Cabin group vs Motel group

Alt text

vs

Alt text

whos better overall in every aspect?

Comments

  • The motel group.

    Honestly, I really din't care so much about the cabin group maybe except Sarah cause some of them felt undeveloped.

  • edited February 2015

    Motel group.They had the best characters.

  • Lol cabin group got such a tiny picture. Clearly the Motel group picture is superior due to it's size and draws more attention, I have to squint to see the Cabin group.

  • Cabin Group

    Even with their lack of development, at the time I remember thinking they were more functional than the Motel Group because everyone in the Cabin Group were friends while the Motel Group weren't on the best terms with each other. Plus the cabin group are truly fab, I have proof!

    Alt text

  • edited February 2015

    Oh god.........I thought it said The Fapin group .....

    Kateis posted: »

    Cabin Group Even with their lack of development, at the time I remember thinking they were more functional than the Motel Group because e

  • edited February 2015

    Lets break it down

    Carlos vs Kenny

    Luke vs Lee

    Nick vs Carley

    Duck vs Sarah

    Clem vs Clem

    rebacca vs catja

    Alvin vs Larry

    who wins?

  • This is a motel?

    Motel group. I love the place they had and all the defenses, and better characters. (Kenny, Lilly, Ben)

  • Lol look at this picture. I don't think it was done on purpose but still... maybe it's not size that matters. Personally I find a Cabin Group a little unfinished while I liked every single characters from the MG. So that's it.

    • I don't like Kenny but can't say he is a worse character than Carlos. Maybe if Genius stayed a little longer...

    • Lol Luke was a boring character imo while Lee was my second favorite

    • Carley is better. Nick didn't have a single line in episode 4 and even before I didn't really care about him.

    • Sarah is better. Duck was just a kid, killed only to make Kenny depressed. Sarah had her whole story.

    • I love both Clems :p A draw.

    • Katjaa vs Rebecca. That one is hard. They are both badass but really different. I'd probably choose Katjaa. Her story is more dramatic and she is one of my favorites.

    • I liked Al but Larry is way better. And that voice acting...

    • I would also add Pete vs Lily, because their are the biggest badasses of their groups. And I don't know who to choose.

    Probably Motel Group won because S1 is way better than S2 :p

    kappafan posted: »

    Lets break it down Carlos vs Kenny Luke vs Lee Nick vs Carley Duck vs Sarah Clem vs Clem rebacca vs catja Alvin vs Larry who wins?

  • Motel. How is this even a question?

  • What had been seen, can not be unseen

    Kateis posted: »

    Cabin Group Even with their lack of development, at the time I remember thinking they were more functional than the Motel Group because e

  • While I have to go with the Cabin just because I found they're story more intresting, Clem and Carley are my two favorites of the series.

  • edited February 2015

    Carlos vs Kenny - Kenny

    Luke vs Lee- Lee

    Nick vs Carley/Doug-Carley/doug

    Duck vs Sarah- Sarah

    Clem vs Clem- Clem

    Rebecca vs Katja- I honestly don't know maybe tie?

    Alvin vs Larry-Alvin( Larry was an asshole)

    Motel group wins.

    kappafan posted: »

    Lets break it down Carlos vs Kenny Luke vs Lee Nick vs Carley Duck vs Sarah Clem vs Clem rebacca vs catja Alvin vs Larry who wins?

  • Motel group.
    It had such wonderful characters like, Lee, Kenny, Carly, Mark, etc.
    The cabin's group, not so much, unless you count Luke and Nick.

  • As much as I love the Cabin Group, I'd have to say the Motel Group, because it had many of the original characters. Lee, Carley, Clementine.. :(

  • Motel because they were actually developed enough IMO

  • development-wise, I would say the motel group was better, but the cabin group seemed more capable of co-surviving

  • Both groups have every role, but looking at the leaders of the groups, motel group wins by a longshot.

    Motel group has Lee, a badass who fought his way through the absolutely unbearable Savannah streets with a meat cleaver and one hand, while dying of blood loss.

    Cabin group has Luke, who, spoiler alert, determinately died because he chose to hug a walker rather than slice it with his fucking machete that he has on him at all times.

    Unless the cabin group has Merle, who fought his way out of Atlanta with one hand, no weapons, and survived, Cabin Group loses.

    Not to mention, the motel group was part of an actual good game, meaning each character was properly developed, and with great themes behind them. Cabin group was part of the worst piece of The Walking Dead franchise, aside from maybe the prison in the comics, or a few of the webisodes (never watched them, so I don't know). This means that the cabin group got next to no development, and had next to no memorable characters.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.