Why cutting Saritas arm is better.

edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
So, I am reading a lot of guys saying that the best choice would have killing the walker, but we cant be sure about that. We dont know the time that needs to pass before you transform into a walker, but lats take Lee, we cant say for sure how much time passed since he was bitten and we cut his arm(if you did) but at the end Lee still died, so we kill the walker instead of chopping off saritas arm, but we need time to get out of there, think what to do find a clean weapon and cut off her arm. Reggie said his arm was cut off imediatly. So since we dont know the exact time it would be too risky killing the zombie first then cutting her arm, this im my opinion, what do you guys think?

Comments

  • edited May 2014
    Cutting off arm walker's blood will go into the bloodstream,
    Kill the Walker biting Arm, not much supply to stop bleeding or separated, either way, Sarita is fucked
  • Yes, but we don't know if it's carried through blood. Characters have gotten blood in their mouths and such before in the ocmics and TV Series. It would appear as if the virus is only spread through saliva.
    Gayman111 posted: »

    Cutting off arm walker's blood will go into the bloodstream, Kill the Walker biting Arm, not much supply to stop bleeding or separated, either way, Sarita is fucked

  • Well, the bloodloss will do her in.

    If only there were juice boxes left. Who needs blood when you've got juice?
  • I don't think the issue with Lee if you cut off his arm was the amount of time you waited. I thought his death was accounted for by the blood loss as a result.
  • I don't think the walker virus is spread through walker blood, it spreads through saliva.

    I know they have gotten cuts and open wounds and then kill a zombie and then the blood splatters (on the wound)
    And in the show, when Hershel got bit rick and rick cut it off, he used an axe that was used to kill zombies before, and he lived.

    Although I still think sarita will die either way because she is in the middle of a horde armless. she is going to bleed out FAST.
  • I don't think that's what cn kill you. I think its the saliva
    Gayman111 posted: »

    Cutting off arm walker's blood will go into the bloodstream, Kill the Walker biting Arm, not much supply to stop bleeding or separated, either way, Sarita is fucked

  • Stap reminding us of Lee, our kokoro still not ready for it yet
    Chocolates posted: »

    I don't think the issue with Lee if you cut off his arm was the amount of time you waited. I thought his death was accounted for by the blood loss as a result.

  • Well, I did cut off her arm. If you'd leave the arm, she'd die for sure. And honestly, I didn't want to give her the chance to decide to keep her limb, like Pete did.

    In the world of the Walking Dead there are enough examples of people surviving a bite by aputating the bitten limb. With luck, that bite made her determinant und by chopping the arm off, she'll be around longer :)
  • well because it was a short period of time since the zombie bite Sarita so she might not turn. this thing with zombie blood on Clementine's blade, it doesn't seem to be in the video game version, maybe tell-tale is adding that into now.
  • edited May 2014
    How the hell is she going to live with that arm? No way.

    Blade is dirty. Walker blood doesn't infect, but that doesn't make it any less unsanitary or dangerous.

    She's losing a lot more blood than when the walker bit her.

    She screamed on the top of her lungs. She's a dinner bell for more walkers.

    I'll be the first to admit that I chopped her arm off, but really I just panicked.
  • Exactly. Cutting her arm off is just as risky, if not more.

    How the hell is she going to live with that arm? No way. Blade is dirty. Walker blood doesn't infect, but that doesn't make it any le

  • Or the nasty bugs that gets created when a dead body starts decaying goes into the living being and kills them but the actual virus is already in the Brain lying dormant that's why if someone dies from natural causes they will come back as a walker
    Zyphon posted: »

    Yes, but we don't know if it's carried through blood. Characters have gotten blood in their mouths and such before in the ocmics and TV Series. It would appear as if the virus is only spread through saliva.

  • For a second there I thought you said "SLAP reminding us of Lee"
    Gayman111 posted: »

    Stap reminding us of Lee, our kokoro still not ready for it yet

  • She's gonna die anyway.
  • This is a spoiler, friend. Please mark it as such.
  • Well, there's that part, but whatever stronger "alive" version of the virus that the walkers spread through saliva probably isn't spread through blood.
    Dan26Shake posted: »

    Or the nasty bugs that gets created when a dead body starts decaying goes into the living being and kills them but the actual virus is already in the Brain lying dormant that's why if someone dies from natural causes they will come back as a walker

  • Knowing Telltale, it's pretty likely.
    Gary-Oak posted: »

    She's gonna die anyway.

