Would you save Sarah or Jane?
If you had to choose between saving Sarah or saving Jane, who would you choose?
Personally, I'd choose Sarah. She's a wonderful, caring human being who'd never hurt anybody, no matter how angry she gets.
I'd happily leave Jane to die, as she's a dumb person with no morals, and even looks like a monkey 
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Sarah, because she's caring and I like her more, and if possible I would teach her to be stronger.
Sarah.
[removed]
Sarah without a doubt.
Sarah, because she's known Clementine longer and they were friends in my playthrough ;_; that and I'd want Clem to help her get over the death of her dad and toughen her up...also! Under no circumstances will Sarah go playing the game of "hide da baby," and result in her taking part to a fight to the death.
Sorry Jane XD you can take care of yourself lady.
Sarah.
Sarah
I would let the game choose for me
Sarah for me.
Sarah.
Jane is not who Clementine wants to be with, even if she understands why she is who she is.
I'd save Sarah.
I'd save Sarah because my Clem became her friend and we know her more than Jane.
Sarah 100%
Wow, I wonder if the developers realized this when they chose to do what they did.
Jane.. I only picked her could no one else did lol
Without a doubt Sarah. Jane lost the little respect I had for her when Episode 5 came out.
Sarah.
I like your username.
I'm surprised everyone says Sarah, I'd save her too. I thought Sarah haters were the majority.
Apparently we're the vocal minority.
I guess you guys are.
Even ignoring her massive out of character scheme with hiding A.J. it's still Sarah by miles.
Replays have made me realize just how shallow Jane's character is and her sudden interest in Clementine is actually creepy. With the way she talks about Sarah and Jamie so dismissively yet she bends over backwards for Clementine even when they disagree. It's like she knows Clem is capable so she wants to mold Clem into her ideal replacement for her sister just so she can have the benefit of company again without actually dealing without the possibility of loss. Her motivations make even her more heroic actions seem incredibly selfish and it also suggests she eventually would ditch Clementine if she became too much a burden.
Sarah because pinky swear. But I still don't understand how people can call Jane ugly. Seriously, for this game's standards, she's far from it.
Lol it used to be my gamertag but Xbox management removed it -_-
Sarah.
because fuck Jane.
Is this even a question?
Decide who you want to be with. HINT: One of these people will get you and everyone around you killed.
Clementine?
Sarah
A.J.?
Rebecca?
Still dodging the question I see. Furthers proves to the evidence Sarah was completely useless and only got people killed, not to mention the notorious sitting in a corner and crying act the whole game. But no one wants to say this of course. The only reason I could see people saving Sarah was they felt pity for her or just is a goody-two-shoes who always tries to save people no matter what the reason.
Sarah. I'd trust her more than I would trust Jane.
Walkers? Jane?
Wow you really hate Sarah...
Great post. Well said. Thats exactly how I see Jane.
How can you not? Can you please tell exactly why you would choose her?
More so of a choice of do you want to be with liability who would only get you killed or someone actually useful and who does something helpful instead of sitting and crying.
Yeah, as opposed to Jane, who hatches an elaborate scheme in the middle of a snow storm to start a fight with a deranged man, then loses said fight and is stabbed to death by her own fucking knife unless saved by an eleven year old girl. What kind of "survivalist" hatches a plan to create a pointless conflict that results in her own death, and to Kenny of all people, the guy who's lost every fight he's ever been in before.
Because people like Sarah's personality more than Jane's. Jane is cold hearted and nobody can relate to her, or agree what she believes. Even by the end of the game she still is cold hearted by hiding AJ and getting Clementine to kill Kenny out of her own selfish desires.
I can TRUST her more, plus Sarah doesn't just use Clem to replace somebody, Sarah actually cares.