    • Put Sam down
    • Rejected Nick's apology
    • Gave him water, only to try and get some answers out of him.
    • Followed Nick

    Episode 2

    • Shared responsibility, thanks to "Honest Sarah"
    • Luke
    • Told the truth
    • Told Walter Nick's a good dude
    • Left to find Luke and Kenny

    Episode 3

    • Helped Sarah
    • Did not tell Bonnie about Luke/Tried to admit I had it
    • Left
    • Chopped her arm off

    Episode 4

    • Really slapped the shit out of her
    • Did not take from him
    • Crawled through
    • Held AJ
    • Put Rebecca down

    Episode 5

    • Grabbed AJ
    • Drew on Mike
    • Killed Kenny
    • With Jane and AJ
  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1

    I tried to help Christa

    I killed Sam

    I accepted Nick apology

    I gave the dying man water (regret it later because i couldn´t give water to Pete)

    I saved Pete

    Episode 2

    I said that Carlos told me to distract Sarah (lol , i refused the take the photo XD)

    I sat with Kenny

    I told Walter the truth

    I convinced Walter that Nick was a good man

    I went to look for Luke and Kenny

    Episode 3

    I helped Sarah

    I told Bonnie about Luke

    I tried to hide the theft

    I stayed to watch Carver die

    I cut off Sarita´s arm.

    Episode 4

    I got Sarah out of the Trailer Park

    I didn´t steal from Arvo

    I crawled through the ticket booth

    I held the baby

    I shot Rebecca

    Episode 5

    I protected AJ

    I tried to help Luke

    I didn´t ask to leave with him

    I shoot Kenny

    I ended up alone with AJ

  • edited February 2015

    E1

    • Tried to help Christa
    • Killed Sam
    • Accepted the apology
    • Gave the dying man water
    • Saved Pete

    E2

    • Blamed someone else for the photo
    • Sat with Luke
    • Told the truth to Walter
    • Made Walter forgive Nick
    • Sought Kenny´s help

    E3

    • Did not help Sarah
    • Told Bonnie about Luke
    • Tried to admit I stole the walkie talkie
    • Watched Carver die
    • Chopped off the arm

    E4

    • Saved Sarah
    • Stole from Arvo
    • Crawled through the ticket booth
    • Held the baby
    • Shot Rebecca

    E5

    • Went for cover
    • Tried to help Luke
    • Did not ask to leave with Mike
    • Shot Kenny
    • Alone with Jane and AJ
  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1

    • Helped Christa

    • Killed Sam

    • I accepted Nick's apology

    • Refused to give water

    • Pete

    Episode 2

    • Took the Blame

    • Sat with Kenny

    • Told Walter the truth

    • I told Walter that Nick was a good guy

    • I went to look for Kenny

    Episode 3

    • Helped Sarah

    • Told Bonnie

    • I tried to say I took it

    • I didn't stay to watch(I didn't want Clem to see murder on purpose)

    • I cut Sarita's arm off

    Episode 4

    • I saved Sarah

    • Didn't take from Arvo

    • I went through the booth

    • I held the baby

    • Shot Rebecca

    Episode 5

    • Got AJ

    • Helped Luke

    • I didn't ask to leave with them

    • I let Kenny stab Jane

    • Stayed with Kenny

    Well this list took forever to write

  • edited February 2015

    EP. 1

    • Did you try to save Christa? A. Yes

    • Did you kill the dog? A. Yes.

    • Did you accept Nick’s apology? A. Yes.

    • Did you give water to the dying man? A. Yes (in an attempt to learn of Christas whereabouts)

    • Did you save Nick, or Pete? A. I saved Pete.

    EP. 2

    • Did you take the blame for Sarah’s photo? A. I blamed someone else.

    • Who did you sit with at dinner, Luke, or Kenny? A. I sat with Kenny.

    • Did you tell the truth to Walter about Matthew? A. Yes, but first suggested Nick not too (before Walter found out on his own).

    • Nicks Fate? A. I let Walter make up his own mind (apparently an unpopular choice to let a grown man make his own decision, only 17% of other players did this)

    • Left to find Kenny? A. I stayed to help Carlos

    EP. 3

    • Did you help Sarah with her chores? A. Yes

    • Did you tell Bonnie about Luke? A. No

    • Did you admit to steal the walkie talkie, or try to hide it? A. I tried to speak up.

    • Did you watch Kenny kill Carver, or leave? A. I watched Kenny kill Carver.

    • Did you cut off Sarita’s arm, or kill the walker? A. I cut off Sarita’s arm (and followed by axing her face... in a panic)

    EP. 4

    • Did you leave Sarah at the trailer park to die, or save her? A. I saved Sarah.

    • Did you rob Arvo, or leave him alone? A. I robbed Arvo. (Didn't trust him. Obviously no person in his shape could survive alone)

    • Did you crawl through the ticket booth, or chicken out? A. I let bonnie reach through (felt like Clementine was tired of people looking at her to do every single thing.)

    • Did you hold the baby, or refuse? A. I held the baby

    • Did you shoot Rebecca, or shout for help? A. I shot Rebecca.

