Has your Clem Killed with intent?
In Season One and Two Clem can kill. Other than Lee, Has your Clem killed another survivor? Or are you trying to avoid it for as long as possible?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
In Season One and Two Clem can kill. Other than Lee, Has your Clem killed another survivor? Or are you trying to avoid it for as long as possible?
Comments
I'm trying to avoid it. i want Clem to keep her humanity.
Yes. In season 1 she killed the stranger.
In season 2 she killed Kenny.
In both cases she wasn't killing out of malice. I can't think of anybody else.
Well Clem sort of kills Winston, doesn't she?
I don't remember if she shot the stranger or not, I think Lee choked him in the playthrough I use to import into season 2.
Regardless, I try to keep Clem from harming other living beings unless it's for the sake of them not turning.
Anyone who shot Kenny.
My Clementine shot the stranger.
Definitely.
She fed Winston to the zombies. She allowed Victor's last moments to be more painful than necessary. She took pleasure in Carver's mutilation. And she allowed Jane to be killed and then murdered Kenny herself.
No regrets.
High 5, bro.
YOLO
Winston?
Jesus man.
I can tell you, that goes against everything I had Lee try to teach her, in my game.
I had him teach her that killing was always bad, even if it's necessary.
You don't know his name?
The Lee I know put down a dead man to protect the group, murdered two worthless cannibals, blew out the brains of multiple bandits, and strangled Clementine's kidnapper before her eyes and deliberately left him to reanimate out of spite.
That, along with Christa summarily executing the bully who killed Omid, has taught Clementine that it's okay to kill people if they deliberately hurt her or her loved ones. And in the end, one needs to be strong enough to put down their enemies while still holding compassion for those who most need it. It isn't actually contradictory for Clem to be both a kind and loving girl and a ruthless killer, as Lee Everett was the same kind of person.
"Pulling the trigger of a gun, Ending a life, You feel yourself lose something every time.. The first time the most" - Lee Everett
I'm trying to avoid it unless it is absolutely necessary otherwise Clem won't be Clem anymore, She will lose who she is.
Oh my Lee did help keep Larry from re-animating.
And he did kill Danny St John, but not Andy, since that's what Andy wanted.
(And plus that, with Jolene killed by Danny, Mark brutally murdered, Danny killed, and Brenda being bit by an re-animated Mark, I did not want anymore damage to be done. So I had Lee spare Andy. As well as having Lee refuse to loot the station wagon.)
And he did also strangle the stranger.
But even after all that, I still wanted Lee to teach Clementine that killing is a very serious thing.
That it's not something to take lightly. Even when it's in self-defense, or in defense of a loved one who's life is in danger, it's still very serious.
And I had Clementine be that kind of person.
Though I had her approve of Carver's demise, and after all he did Carver deserved to die, though I did not have Clementine stay and watch.
I did have her put down a re-animated Rebecca, as it needed to be done.
I had her try to save Luke.
And I had Clementine support Kenny, and have his back when Jane tried to pull her crazy, selfish stunt.
As well as leaving Wellington with Kenny.
Just as Lee did, my Clementine only kills in self-defence and doesn't believe in killing the defenceless and helpless, and not in an act of revenge unless it's in extreme cases when it involves the death of a loved one and the killer appears to be remorseless.
I didn't exactly treat Clem's mostly indirect methods of killing of people lightly either. Winston was a genuine threat to her safety, Victor had intentionally attacked her mother figure and possibly murdered her all because he wanted Clementine's supplies, Carver was an utter monster who Clementine would have been happy to shoot herself, and she had grown frightened of both Jane & Kenny's instability. I think, however, that Telltale is trying to characterize her as someone who kills to protect rather than she wants to - that's why she doesn't murder Jane even after realizing she had provoked Kenny into a fight.
And just a note about Andy: Telltale, apparently wanting to make our consciences easier, implies heavily that Andy would have died anyway even if you hadn't directly killed him. In fact, getting eaten alive would probably have been a slower and more painful death than getting shot or electrocuted!
Well she can just straight up shoot Kenny in the head out of anger.
Calm down.
No need to get belligerent.
Anger? It was more like killing the a monster he became.
Yes "anger" if you chose to straight up shoot Kenny in the head you were either angry that he killed Jane or you were angry at what he had become. No doubt that is one of the rare options to straight up just shoot someone with malice.
Nope, nope. Leaving aside your whole Kenny is a moster bullshit, watch that scene again, taking note of Clem´s face. She is clearly angered.
If this isn't angry I don't know what is...
She's crying, looks like she clearly regrets it.
Far as I'm concerned, she was doing it to protect herself. It's up to you whether she and the baby are safer on their own, or with adults who have proven themselves to be unstable or untrustworthy.
And? She is also clearly angry.
I play her same way I played Lee, She doesn't attempt to kill unless in self defense (as a last resort) or out of mercy.
That's his most famous quote
I to got that impression about Andy.
However, I decided that I wasn't going to stoop to that level.
And thus I reflected that in Lee, by sparing him.
I figured: "Yeah Andy will probably die, but I don't have to be the one to do it."
When exactly did Lee say that?
I don't remember him saying that.
I do remember him saying: "Killing changes you, and I don't want you getting use to it."
I'n my first playthrough she killed the stranger,but then my save fucked up and had to play it all again and this time Lee killed the stranger.
He says it when he tells Clementine that killing is never a good thing. Your quote is when you tell her not to shoot him.
More like sad about what Kenny became.
More like anger.
Seriously.
Look at the image and tell me you don´t see anger.
Really?
I do remember him saying: "Killing is bad no matter what."
Is your quote from a different dialogue choice?
It's been so long since I've played TWD, or any game for that matter, that I don't remember.
Been busy doing stuff.
Winston says that over and over again, it's something people associate Winston with.
I taught her to be ruthless even if that means killing someone with intent, The world works differently now. But i tried to maintain some compassion in her and counterbalance the ruthlessness... For example making her the swing in Season 1 and not letting her suffer with loneliness or hunger. Couldn't bear to see her get hurt or took advantage of, so i taught her harsh survival lessons but to maintain some of her innocence.
Didn't remember that.
Haven't played since the last episode.
Not really a gamer.
I like to do more hands-on and active things.
Like hiking, fishing, bike riding, ( both bicycles and motorcycles), and alike.
I know mentioning that about myself might seem strange.
But I say it proudly.
As it's part of who I am as a person.
Yeah... I can see the rage radiating out of those tears.
No really a gamer, but you like this game enougth to be in this forum.
...
...
...
Her expression. Look at her expression.
Also, people also cry in anger not just in sadness.
No, though EP5 of Season 2 gave me my cake. Behind a goddamned see-through diamond wall of Story.