The Walking Dead Season 2 Critique
goinoutwithabang
Banned
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
goinoutwithabang
Banned
Comments
Alot of people have seen this video and alot of people can agree that season 2 was bad. It had many flaws and all we can hope for is that Season 3 is better.
Goinoutwithabang only joined yesterday o.o he probably didn't know they'd come up before.
Yup,, im just letting him know
It wasn't. But opinions I guess.
This guy was boring to listen to.
"If you aern't convinced by this point that the second season isn't at least mediocre, then God help you because you're fucking wrong."
Yes, because letting people have their own opinions just doesn't exist anymore.
Many have seen it. Anyway Flimsi hit the nail on the head with a lot of reasonable complaints. Season 2 a lot of the time felt more like an early R.L Stein book instead of a game.
I can't get enough of re-watching those two videos.
Flimsii addressed every single problem I had with the season.
Thats why I didnt say everyone. I said alot
Did the video maker actually say that in his video? I wasn't going to watch it before but now I'm definitely not going to. What a self righteous asshole.
Yes he did. Well he is a youtber after all so that kind of attitude is expected unfortunately. I also don't think season 2 is as bad(its not at all, in fact is pretty good) as he is making it out to be
Yeah he didn't say that... I just watched the videos. I recommend you watch them
You do realize that what you just said is an opinion? Because you say it as if it is fact.
Season 2 didn't meet most people's (INCLUDING ME) expectations (plot was messy af, poor character development, cheap death shock value, dull protagonist, choices barely mattered, etc). I was embarrassed playing it, I felt as if it had "failed" twd s2's predecessor. It had flaws that i believe would have Lee turning in his grave...
Like @Only_Jags said, we can only hope for it's successor to be better.
And to everyone saying s2 was "great" well that's your opinion, to me it was the exact opposite. But you have to admit, the VAST majority of people that played TWD games prefer s1 over s2. The ratings make this sorta clear.
He did. Near the end of part 2.
Yes, Sherlock.
k
I like how this guy described season 2 being a shit. No choice in that season matters except the last one. This dude made a lot of good points. I hope Telltale watched this videos.
I hope my opinion didn't offend you or anything...
but if it did, thats not my fault.
But Watson, You want to discredit people's views with your views as if they are facts. So obviously you are not Sherlock Holmes yourself...
Oh.. Well he had some pretty good points but if he said that... That would've made me not like him
But I think he has some valid points but it doesn't seem like he liked the walking dead to begin with.
To be fair, he is right in the regard that most people preferred S1 over S2. However, that doesn't necessarily mean that people didn't like S2 period.
I'd honestly say that a majority people liked S2, but preferred S1 overall. The people that hated it or straight up didn't like it feel like a vocal minority (with all due respect to people that don't like it. I don't mean to marginalize anyone that doesn't, but given the general reviews and reception of S2 across the web, it really doesn't seem like it's the majority consensus.)
But how can season 3 even redeem itself? Clementine is walking around with AJ and there's supposed to be a story after that? How long into the future?
Idk how Clem will make sense surviving in the TWD world after what happened to her in season 2. If molly doesn't come or someone familiar to save the day, like morgan on the show, then idk how it's gonna redeem itself into making sense again
That was on of those endings that I have no idea what they will be able to make something out of it that is realistic and good.
Can't time skip because of that weird The Walking Dead Time Universe rule, that sucks.
I have no idea either.
That's exactly what they should do, and not make the same mistake they did in s2. In s2 there were 5 episodes for the 400 Days characters to return, yet all they got were some shitty cameos. I hope they bring back one of the dlc characters.
That's why I'm kinda disappointed in the whole Michonne thing?
I Read the comics, and after what they did to season 2, if I'm robert kirkman idk if I should trust them to not mess this up, story wise.
Bringing someone back would keep fans into the game also. It wouldn't be looking for the comic book audience but catering to the fans that have already bought their content
Also molly was badass, she's not dead and she has to make a comeback. What if she snuck on the boat hoping to find lee and Clem, and the story ended up being about her and Vernon? There is so much to talk about for the dlc that they could've picked something else.. But no let's take robert kirkmans story and make a game of it.
Theres way they could revive this game, but not with a Michonne dlc. And I love Michonne.
And I'm mad about 400 days because I feel like they probably had something actually planned, but scrapped it. Like the whole last 2 episodes were just.... Dammn
Why would I waste time making decisions for these ppl if they had no way to redeem themselves?
And I just hated Bonnie, why couldn't Vince have been the main one from 400 days? Shit Tavia was really interesting but that is all gone.
Agreed, but I'd rather see Shel get more character development if we had to pick one. I'd like to see her change from keeping the old ways alive to Season 5 Rick. That would've been fun.
That's assuming that Robert and Skybound feel the same way you do about things. Just because you thought S2 wasn't that great doesn't mean they do.
I hope they do... Because if they don't they're gonna waste a really good story that they could release on their own and get much more money from
IMO, 5 episodes aren't enough to have an in depth season. They're still good and fun to play, but having 10 episodes could really build a storyline, character development and give us a great climactic finish. The game would go from roughly 10 hours to 20 hours and they could release 1 episode a month.
10 would be a beautifully made game as long as they don't scrap their story.
At least 7-8 episodes would be nice. It would give a villain more than one episode to have a story and still die
Never said I was, cupcake. Also I'm not discrediting opinions.
Eh, to each their own.
Don't worry it didn't.
Exactly. Carver's death would've had a bigger impact on me if they kept him around longer than 2 episodes. If Season Two was a 10 episode season, then Carver could've been around from Episode 2 - Episode 7, and Episode 8 - 10 could've been about Clem's group surviving on the road.
Oh I know alot of people prefer S1 over S2. I wasn't saying he was wrong.
They won't.
On my first playthrough I was really hoping to get along with carver. I actually agreed with him somewhat, and I hoped that I could get him to like Clementine. I kinda liked Troy too, well if he didn't hit me and all.
I was hoping that I would get some time to learn more about carver and what happened to their safe place after 400 days. That's why we need at least 8 episodes
Lmao and then you'll hear things from telltale like
"We did this for our fans"
Any dumbass with a camera... I guess.