If you're worthy of Janes time she might just teach you the tricks to be badass (The walker guts, the knee trick, versatility not overrated, etc.) Molly on the other hand probably had years of parkour before the apocalypse started and it'd be very hard to learn from her.
I absolutley hate the character of Molly, and for me Jane is Molly 2.0.
The whole series is based on how hard it is for everyone to survive, and that they are in fact normal people. Then a Mary-Sue-character comes along and ruins this illusion.
She would've belonged in Assassin's Creed, not The Walking Dead.
And Jane...I don't know why, but I like her more. I can understand her better, even if that may sound weird now.
But seriously, Telltale...don't give us another over-the-top badass female character that has lost a sister and now is depressed about it and lacks self confidence because of it, who also seems to be a master intruder and a badass fighter and is tough and shit for Season 3.
Actually, Jane's mistake with Luke made her more likable in my books. Sure, it was reckless and stupid, but it made her a little human, not like Molly 1.0.
People are really going with Molly? Molly's a pretty big Mary Sue.
It has nothing to do with her looks for me, it has to do if i can trust her enough not to leave in the middle of the night, without saying goodbye.
I trust Molly more than I trust Jane. Plus Molly is actually sort of funny warm and inviting unlike Jane. She seems like a Molly copy paste but is purely cold.
Attractiveness and gender doesn't really have anything to do with it.
It's about a flawless character... in a bad way, I mean. A character written with no particular faults or weaknesses. Molly can outfight a grown man with military training with her hyper-realistic ninja skills, she's always got a cool line, and she barely fucks up.
You took the words right out of my mouth EpicMustacheGuy.
At least Jane feels more real and human. Molly was the typical video game badass female power fantasy, every interaction with this "blonde ninja with a mouth" completely broke my immersion and made me feel I was rather caught back in your average 21st century action movie/TV show with mandatory mouthy strong female character.
At first I got the same feeling from Jane, but her skills made sense, were more balanced and were justified. She developed them through experience, you can understand where they come from, and she shares them, they can be learned and trained.
Molly "I'm defying gravity"'s ninja powers were completely forced : teleportation from behind the counter (won't see her do even if her only possible way of escape was definitely in your field of view all the time), also Telltale made sure she would beat most players by giving her fight the most difficult QTE of all the game.. Talk about forcing respect for a character instead of making this character earn this respect. Her superior agility is never explained, it's shoven down your throat. It has no other justification than the desire of writers to make her look cool.
Jane feels human, Molly feels pure video game character.
Ant that's why I would choose Jane over Molly any time if presented with this choice. (but Molly died in my season one anyway)
I absolutley hate the character of Molly, and for me Jane is Molly 2.0.
The whole series is based on how hard it is for everyone to survi… moreve, and that they are in fact normal people. Then a Mary-Sue-character comes along and ruins this illusion.
She would've belonged in Assassin's Creed, not The Walking Dead.
And Jane...I don't know why, but I like her more. I can understand her better, even if that may sound weird now.
But seriously, Telltale...don't give us another over-the-top badass female character that has lost a sister and now is depressed about it and lacks self confidence because of it, who also seems to be a master intruder and a badass fighter and is tough and shit for Season 3.
Actually, Jane's mistake with Luke made her more likable in my books. Sure, it was reckless and stupid, but it made her a little human, not like Molly 1.0.
Attractiveness and gender doesn't really have anything to do with it.
It's about a flawless character... in a bad way, I mean. A characte… morer written with no particular faults or weaknesses. Molly can outfight a grown man with military training with her hyper-realistic ninja skills, she's always got a cool line, and she barely fucks up.
You took the words right out of my mouth EpicMustacheGuy.
At least Jane feels more real and human. Molly was the typical video game badas… mores female power fantasy, every interaction with this "blonde ninja with a mouth" completely broke my immersion and made me feel I was rather caught back in your average 21st century action movie/TV show with mandatory mouthy strong female character.
At first I got the same feeling from Jane, but her skills made sense, were more balanced and were justified. She developed them through experience, you can understand where they come from, and she shares them, they can be learned and trained.
Molly "I'm defying gravity"'s ninja powers were completely forced : teleportation from behind the counter (won't see her do even if her only possible way of escape was definitely in your field of view all the time), also Telltale made sure she would beat most players by giving her fight the most difficult QTE of all … [view original content]
I'm not confused, I draw a logical conclusion from her situation at the end of my play. Shot in the shoulder, bleeding, chased after by zombies having left her beloved pickaxe and only weapon behind her... Even if she escaped the zombies (and that's a big deal, even with her ninja powers, she was in an even more difficult situation than Kenny's who was not wounded), she bled to death or died from infection - every single usable medical supply available in Crawford had been taken by us, and several times it had been made a point that the rest of Savannah had been cleared clean of anything worthy of interest for survival purpose.
