What is one choice...
that you always pick? No matter how many times you replay it, you always pick that decision. For me, its side with Kenny about Duck, don't kill the brothers in front of Clementine and shoot Duck. In s2, I always help Christa, sit with Kenny, watch Carver's death, and hold the baby.
How about you? What decisions do you always pick?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Leave Lee's arm uncut.
I would always save Carley.
Well when I play through an episode again, I always make the same choices. I go on the on YouTube and look alternate choices for an episode.
Nate- Should we just kill these folks and take all their stuff?
Russell- Uhhhh.
I like Nate
Vince- Fuck Wall Street.
Clem- Let's take them.
Clem- Shut up, Nick.
Clem- I want to stay with you and Kenny.
Lee- You got this. You got this, mother fucker.
Wyatt- Are you fucking serious?
Clem- That's none of your business.
Lost my temper with Kenny, tbh I keep accidentally doing this xd
Walt will never let Nick die for me.
Even though i wanted Kenny to be by my side, i could never bring myself to smash Larry's head against Lilly's will. Especially knowing he may not be dead.
Will never ever help to kill Larry, it was pretty clear to me that he was still alive. And if you watch really closely, you can even see him breathe if you try and save him.
It may sound silly and stupid, but i always kill Sam. I can't stand seeing animals suffer
Now that you mentioned it, i always shot Duck too. When i replay the episodes i mostly try to change only the choices i found ''unsatisfying''. (Ex: When i played episode 4, in the tent i told Kenny Rebecca needed him for the labor. When i replayed it, i picked the ''i had to shoot Lee'' option, and i thought it was cooler.)
Not at all. That choice is 110% certainty for me.
I always cut off Lee's arm (I don't know why, it's a pretty gruesome fucking scene), I never kill the brothers, I can't steal from the car, I have to kill Duck and the boy in the attic, and I don't know why either, but I can't have Clem kill me.
I always choose to leave the group when Clem and Lee are making their plan on the train.
Ask Christa and Omid to take care of Clem.
And always take Clem with me to Crawford,
I know it says one choice, but you also said "decisions", so make way for the fun train...
Season 1:
Always try to save Larry. By extension, I always fight Kenny on the train. My philosophy when I'm replaying these episodes is to play out the best story from my point of view, and I love the whole dynamic of tension between former friends growing so much that they finally have it out, kinda like Rick and Shane. From there, it can go either way whether I become a bro to Kenny or tell him to piss off. Usually, I'll be his friend after the earlier tension has worn off.
Always kill the St. Johns.
Always threaten Vernon and the patients. Asshole Lee is too badass and hilarious not to.
Always tell Clementine the story of Lee's brother. Don't know why, I just like that one the best. Bud sounded like a cool dude.
Not really "always" with this one, but 9 times out of 10 I'll keep Lee's arm. The glass shard moment adds a lot to the final march.
Again, a 9 times out of 10 choice to let Ben fall from the tower in Crawford. One of the saddest deaths in the game and in my opinion, a lot sadder than the determinant Kenny scene that comes if you save him, simply because my issues with the writing keep getting in the way. I'm an asshole even when I'm playing the game, you see. :P
400 Days:
Always leave Roman's camp. Shel will never kill her girlfriend in my playthroughs. :P
Always shoot Justin, just because, all respect to Danny's actor, but he doesn't portray pain very well at all. Justin's is much more convincing.
Always go outside (when the game lets me, that is -_-) of the car with Wyatt. The sequence in the fog is way cooler than the car.
Always take Nate's gun and then aim at him to "catch him with his balls out".
Season 2:
Always kill Sam.
Always threaten Rebecca.
Always leave Sarah behind, even though I'm personally against it, because in terms of the story and the writing, her first death comes with lots of reflection on her and a chance to defend her against Jane, not to mention Rebecca's reaction later. It all works together to actually communicate a sense of loss which isn't present in her second death. I still think it was bullshit, but it's a much more satisfying death scene.
A part of me wants to always let Nick die in episode 2 now that I know there's no point in bringing him along, and Clementine awkwardly hitting Walter is the best. :P But I think Nick's genuine confession and apology, and Walter's awesomeness in saving his life despite what he did is much more satisfying story wise. Too bad what we get later is... well, yeah.
Always cut Sarita's arm, because it doesn't make Kenny look like a total idiot when he gets mad at Clem, and Gavin's delivery of Kenny's lines during the horde was fucking amazing, even though I don't know why the walkers didn't just converge on him right then and there.
Oh, and let's not forget- shot Okay, I'm done.
How did he respond on that
Yeah for the badass glass shard scene.
Giving Clementine food in Episode two of Season one. No matter who else I give food to, Clementine always eats first!
Yep! So true. I always give her an apple. That's a cute picture by the way, did you draw it?
Saving Ben. Though I've never actually replayed the game, I'd just feel like such a scumbag letting him die. It would be the same with getting Walter to forgive Nick and saving Sarah.
One choice I honestly can't bring myself to choose is telling Clementine her parents are dead in S1. Just can't do it.
Thanks! I wish I could draw like that, my freind posted it on Tumblr and I thought it was great! Not sure if she drew it or not though... Ahah
''I don't need to hear this shit. I can't even look at you right now.''
I believe it depends how your relationship was with him in S1
I always uhh... Kill the Stranger. <.<
I doubt it. Me and Kenny had a good relationship back in S1, and even if we didn't, why would it have anything to do with Clem?
I always help kill Larry
Saving Larry, I always loved that old man, even though he treated me like dirt. I called him dad.
Always let Clementine shoot me, can think of Lee's turning....and it makes sense for Clementine's character in season 2.
none.... i try to pick against my natural inclination on replays so i can see the different dialogue.... while the ultimate outcomes don't change, sometimes a small tweak in a choice can have a drastic effect (ending in your untimely death because you said/didn't say something)
Giving Clem, Duck and Ben food. (All 3 are kids and Ben must've been starving.
Killing the Stranger
Refuse to steal from the station wagon.
Losing temper with Kenny
Beat up Kenny in train
Oh... NO!
Well Lee and Kenny BBF I saw somebody on Youtube that got a different calm reaction
Lee: PUT THE GUN DOWN BITCH
Not robbing the car in episode 2 of Season 1, in the desperate futile hope that I can stop the Stranger from wrecking havoc.
I always pick to save Shawn over Duck and I always choose to leave at night...I always save Doug and I always leave both Andy and Danny St.John for dead and not kill them.
For season 2 I always pinkie swear with Sarah and always am nice when talking with Carlos, Sarah, Rebecca, Alvin, Walter. And I always go with Pete at the end of episode 1. There's a lot more but I can't be bothered to remember and I'm still playing through season 2 again.
Larry was exactly like my dad and they both passed due to heart problems. (Well I think Larry mainly died bc of salt lick but still :P)
Only one choice? Hm...
[Save Ben]
If you have a link, i'd love to be proven wrong. =p
Shooting Beatrice.