She doesn't have PTSD. She doesn't have a disorder in the first place.
If Sarah had it, Clementine has it.
That makes no sense, Sarah was traumatized and she couldn't handle it. We all witnessed her behavior. The reason why Clementine is "down" most of the time, is because she lost a lot of people and she feels sad for being alone. Some people just can't handle emotions.
the creator of this thread said:
I want her to have a little more emotion in her voice
voice actor is way too old, it's hard to make a proper voice for a eleven year old, but the voice also needed to fit with the character. so can't say to much about that.
Clementine's character has been affected by everything she has been through. We don't know what else happend after Omid died, and seriously; A LOT could've happend in that time.
Clementine is still mentally stable, after everything she been through. In contrast of Sarah, who wasn't.
Clementine probably has PTSD. After watching every person she loved die horribly, i mean come on. If Sarah had it, Clementine has it.
I… morets a disease that makes you feel like a zombie, so she probably doesn't feel happy or sad or pretty much anything anymore. She should be a pint size version of yours Truly if you want a real representation.
Sarah is nothing like me. She didn't have PTSD, i don't know why the writers said that, because she was not a accurate representation of what the disease is. I feel like they were just trying to explain away her obsucre behavior with a disease that is "trendy." in pop culture, or they didn't know what to say and said the first thing that popped in their mind.
She shows no symptoms that are comparable with PTSD, or anything that would make me think she has it. I was diagnosed myself with this disorder myself. However Clementine i could see, having the disease because of all the horrible things that happened to her since the whole mess started.
If Sarah had it, Clementine has it.
Clementine doesn't have PTSD.
Look at the symptoms Sarah had: Not wanting to move, wanting to… more be quiet, didn't want anything to do with anyone, wanted to believe her father was still alive after witnessing his demise.
Now compare those to Clementine. If she has it, everyone would complain that she's a liability and that she's useless and spend most gameplay doing nothing but sitting around and being depressed.
Sure, Clementine has lost more than Sarah, but it doesn't mean she has a disorder. She can simply handle stuff like that more better than Sarah. I'd say it's more of survivors guilt than PTSD.
Kenny was way more interesting than that cunt Jane. We've seen the silent badass who loses her family and becomes selfish then brought out of her shell by the main group of survivors, sound familiar? I assume you're talking about Sarah when you say "young girl", she was annoying, lame, useless, and definitely lowered everyone's chances of surviving. I don't understand the few people who hate Kenny, do you all realize how boring the story would've been without him, would you rather all the characters get along and live in peace without absolutely any conflict? And sub-par writing? So why do you bother playing it? You clearly don't know what you're talking about.
What does she have to be happy about?
Being written to follow a group of idiots and fuck-up's through their demise as she is forcibly als… moreo written to not kill a psychopathic redneck that only lowers her survival odds until the end of the game in a "climatic finale."
Then having the writer's favor a drooling whining new-born over a young girl that, at least, had purpose in the narrative and wasn't just shoe-horned in to get the bleeding-hearts to care for it's safety. Then getting the writer's to favor said psychotic-bumbling-assface-Kenny over a character as interesting as Jane.
I'd be depressed too if I lived in a sub-par writer's head.
About Clementine...
She doesn't have PTSD. She doesn't have a disorder in the first place.
If Sarah had it, Clementine has it.
… more
That makes no sense, Sarah was traumatized and she couldn't handle it. We all witnessed her behavior. The reason why Clementine is "down" most of the time, is because she lost a lot of people and she feels sad for being alone. Some people just can't handle emotions.
the creator of this thread said:
I want her to have a little more emotion in her voice
* voice actor is way too old, it's hard to make a proper voice for a eleven year old, but the voice also needed to fit with the character. so can't say to much about that.
* Clementine's character has been affected by everything she has been through. We don't know what else happend after Omid died, and seriously; A LOT could've happend in that time.
* Clementine is still mentally stable, after everything she been through. In contrast of Sarah, who wasn't.
If Sarah had it, Clementine has it.
Clementine doesn't have PTSD.
Look at the symptoms Sarah had: Not wanting to move, wanting to… more be quiet, didn't want anything to do with anyone, wanted to believe her father was still alive after witnessing his demise.
