Did Carver and Troy really need to die?

2»

Comments

  • edited March 2015

    I always thought that something like that happened between them...whether it was consensual or not....like when Troy says, "I thought you wanted out of pen, not whatever this sh*t is.."....I interpreted that to mean that they had made deals of a sort in the past, like Molly and Dr. Logan...but either scenario explains why Jane had little remorse for shooting Troy in the genitals and leaving him to die

    but I do agree that they died too soon

    My complaint is that Kenny wasted too much time with his melodramatic bullshit, should have just shot him in the head and called it a day. T

  • LOL yeah, i like, i dont care if Clem gets hit honestly, i dislike her, but killing Walter really made me hate him

    Kennyftw posted: »

    That sealed the deal for you? Seriously? lol I'd figure him throwing a guy off of a roof would do that. Or maybe executing hostages.

  • Carver did; I didn't like what he does to Alvin if you save him at the lodge. Seriously, what was the point of keeping him in your office like that? If you choose to have Clem ask to let him go I believe his answer is "Why would I do that?" That's why I stayed and personally watched his ass die.

    As for Troy, his ass was gonna die anyway, he doesn't seem like the type that'd be competent enough to escape a herd.

  • edited March 2015

    Shooting him in the genitals is probably one of the biggest reasons why I think he did something bad to her, even if rape wasn't it. You don't just shoot someone in the dick because they are an asshole getting in the way of your escape, there was revenge related reasons for her doing that.

    A scenario similar to Molly's situation is probably it, I think I agree there. When Jane was distracting him she was talking about them 'running away together' or whatever. Can't remember the exact quote; but I remember Troy's, "I thought you meant get out of the pen, not whatever this shit is!" So there was definitely some plan between them. I guess I'll have to add it to the long list of 'things I wanted to know about but the writers wouldn't explore it' 3:

    Aerie88 posted: »

    I always thought that something like that happened between them...whether it was consensual or not....like when Troy says, "I thought you wa

Sign in to comment in this discussion.