I'm not confused, I draw a logical conclusion from her situation at the end of my play. Shot in the shoulder, bleeding, chased after by zomb… moreies having left her beloved pickaxe and only weapon behind her... Even if she escaped the zombies (and that's a big deal, even with her ninja powers, she was in an even more difficult situation than Kenny's who was not wounded), she bled to death or died from infection - every single usable medical supply available in Crawford had been taken by us, and several times it had been made a point that the rest of Savannah had been cleared clean of anything worthy of interest for survival purpose.
Love both but Molly. Jane put the group in danger by having sex with Luke instead of helping with Rebecca who was in labor. Plus I hate how she was ragging on Rebecca about being pregnant and then having unprotected sex.
Yes, but she wouldn't exist IRL. She's far from realistic. It's like choosing between a laser cannon that can insta kill hundreds of zombies in seconds, or a shotgun. Like, I'd want the laser cannon, but why the hell would I have a laser cannon in The Walking Dead? It doesn't fit. I should be using the shotugn.
Exactly! Who wouldn't want a perfect teammate who literally so good at everything that she's not realistic at all? Also, laser cannon confirmed for S3.
Yes, but she wouldn't exist IRL. She's far from realistic. It's like choosing between a laser cannon that can insta kill hundreds of zombies… more in seconds, or a shotgun. Like, I'd want the laser cannon, but why the hell would I have a laser cannon in The Walking Dead? It doesn't fit. I should be using the shotugn.
Not really true. People have died in Season 2, and Clem was indirectly responsible for quite a few of them. I mean, Lee was kind of the same if you rule out his past like you're doing with Clementine. Lee was flawed BECAUSE of his past, and he can make "perfect" decisions to make up for it. Or, he could make more immoral decisions (Drop Ben? Kill the St Johns?).
On top of indirectly getting people killed, Clementine also has the choice to make immoral decisions (Leaving Sarah is immoral in some contexts, and watching Carver die isn't exactly a humane decision).
Thank you. And, I think it's because I have a younger sister & I would of tried to do everything I could to protect her like Molly did with hers whereas Jane did the opposite in the end. Also, Hilda is a lot more cooler than Jane's silly nail file.
How is helping Clem & the others many times is unreliable? do you even read the lines? she said she left Jamie because it's what Jamie's want,I swear you Kenny fans always pick on the most ridiculous mistake & like a hate insect swarming from one character to another that conflicted with the "almighty" Kenny.
Jane ditched the group because she was afraid that it will fall. Molly left the group because she didn't want to take place on the boat and … moremake the group throw out someone. Pretty different reasons, huh? Jane is not reliable. She is running like a rat from the sinking ship. Is there a chance that she won't leave your group when shit will hit the fan? Molly is more selfless. I believe that she'll always have your back. She even fought till the end to save her sister, while Jane abandoned Jamie.
Oh, and ice pick is more useful than a nail file.
Comments
great picture
I personally love Molly's character and I really liked having her around. She's a badass parkour ninja. What's not to like?
That's An Easy Choice. Molly.
Molly.
Jane Is Just Wrong In Many Ways... I Mean She'd Rather Have Sex Than Pay Attention To Walkers.
If you're worthy of Janes time she might just teach you the tricks to be badass (The walker guts, the knee trick, versatility not overrated, etc.) Molly on the other hand probably had years of parkour before the apocalypse started and it'd be very hard to learn from her.
wow the voting results is heavy in favor for molly
Molly with Hilda.
Molly wouldn't just leave in the middle of the night without saying...
[Rewinds to Season 1]
Then again...
Molly, she seems more trustworthy than Jane.
I would say Molly, she was awesome, had a purpose and didn't fuck another group member.
Molly.
People are really going with Molly? Molly's a pretty big Mary Sue.
I absolutley hate the character of Molly, and for me Jane is Molly 2.0.
The whole series is based on how hard it is for everyone to survive, and that they are in fact normal people. Then a Mary-Sue-character comes along and ruins this illusion.
She would've belonged in Assassin's Creed, not The Walking Dead.
And Jane...I don't know why, but I like her more. I can understand her better, even if that may sound weird now.
But seriously, Telltale...don't give us another over-the-top badass female character that has lost a sister and now is depressed about it and lacks self confidence because of it, who also seems to be a master intruder and a badass fighter and is tough and shit for Season 3.