Now compare those to Clementine. If she has it, everyone would complain that she's a liability and that she's useless and spend most gameplay doing nothing but sitting around and being depressed.
Sure, Clementine has lost more than Sarah, but it doesn't mean she has a disorder. She can simply handle stuff like that more better than Sarah. I'd say it's more of survivors guilt than PTSD.
Oh, she definitely has it. So does shell-shocked Kenny.
Kenny for certain. His behavior, the way he treated Arvo. In my own experiences I never became violent, but i definetly could identify with Kenny in some degree. For example this line.
"What is wrong with Kenny? Why is Kenny acting this way? Is Kenny going to be okay."
PTSD isn't the only thing that's "off" with Sarah. 15 year old girls don't act like her - they act like Becca.
I disagree, i think every child acts different. Some are more outgoing then others, some are born shy. I never thought Sarah had anything mentally wrong with her, other than she was lonely/sheltered and wanted a friend. She was my Ben Character for me in S2.
I loved Ben from S1. I wished he would of survived, and in S2 same with Sarah.
Oh, she definitely has it. So does shell-shocked Kenny.
PTSD isn't the only thing that's "off" with Sarah. 15 year old girls don't act … morelike her - they act like Becca.
BTW, look up "Happy Little Clem" or "Psycho Clem" on Youtube if you want to see her smiling.
"Symptoms of PTSD. People with PTSD often experience feelings of panic or extreme fear, which may resemble what was felt during the traumatic event. A person with PTSD has three main types of difficulties, which include: reliving the traumatic event – through unwanted and recurring memories and vivid nightmares."
They claim that she has PTSD. Although not represented properly, it is confirmed that she has it. I guess that she's just silent when Clem comes in, because with Luke, she was screaming very loudly.
However Clementine i could see, having the disease because of all the horrible things that happened to her since the whole mess started.
Well, it's not really the matter of what she's seen, it's more of how she acts. She doesn't show any symptoms whatsoever, nor is it confirmed. But I can see what you're trying to say.
Sarah is nothing like me. She didn't have PTSD, i don't know why the writers said that, because she was not a accurate representation of wh… moreat the disease is. I feel like they were just trying to explain away her obsucre behavior with a disease that is "trendy." in pop culture, or they didn't know what to say and said the first thing that popped in their mind.
She shows no symptoms that are comparable with PTSD, or anything that would make me think she has it. I was diagnosed myself with this disorder myself. However Clementine i could see, having the disease because of all the horrible things that happened to her since the whole mess started.
Oh, she definitely has it. So does shell-shocked Kenny.
Clementine doesn't even show any symptoms of PTSD. But I agree with Kenny having it.
And no, we were born with "personality" for a reason. Not every 15 year old acts like Becca, Becca just seems to look at the ZA in a different way. Sarah, not only has PTSD, but was very sheltered. Her personality is warm and caring, and Becca's is hostile and quirky.
Oh, she definitely has it. So does shell-shocked Kenny.
PTSD isn't the only thing that's "off" with Sarah. 15 year old girls don't act … morelike her - they act like Becca.
BTW, look up "Happy Little Clem" or "Psycho Clem" on Youtube if you want to see her smiling.
What does she have to be happy about?
Being written to follow a group of idiots and fuck-up's through their demise as she is forcibly als… moreo written to not kill a psychopathic redneck that only lowers her survival odds until the end of the game in a "climatic finale."
Then having the writer's favor a drooling whining new-born over a young girl that, at least, had purpose in the narrative and wasn't just shoe-horned in to get the bleeding-hearts to care for it's safety. Then getting the writer's to favor said psychotic-bumbling-assface-Kenny over a character as interesting as Jane.
I'd be depressed too if I lived in a sub-par writer's head.
Seconded, once again. I'm all for having some actual introspective on Clem's growth and the childhood she left behind, and exploring that kind of sisterly bond with Sarah would be a very bittersweet dynamic.
Clem hates tree houses. =P
I was actually thinking a set of swings Sarah wants to play on. She invites Clem to swing with her and if you … moresay no, Sarah tries to spin it into a competition. Asserting she can jump further from the swing than Clem can. It could be a quicktime event if you accept her challenge. But if you still say no, Sarah just swings without Clem and you see Clem watching Sarah have fun and you can tell she really wants to go over there. And afterwards Sarah can offer to push Clem to see how much higher she could swing. Just a short little scene somewhere in between the action that acknowledges that even if Clem believes she has to be cold to survive, she doesn't want to be.