  • I just cut off her arm because it was fun ! :D fucked or not ! i don't give a rat's ass about sarita but i hope she lives for kenny's sake
  • edited May 2014
    It certainly made him weaker but it was the virus that killed him, you can see that from how the got weaker and weaker / started coughing and having a very weak voice.
    Chocolates posted: »

    I don't think the issue with Lee if you cut off his arm was the amount of time you waited. I thought his death was accounted for by the blood loss as a result.

  • Welcome to Lee's school of do it yourself surgery
    Courses include but are not limited to:
    Amputating your own limbs with an fainted teenager on the floor
    Sowing up your arm when all you have is a sowing needle and fishing line
    Amputating your friends limbs in the middle of a walker hoard
    I look forward to seeing you all in next weeks class when we learn how to preform a c section with a dirty machete and a lighter
  • yeah, but we dont know how much time it takes

    well because it was a short period of time since the zombie bite Sarita so she might not turn. this thing with zombie blood on Clementine's blade, it doesn't seem to be in the video game version, maybe tell-tale is adding that into now.

  • both occasions are risky but in the heat of the moment I think cutting her arm would be better
    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    Exactly. Cutting her arm off is just as risky, if not more.

  • edited May 2014
    Sarita will die either way. She has been doomed by the writers.

    But if you cut off her arm, she'll probably die due to bloodloss or a festering wound and Kenny might blame you for her death.
  • I agree, she's gonna die either way. But at least by cutting off her arm you gave her a chance.
  • correct we don't.
    Kbkristi posted: »

    yeah, but we dont know how much time it takes

  • On my first playthrough, Sarita's Macbeth shriek lingered and I thought it was a truly shocking cliffhanger that left me desperate to find out what happens next.

    Then I thought about it.

    She's kinda screwed no matter what.

    Logically, she should die in the beginning of Episode 4 for a variety of common sense. If she doesn't pass out from the pain and blood loss, no one is going to be able to carry her long enough to make it out of the herd; the fact she'll be screaming and stricken with unholy panic is going to draw more walkers into taking a bite out of her. And even if she somehow does manage to make it out of the herd, there's no Carlos around to see her medically fit.

    So, thinking about it, I think the end scene of In Harm's Way was designed to test your instincts and provide a bit of gratuity. Sarita's got 99 problems, and a happy ending ain't one.
  • edited May 2014
    I dont think Kenny would blame us
    EmperorZorn posted: »

    Sarita will die either way. She has been doomed by the writers. But if you cut off her arm, she'll probably die due to bloodloss or a festering wound and Kenny might blame you for her death.

  • down would be to develop a diet program that most useful fits you. A great diet plan must make the most of genetics and also other gender-based specification in order that they works as designed. Consequently, there needs to be diets for men and diets for women which make an effort to meet up with the same objectives but utilize the full difference in human anatomy processes between gents and ladies to ultimately achieve the goals.

    http://amazinggarciniatry.com/
  • dafuq did i just read
    OSict4285 posted: »

    down would be to develop a diet program that most useful fits you. A great diet plan must make the most of genetics and also other gender-ba

  • Well, following his development I think TTG wants him to mentally snap at some point.
    Losing Sarita, his "replacement" for Katjaa might trigger just that.
    Kbkristi posted: »

    I dont think Kenny would blame us

  • That.

    Sarita won't make it. Kenny is going to snap.
    Let's hope there are no saltlicks in Wellington...

    On my first playthrough, Sarita's Macbeth shriek lingered and I thought it was a truly shocking cliffhanger that left me desperate to find o

  • He might lose it,but still I dont think he would blame us, I think he would have done the same thing if he was in our place
    EmperorZorn posted: »

    Well, following his development I think TTG wants him to mentally snap at some point. Losing Sarita, his "replacement" for Katjaa might trigger just that.

  • If you cut off her arm, she is fucked a 100%, because of the walker blood. Thats a fact and walker blood is confirmed to infect you if it gets in contact with your body fluids. If you chose not to, there is still a tiny chance that you can cut it off later with a clean weapon in time. Although i doubt it. I think she is going to die either way
  • If Sarita miraculously defies logic and survives the herd, I'd imagine one of the decisions forced upon the player would be to hack or not to hack off the rest of Sarita's arm. Which may drive her way over the bend and cause her to off herself.
    booki94 posted: »

    If you cut off her arm, she is fucked a 100%, because of the walker blood. Thats a fact and walker blood is confirmed to infect you if it ge

  • I cut her arm off because it's the only way she'd stand a chance of living, but it's far from a big chance. I stand by my decision but I sense a Duck moment coming...
Sign in to comment in this discussion.