Actually, Jane's mistake with Luke made her more likable in my books. Sure, it was reckless and stupid, but it made her a little human, not like Molly 1.0.
You chose Jane
(?) Luke supports your choice.
It has nothing to do with her looks for me, it has to do if i can trust her enough not to leave in the middle of the night, without saying goodbye.
Regardless both of them had sex but I choose Molly.
Uh, what? Do you know what "Mary Sue" means?
Attractive perfect woman?
Molly no doubt.
I trust Molly more than I trust Jane. Plus Molly is actually sort of funny warm and inviting unlike Jane. She seems like a Molly copy paste but is purely cold.
Attractiveness and gender doesn't really have anything to do with it.
It's about a flawless character... in a bad way, I mean. A character written with no particular faults or weaknesses. Molly can outfight a grown man with military training with her hyper-realistic ninja skills, she's always got a cool line, and she barely fucks up.
You took the words right out of my mouth EpicMustacheGuy.
At least Jane feels more real and human. Molly was the typical video game badass female power fantasy, every interaction with this "blonde ninja with a mouth" completely broke my immersion and made me feel I was rather caught back in your average 21st century action movie/TV show with mandatory mouthy strong female character.
At first I got the same feeling from Jane, but her skills made sense, were more balanced and were justified. She developed them through experience, you can understand where they come from, and she shares them, they can be learned and trained.
Molly "I'm defying gravity"'s ninja powers were completely forced : teleportation from behind the counter (won't see her do even if her only possible way of escape was definitely in your field of view all the time), also Telltale made sure she would beat most players by giving her fight the most difficult QTE of all the game.. Talk about forcing respect for a character instead of making this character earn this respect. Her superior agility is never explained, it's shoven down your throat. It has no other justification than the desire of writers to make her look cool.
Jane feels human, Molly feels pure video game character.
Ant that's why I would choose Jane over Molly any time if presented with this choice. (but Molly died in my season one anyway)
Like Clementine?
Clementine basically kills Lee by listening to the stranger. So nah. Not really.
Yeah, but she's a boring character. She doesn't feel real. She doesn't fit with the other characters.
I am referring to season 2 clementine.
[removed]
BUT because of that, she'd be better to have irl.
She never dies! Seriously, it's been two years since the episode was released and people still get confused about that? ;-;
I'm not confused, I draw a logical conclusion from her situation at the end of my play. Shot in the shoulder, bleeding, chased after by zombies having left her beloved pickaxe and only weapon behind her... Even if she escaped the zombies (and that's a big deal, even with her ninja powers, she was in an even more difficult situation than Kenny's who was not wounded), she bled to death or died from infection - every single usable medical supply available in Crawford had been taken by us, and several times it had been made a point that the rest of Savannah had been cleared clean of anything worthy of interest for survival purpose.
...she still got have gotten "lucky"... Inb4 Molly shows up in the next season with a beard.
Love both but Molly. Jane put the group in danger by having sex with Luke instead of helping with Rebecca who was in labor. Plus I hate how she was ragging on Rebecca about being pregnant and then having unprotected sex.
Molly way hotter
Yes, but she wouldn't exist IRL. She's far from realistic. It's like choosing between a laser cannon that can insta kill hundreds of zombies in seconds, or a shotgun. Like, I'd want the laser cannon, but why the hell would I have a laser cannon in The Walking Dead? It doesn't fit. I should be using the shotugn.
Exactly! Who wouldn't want a perfect teammate who literally so good at everything that she's not realistic at all? Also, laser cannon confirmed for S3.
Not really true. People have died in Season 2, and Clem was indirectly responsible for quite a few of them. I mean, Lee was kind of the same if you rule out his past like you're doing with Clementine. Lee was flawed BECAUSE of his past, and he can make "perfect" decisions to make up for it. Or, he could make more immoral decisions (Drop Ben? Kill the St Johns?).
On top of indirectly getting people killed, Clementine also has the choice to make immoral decisions (Leaving Sarah is immoral in some contexts, and watching Carver die isn't exactly a humane decision).
after a whole day with 133 votes 79% goes towards molly.
78% for molly after 144 votes
Thank you.
And, I think it's because I have a younger sister & I would of tried to do everything I could to protect her like Molly did with hers whereas Jane did the opposite in the end. Also, Hilda is a lot more cooler than Jane's silly nail file. 
How is helping Clem & the others many times is unreliable? do you even read the lines? she said she left Jamie because it's what Jamie's want,I swear you Kenny fans always pick on the most ridiculous mistake & like a hate insect swarming from one character to another that conflicted with the "almighty" Kenny.