I actually had this odd dream after my second play through of season two. Where Clem and Sarah find a department store, and Clem lays out all these tools and equipment on the floor. Canteen, lighter, rope, tin snips, pliers, raincoat, screwdriver, mirror, needle nose pliers, compass. Where as Sarah adds a couple of frivolous fun items. Pack of Cards, a couple of books, pad of paper and pens. And then you have to pick only six items to take with you. Kind of a symbolic decision on how much you value happiness in such terrible times.
Then later Sarah gets bitten, and her dying request is to return to the department store and just play with Clem in the toy section for a couple a hours before she dies. And there be a ton of things to click on but you could only go through a small amount of them before Sarah succumbs to the bite. Then she thank Clem for fulfilling her dying wish and Clem would have to shoot her. A bittersweet experience with Clem getting to relive her lost childhood briefly before leaving it behind for good as signified by Sarah's death.
Seconded, once again. I'm all for having some actual introspective on Clem's growth and the childhood she left behind, and exploring that kind of sisterly bond with Sarah would be a very bittersweet dynamic.
He has countlessly insulted other members directly...Yet the mods move my interactive story the same day it was created...Yes I am spiteful about that.
He has countlessly insulted other members directly...Yet the mods move my interactive story the same day it was created...Yes I am spiteful about that.
Yeah others have been up for weeks...I'm pretty pissed...But I won't do or say anything.
I asked Blind why he moved it...He said it got enough attention...I said it was created just today...He never responded.
Oh, she definitely has it. So does shell-shocked Kenny.
Clementine doesn't even show any symptoms of PTSD. But I agree with Kenny ha… moreving it.
And no, we were born with "personality" for a reason. Not every 15 year old acts like Becca, Becca just seems to look at the ZA in a different way. Sarah, not only has PTSD, but was very sheltered. Her personality is warm and caring, and Becca's is hostile and quirky.
I'd take too much time figuring out different item combinations, but I like the idea of the variation that would come with prioritizing certain supplies (Even if I'd feel bad having to explain why we needed a canteen more than a fantasy novel).
Then later Sarah gets bitten, and her dying request is to return to the department store and just play with Clem in the toy section for a couple a hours before she dies. And there be a ton of things to click on but you could only go through a small amount of them before Sarah succumbs to the bite.
Ouch. I'm a sap that likes to imagine a positive outcome for Sarah, but the idea of sitting it out with her as she slowly deteriorates could have had some heavy impact on me. Apart from Lee, and the few minutes you can sit with Pete, we haven't really talked to someone who knew it was only a matter of time after a bite.
What if Sarah didn't fully know that her wound was fatal, and Clementine had to go about explaining it? Easing her into the idea, or avoiding the topic while Clem tries to keep her composure playing a game or while reminiscing about random hobbies they had in the past. Staving off reality for however long you're able to give each other, and trying to smile despite the inevitable.
I actually had this odd dream after my second play through of season two. Where Clem and Sarah find a department store, and Clem lays out al… morel these tools and equipment on the floor. Canteen, lighter, rope, tin snips, pliers, raincoat, screwdriver, mirror, needle nose pliers, compass. Where as Sarah adds a couple of frivolous fun items. Pack of Cards, a couple of books, pad of paper and pens. And then you have to pick only six items to take with you. Kind of a symbolic decision on how much you value happiness in such terrible times.
Then later Sarah gets bitten, and her dying request is to return to the department store and just play with Clem in the toy section for a couple a hours before she dies. And there be a ton of things to click on but you could only go through a small amount of them before Sarah succumbs to the bite. Then she thank Clem for fulfilling her dying wish and Clem would have to shoot her. A bittersweet experience with Cl… [view original content]
Comments
About Clementine...
She doesn't have PTSD. She doesn't have a disorder in the first place.
