What if Kenny had drowned instead of Luke?
Lets say the same situation happens where Kenny drowns instead of Luke (wanted to model swap with Luke and Kenny to post a screenshot but my game isn't cooperating with me at the moment), what do you guys think would happen after? Would it be a simple good riddance? Do you guys think the group would still fall apart, or do you think they would get over it rather quickly since the group thought that Kenny was losing it?
How would the Season conclude?
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I don't think the group would fall apart... I hate to say it, but the whole group disliked how Kenny treated Arvo which caused them to feel the need to leave... if Kenny died the group may have still been together, but Arvo may still have shot Clementine :x
I'm sure they would head back to Howe's and give up on Wellington. On the other hand, who knows if they could've got the truck working.
Yeah that's what I was wondering, everyone seemed to have a different idea on where to go once Kenny got the car started to work, would of been interesting to see what would of happened there
Luke wanted to go North in the first place. Wellington is most likely on the way.
I don't think it's fully dependent on what Luke would want. He would ask everyone elses opinions on the matter. Mike wanted to go to Texas. Jane wanted to go to Howe's. Don't know where Bonnie wanted to go. At a tie-up in terms of vote, he would ask Clem what she wanted to do.
Honestly, Luke was the one holding the group together. So if Kenny took his place, the group probably would have stuck together, and not gotten Clem shot, and Bonnie and Mike probably wouldn't have left.
And then we'd get three different endings. Aaahh, I see.
YES YES YES!
OH MY FUCKING GOD #YES
I'd love that, could Nick also be alive?
Please?
I'm honestly surprised by the lack of Kenny fans in this thread.
((Totally didn't edit this because I made a stupid mistake))
A large shitstorm would go through this forum.
The group would die because Kenny knew how to fix the truck
As much as I love Kenny, I think I would've preferred this.
I don't know, I think again I would've been annoyed because of the whole business with Luke and Kenny going completely nowhere...but then, Luke would've been ALIVE!!!
But an interesting question. Personally I don't think the group would've fallen apart, I think there might've been an issue with Arvo afterwards and if to still keep him prisoner [that and if Mike might cut and run] but they more than likely would've stayed together as a group. I'm not sure how it would've concluded though...
Honestly, Kenny or Luke falling in the lake is stupid...it should've been Jane. I mean, think about it, a woman who became like ice trying not to care for others, ends up warming up to Clem enough that she comes back to stay with her and the group, only to die there while trying to either stop Clem from running over to help her so she doesn't fall in too, or by Jane saving her from the walker when she didn't have to do it, as if making up for not saving Jaime.
dont worry. its only this shitty forum against him. thats because people are leaving. just look the infinite topics trying to put him down.
kepp dreaming. if if if.... the fact its that nick is dead since epidode 2 hahahaha. and no one is going to talk about luke or jane in a few months and kenny will be there forever.
deal with it
No the group wouldn't have fallen apart. As much as I hate to say it, I feel like Clem would be the only one who would grieve Kenny's drowning (then again, its player determinant), and the rest of the group would probably lightly brush it off and stick together. They would head to Howes or somewhere else back south.
But what if Jane had drowned instead of Luke? What would happen then =O
Jane drowning instead of Luke? That would amazing, Luke would LIVE!
As much as I hate to say it, the group wouldn't have fallen apart. Since pretty much everyone except determinant Clem hated him. I think Clem would be the only one grieving for him, maybe Luke would've tried to help her get over it.
Arvo would angry and happy, he's angry Clem didn't die and happy that Kenny died.
Mike might be sad but I'm not sure, he was developing a hatred to Kenny throughout the whole episode.
I don't know about Bonnie and Jane.
Thank god he didn't die in my game, but.... R.I.P Luke.
and Jane DEAD! Awesome
Why not Arvo?
I don't really hate Jane, I don't like her either.
The only characters that I cared about in Ep5 were: Clem, Kenny, Luke, and maybe AJ.
What a great idea.
10/10 DOTY
Jane would be happy because there one less reason for clem to stay with the group and Bonnie would be "meh , i dont care"
I don't think Jane would be happy, I doubt she would feel bad for Kenny, but feel bad for Clem because she lost another person she cared about. And she did say she would stick with Clem this time.
You're right about Bonnie though.
Then Kenny would come back in season 3 saying he got lucky.
Doubt Kenny would have drowned even if he fell in, the only reason Luke drowned was because he was beat to shit (shot leg, broken ribs) and was all around tired.
While running trying to reach Arvo?
Again if he did fell he would just gotten out like Bonnie did if you cover Luke. (and yea if you break the ice)
If this forum is shitty, why are you here? And imo Kenny is not as good as most people make him out to be. Though he was an interesting character nevertheless.
There might have been a chance to explain to Arvo that Clementine shot his sister when she had already turned into a walker, and in the previous episode depending on dialogue choices Arvo can say that Clementine was nice (Even if she does steal the pills) and he wishes they could have met differently. So if the misunderstanding was explained, I don't think Arvo would have ever shot her, or could have even had the opportunity to because there'd be no Kenny to freak anyone out and make them feel like they have to run away.
But considering how trusting everyone seemed of him (I mean yeah, I felt bad for Arvo but if I was in that situation I would under no circumstances trust him right away. I'd never beat on him like Kenny did, but there were two extremes, you have Mike being too nice to him, and Kenny who was too harsh. idk.) they might have just untied him right after they found the supplies, and depending on how accurate the interpretation of Arvo as 'evil' (for lack of a better word) actually is, he might have started trying to get revenge on Clementine before the misunderstanding could be explained, or maybe he even still hates Jane considering she was the one who jumped him and that kinda started the whole thing.
I'm just babbling now I don't even know what I'm getting at. But basically, if Kenny had died instead, it woulda been great. Everybody could go back to Howe's and live as one happy family. Or whatever. And since Arvo was trying to hotwire the truck, maybe he knew how to fix it too but Kenny beat him to it and got to work on it first. Then they wouldn't have to walk back.
Well the truck would not have been repaired and the major conflict within the group would be gone. Oh but what about Bonnie? In my play through she died on the lake. So my group that made it to the cabin was: Clem, AJ, Mike, Arvo, Jane & Kenny. I think the group would return to Howe's , but I don't think Arvo or Luke would reach the end. I think Luke would die and turn kill Arvo and get put down by the group. (The kill Arvo was just an easy way to get rid of the character.) Or Luke turns and gets put down. Then sometime on the return journey Arvo will try to kill Clem, be unsuccessful, and the group makes a decision to leave him with one days food. So my final group would be Clem, AJ, Mike and Jane. We would have all the supplies because there would have never been a tribal split.
I'd hate to say it, but if Kenny did drown in the lake the group would either split up in the most dramatic of ways or they would find someone else to crucify for their problems. Plus for those people that actually wanted to go to Wellington (to find Christa or just safety) it would be outta the question since Clem would be the only person with interest there.
No, what if Kenny drowned in E5, everything before that still happened.
I don't get how the group gets on Kenny's back for treating Arvo like shit yet Luke says his going to go check out the area to make it safe and he ditches the group to have sex with Jane even though he knew Rebecca was almost in labour. Fair enough, Kenny should've have belted the kid but Luke was willing to let the group suffer just so he could get some self pleasure.
I don't know how was the one holding the group together when he deserted them mulptile times.
The difference is that Luke made a mistake, Kenny beat the kid multiple times and (determinant) knocks out Arvo.
Yeah i did care about Aj until the end of Ep 5. Extreme Baby character Development yo
Carver would have probably just shot Clem in the head to be honest