    EP. 5

    • Did you protect the baby, or go for Luke? A. I protected the baby.

    • Went to help luke? A. No (at his request. I liked Lukes character and the buddy nature he shared with Clementine. Luke was kinda like the Clementine to Lee, but for Clementine. Clementines Clementine.)

    • Asked to leave with Mike? A. No

    • Did you shoot Kenny, or look away? A. I shot Kenny (stayed neutral most of the fight, yelled at Kenny once, pushed Jane once, let the wire go all the way down until I decided to shoot Kenny.)

    • In the end? A. I was alone with AJ (Jane manipulated Clementine in an attempt to show how unstable Kenny was, it resulted in Clementine being the trigger for the closet thing to family she has left, so I left Jane even though she was a good survival mentor to Clementine.)

    I made my choices mostly by catering to the type of person Clementine is. Initially an innocent kid, now growing up in a zombie apocalypse and being cared for by Lee has evolved Clementine as you could tell by a lot of her dialogue options. Didn't steal from the stranger last season, but that was before I realized it's every group for them self. Playing the episodes consecutively I think you can feel a stronger character connection than if you wait for episodes.

  • Episode 1

    • Tried to help Christa
    • Killed the dog
    • Rejected the apology
    • Refused to give water
    • Saved Pete

    Episode 2

    • Blamed someone else
    • Sat with Luke
    • Lied about Matthew
    • Didn't convince Walter to forgive Nick
    • Went to find Kenny

    Episode 3

    • Did my own work
    • Didn't tell Bonnie about Luke
    • Tried to come clean
    • Watched Kenny kill Carver
    • Chopped it off

    Episode 4

    • Left Sarah
    • Robbed Arvo
    • Crawled through
    • Held the baby
    • Shot Rebecca

    Episode 5

    • Protected the baby
    • Tried to help Luke
    • Didn't ask to leave with Mike
    • Shot Kenny
    • With Jane and AJ
  • edited February 2015

    All That Remains

    Helped Christa

    Euthanized Sam

    Extra-Became Friends with Sarah

    Accepted Nick's apology

    Gave the man water

    Saved Nick

    A House Divided

    Took the blame

    Sat with Lord Kenny, Savoir of Boats and Urbans.

    Told Walter the Truth

    Convinced Walter to Forgive Nick

    Extra-Saved Alvin

    Stayed to help Carlos

    In Harm's Way

    Helped Sarah

    Told Bonnie about Luke

    Tried to speak up

    Didn't watch Kenny kill Carver

    Didn't chop Sarita's arm off

    Amid The Ruins

    Saved Sarah

    Didn't Steal from Arvo

    Crawled through the Ticket Window

    Held AJ

    Didn't shoot Rebecca

    No Going Back

    Ran to AJ

    Went back for Luke

    Didn't ask to leave with Mike

    Didn't Shoot Kenny

    With Kenny and AJ

  • All That Remains

    Tried to help Christa

    Killed the dog (because only a mega-dick would leave the dog to die)

    Accepted Nick's apology

    Went with Pete

    A House Divided

    Took the blame for Sarah's photo (even though I didn't even take the picture myself in my playthrough)

    Sat with Kenny

    Told Walter the truth

    Convinced him to forgive Nick

    Surrendered (escalating a hostage situation is a bad idea)

    In Harm's Way

    Helped Sarah with her chores

    Told Bonnie about Luke

    Tried to admit to stealing the walkie

    Stayed to watch

    Cut off Sarita's arm

    Amid The Ruins

    Saved Sarah at the trailer park

    Didn't rob Arvo

    Let Bonnie reach through the ticket booth

    Held the baby

    Didn't shoot Rebecca

    No Going Back

    Went for AJ

    Tried to help Luke

    Didn't ask to leave with Mike

    Didn't shoot Kenny

    With AJ in Wellington

  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1: I left Christa, killed the dog, accepted Nick's apology, kept water(you can give to Pete in next episode), and went to Pete.

    Episode 2: I took the blame for the photo, sat with Kenny, told Walter the truth, persuaded Walter into forgiving Nick, and surrendered to help Carlos.

    Episode 3: I helped Sarah, told Bonnie about Luke, tried to admit having the radio, didn't watch Carver get killed, and didn't cut off Sarita's hand.

    Episode 4: I saved Sarah, didn't rob Arvo, let Bonnie stick her arm through the booth, held the baby, and remained silent when Rebecca turned.

    Episode 5: I went after the baby, asked to leave with Mike, let Kenny kill Jane, and stayed at Wellington.

  • I will also add reasons to my choices

    Ep 1 ALL THAT REMAINS

    Saved Christa (Being a friend and fellow survivor. Plus despite her bitterness, she's still a good person)
    Killed the dog (Couldn't let it suffer)
    I accepted Nick's apology (Once he opened up and admitting "being a dick" he earned my respect. I wasn't fond of Ben from Season 1 but Nick I felt was different, better even, more redeemable)
    Kept the bottled water (I have no idea if Christa was dead or not, but he and his buddies were the ones whom done the deal. Plus even my compassion has it's limits)
    Saved Pete (Despite being bit, I felt I owed him, saving Clem's life and all.)

