Luke vs. Kenny would have been much more better, imo. Everything was leading up to it and all, only for it to be cut off by Luke dying.
I… moret would have been much more easier/better if Jane was the one who drowned, seeing that Luke would be all sad and shit, and realize that he can't just 'get over' everything. Then, when Luke doesn't want to head north anymore, after seeing Jane die BECAUSE of an icy lake, Kenny get pissed. Says "You're just mopey and all that shit because your girlfriend died". Causing even MORE tension between the two.
Mike and Bonnie would want to leave, obviously, Mike would talk Bonnie out of asking Luke since he's all mopey and shit and wouldn't do much. Bonnie would reluctantly agree, then the scene goes on from there. Eventually, Luke's anger will get to him in the car. Everything will hit him like a shit ton of bricks. His parents dying, Pete, Nick, Alvin, Carlos, Sarah, Rebecca, Jane, Mike and Bonnie leaving, th… [view original content]
Luke vs. Kenny would have been much more better, imo. Everything was leading up to it and all, only for it to be cut off by Luke dying.
I… moret would have been much more easier/better if Jane was the one who drowned, seeing that Luke would be all sad and shit, and realize that he can't just 'get over' everything. Then, when Luke doesn't want to head north anymore, after seeing Jane die BECAUSE of an icy lake, Kenny get pissed. Says "You're just mopey and all that shit because your girlfriend died". Causing even MORE tension between the two.
Mike and Bonnie would want to leave, obviously, Mike would talk Bonnie out of asking Luke since he's all mopey and shit and wouldn't do much. Bonnie would reluctantly agree, then the scene goes on from there. Eventually, Luke's anger will get to him in the car. Everything will hit him like a shit ton of bricks. His parents dying, Pete, Nick, Alvin, Carlos, Sarah, Rebecca, Jane, Mike and Bonnie leaving, th… [view original content]
I love those ideas, that definitely would've been a cool way to see it play out and would've made the finale ten times better.
Take my like, take it aaaaall!
telltale pls, goddamn I would have loved both those endings.
However, I think the stats would have been completely knocked off the scale with Luke>Kenny as Kenny is very obviously the 'bad guy/aggressor' in this scenario.
Luke vs. Kenny would have been much more better, imo. Everything was leading up to it and all, only for it to be cut off by Luke dying.
I… moret would have been much more easier/better if Jane was the one who drowned, seeing that Luke would be all sad and shit, and realize that he can't just 'get over' everything. Then, when Luke doesn't want to head north anymore, after seeing Jane die BECAUSE of an icy lake, Kenny get pissed. Says "You're just mopey and all that shit because your girlfriend died". Causing even MORE tension between the two.
Mike and Bonnie would want to leave, obviously, Mike would talk Bonnie out of asking Luke since he's all mopey and shit and wouldn't do much. Bonnie would reluctantly agree, then the scene goes on from there. Eventually, Luke's anger will get to him in the car. Everything will hit him like a shit ton of bricks. His parents dying, Pete, Nick, Alvin, Carlos, Sarah, Rebecca, Jane, Mike and Bonnie leaving, th… [view original content]
telltale story writer 1: Hey you know what we should do? Remember Luke?
telltale story writer 2: Yeah, the guy we've been building up and developing to be a major character since s2e1.
telltale story writer 1: We should just drown him and conveniently let molly2.0 save the group, then make her pull an illogical dickmove and make it jane v kenny! because shocking plot twist lol
Honestly I would have them become friends instead of rivals, and the choice would give you bullet and have to save them form zombies.
Have the after effect like choosing who to sit with back in Ep2.
I still would've chose Kenny.
telltale story writer 1: Hey you know what we should do? Remember Luke?
telltale story writer 2: Yeah, the guy we've been building up and… more developing to be a major character since s2e1.
telltale story writer 1: We should just drown him and conveniently let molly2.0 save the group, then make her pull an illogical dickmove and make it jane v kenny! because shocking plot twist lol
telltale story writer 2: lol k
I assume they've said this in their video interviews? If so, they fumbled big time - there was much more build-up to Carver's importance in the first half of the Season than the conflict between two characters who didn't even interact in the first episode they shared.
Carver was never planned to be a big character. They just got Madsen on board so they went ahead and gave Carver more of the spotlight.
A… morend Luke dying and the Kenny vs. Jane fight was planned from the beginning and in the very first draft of the script.
Bringing Jane into the game was a bad move in itself, IMO. They should have kept Carley instead.
Carley was more appealing. She was prett… morey, had a nice personality and a sexy voice.
She was well-read and knew a lot about geography, being a reporter.
She was a moral person, and helped maintain the group's humanity while they were trying to survive. She consistently made the right call (deciding to keep Duck, telling Lee to tell the truth, etc.)
If she were still with the group, they would have reached Wellington a lot earlier, perhaps with several of them still alive.
Comments
Depends upon you.
I love those ideas, that definitely would've been a cool way to see it play out and would've made the finale ten times better.
Take my like, take it aaaaall!
This probably was Episode 5's original ending before they decided to be SHOCKING.
Same reason why they killed off Carver mid-season.
Carver was never planned to be a big character. They just got Madsen on board so they went ahead and gave Carver more of the spotlight.
And Luke dying and the Kenny vs. Jane fight was planned from the beginning and in the very first draft of the script.
Thanks, Lilac. c:
SHOCKING.
Do you mind if I fangirl with you?
Lol fair enough, but even Superman has Kryptonite :P
telltale pls, goddamn I would have loved both those endings.
However, I think the stats would have been completely knocked off the scale with Luke>Kenny as Kenny is very obviously the 'bad guy/aggressor' in this scenario.
telltale story writer 1: Hey you know what we should do? Remember Luke?
telltale story writer 2: Yeah, the guy we've been building up and developing to be a major character since s2e1.
telltale story writer 1: We should just drown him and conveniently let molly2.0 save the group, then make her pull an illogical dickmove and make it jane v kenny! because shocking plot twist lol
telltale story writer 2: lol k
would you shoot Luke in front of Sarah? How would that effect your friendship.
Rememer. back at the lounge when you sat with me? I need you to do this now!
Or something like that
[Meanwhile at Telltale headquarters]
(?)Telltale will remember that...
I assume they've said this in their video interviews? If so, they fumbled big time - there was much more build-up to Carver's importance in the first half of the Season than the conflict between two characters who didn't even interact in the first episode they shared.
It seems bad but it was one of the greatest game experience in that year. It just needs context (thinking) to be read properly... http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/82972/2nd-season-ending-my-interpretation-kenny-vs-jane-and-the-dream
Yeah, I think that's why they killed her.
:-)