    EPISODE 2 A HOUSE DIVIDED
    Is it possible to do neither, taking the blame or not. Didn't feel that important
    Sat with Kenny (old friends and all)
    Told Walter the truth (No lies with me, only truth unless otherwise)
    I convinced Walter to forgive Nick (Nick was a good guy, just impulsive sometimes plus I hoped he would learn and develop)
    First I went to look for Kenny but I restarted that part and chose to surrender (there were three of them armed with AK-47's, plus with Carlos getting pummeled, I felt it was the best course of action)

    EPISODE 3 IN HARM'S WAY
    Helped Sarah (Felt I needed too. Sarah maybe a burden at times but like Nick I had taken solace in seeing the both of them redeemable)
    Bonnie I wasn't sure about so I kept it to myself (Wasn't 100% she would agree with escaping)
    Kept the walkie talkie hidden (The plan to bust out was paramount. No way I was staying there under Carver's tyrannical rule)
    Stayed and watched Kenny bash Carver's head in (I wanted to see the monster die, he deserved it. It was for the good of all)
    This one I spoiled myself on a walkthrough. Given the situation, I killed the walker that bit Sarita for I couldn't risk it.

    EPISODE 4 AMID THE RUINS
    Saved Sarah (After losing Nick (boy that was a buzz kill), I wanted Sarah to survive as well and learn, once again I was proven wrong and wished otherwise later in the game)
    Didn't steal (I'm not sure if Arvo was right about his sister being sick, but from Ep 1, I will not become a thief unless it is necessary)
    Chose to fit through the booth (Initiative, man)
    Held the baby (Nuff said)
    Killed the walker Rebecca (to protect her child. Again, nuff said)

    EPISODE 5 NO GOING BACK (My fav of this season, with A House Divided in at close second, followed by In Harm's Way)
    Went for the baby (The little one in the middle of a crossfire. Had to take the chance)
    Tried to help Luke (Lost so many, I would not allow one more. But of course fate said otherwise. At least he saved Clem, one last time)
    Didn't ask to leave with Mike
    This choice of Kenny and Jane is by far the HARDEST in both seasons of the game. Sure I read what would happen, but it still made me uneasy. Throughout the level, I continued to weigh pros and cons in my head about these two. Then, the final showdown commenced. And finally, I yelled "NO" and shot Kenny. I chose to tell him he would be with his family "You were always...good for a smile". Gets me every time. When finding AJ alive and well, i made an uneasy amends with Jane (NEVER ALONE, NEVER AGAIN) and thus we returned to Howe's.
    Abandoned but still had the fortifications plus the greenhouse was still working. Then, when the family asked for my help, I let them come in. Were they being honest or lying, I don't know but I'm not planning on giving up on humanity, not while there are still good people out there. And I feel proud with this final choice for Clementine "Maybe we can start something here, Jane" and I hope that it will be possible.

    These are my choices and I'm sticking by them.

  • edited February 2015

    Episode 1
    I saved Christa

    I killed the dog

    I accepted Nick's apology

    I gave the dying man water (in my sec playthrough I did not)

    I saved pete(Sec playthrough Nick)

    Episode 2
    I took the blame

    I sat with Luke not really thinking about it much(sec playthrough I sat with Kenny)

    I told the truth

    Walter didn't forgive Nick

    I gave up and went down with Rebecca

    Episode 3
    I helped Sarah

    i told Bonnie about Luke(sec playthrough i did not)

    I didn't say anything

    I watched Kenny kill Carver although in my second playthrough I didn't watch because I didn't want Clem to see that shit.

    I cut Sarita's arm(in my sec playthrough I didn't)

    Episode 4
    I saved Sarah

    I stole his stuff (sec playthrough I didn't cause we didn't use that stuff anyway except for the pain killers)

    I crawled (sec playthrough I let Bonny risk her life not an 11 year old girl)

    I held the baby

    I shot Rebecca

    Episode 5
    I protected the baby(Duh)

    I covered Luke(Going near him would have been illogical)

    Didn't ask to go with Mike

    Let Kenny kill Jane

    Killed Kenny and went alone with the baby through a herd of walkers.(In my second playthrough I didn't kill Kenny and stayed in Wellington because Kenny was done anyway.)

  • All That Remains:

    I saved Christa

    Killed the dog

    Accepted Nick's apology

    Gave water to the dying man

    Saved Nick

    A House Divided:

    Took the blame for Sarah's photo

    Sat with Luke

    Lied to Walter

    Let Walter decide on his own

    Stayed to help Carlos

    In Harm's Way:

    Helped Sarah

    Kept the truth from Bonnie

    Tried to speak up

    Watched Kenny kill Carver

    Chopped off Sarita's arm

    Amid the Ruins:

    Saved Sarah

    Stole from Arvo

    Let Bonnie go through the ticket window

    Held AJ

    Shot Rebecca

    No Going Back:

    Ran to AJ

    Covered Luke

    Asked to leave with Mike

    Shot Kenny

    Alone with AJ

Sign in to comment in this discussion.