That makes no sense, Sarah was traumatized and she couldn't handle it. We all witnessed her behavior. The reason why Clementine is "down" most of the time, is because she lost a lot of people and she feels sad for being alone. Some people just can't handle emotions.
the creator of this thread said:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PMQ0rsWMGs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8tXlfKXjLkk
Sarah is nothing like me. She didn't have PTSD, i don't know why the writers said that, because she was not a accurate representation of what the disease is. I feel like they were just trying to explain away her obsucre behavior with a disease that is "trendy." in pop culture, or they didn't know what to say and said the first thing that popped in their mind.
She shows no symptoms that are comparable with PTSD, or anything that would make me think she has it. I was diagnosed myself with this disorder myself. However Clementine i could see, having the disease because of all the horrible things that happened to her since the whole mess started.
Incorrect.
Her life is awesome.
[removed]
Depends on the situation.
For sexual purposes, no.
Kenny was way more interesting than that cunt Jane. We've seen the silent badass who loses her family and becomes selfish then brought out of her shell by the main group of survivors, sound familiar? I assume you're talking about Sarah when you say "young girl", she was annoying, lame, useless, and definitely lowered everyone's chances of surviving. I don't understand the few people who hate Kenny, do you all realize how boring the story would've been without him, would you rather all the characters get along and live in peace without absolutely any conflict? And sub-par writing? So why do you bother playing it? You clearly don't know what you're talking about.
Telltale confirmed that Sarah suffers PTSD.
Oh, she definitely has it. So does shell-shocked Kenny.
PTSD isn't the only thing that's "off" with Sarah. 15 year old girls don't act like her - they act like Becca.
BTW, look up "Happy Little Clem" or "Psycho Clem" on Youtube if you want to see her smiling.
Kenny for certain. His behavior, the way he treated Arvo. In my own experiences I never became violent, but i definetly could identify with Kenny in some degree. For example this line.
"What is wrong with Kenny? Why is Kenny acting this way? Is Kenny going to be okay."
I disagree, i think every child acts different. Some are more outgoing then others, some are born shy. I never thought Sarah had anything mentally wrong with her, other than she was lonely/sheltered and wanted a friend. She was my Ben Character for me in S2.
I loved Ben from S1. I wished he would of survived, and in S2 same with Sarah.
After all that's happened, we are lucky Clem is not catatonic so no, there is Zeo reason for her to be much happier then she is
"Symptoms of PTSD. People with PTSD often experience feelings of panic or extreme fear, which may resemble what was felt during the traumatic event. A person with PTSD has three main types of difficulties, which include: reliving the traumatic event – through unwanted and recurring memories and vivid nightmares."
They claim that she has PTSD. Although not represented properly, it is confirmed that she has it. I guess that she's just silent when Clem comes in, because with Luke, she was screaming very loudly.
Well, it's not really the matter of what she's seen, it's more of how she acts. She doesn't show any symptoms whatsoever, nor is it confirmed. But I can see what you're trying to say.
Clementine doesn't even show any symptoms of PTSD. But I agree with Kenny having it.
And no, we were born with "personality" for a reason. Not every 15 year old acts like Becca, Becca just seems to look at the ZA in a different way. Sarah, not only has PTSD, but was very sheltered. Her personality is warm and caring, and Becca's is hostile and quirky.
I think they're talking about Clementine, I'm not sure.
What the fuck? That wasn't even needed, let alone implied.
assface.
Insult of the day.
Seconded, once again. I'm all for having some actual introspective on Clem's growth and the childhood she left behind, and exploring that kind of sisterly bond with Sarah would be a very bittersweet dynamic.
I actually had this odd dream after my second play through of season two. Where Clem and Sarah find a department store, and Clem lays out all these tools and equipment on the floor. Canteen, lighter, rope, tin snips, pliers, raincoat, screwdriver, mirror, needle nose pliers, compass. Where as Sarah adds a couple of frivolous fun items. Pack of Cards, a couple of books, pad of paper and pens. And then you have to pick only six items to take with you. Kind of a symbolic decision on how much you value happiness in such terrible times.
Then later Sarah gets bitten, and her dying request is to return to the department store and just play with Clem in the toy section for a couple a hours before she dies. And there be a ton of things to click on but you could only go through a small amount of them before Sarah succumbs to the bite. Then she thank Clem for fulfilling her dying wish and Clem would have to shoot her. A bittersweet experience with Clem getting to relive her lost childhood briefly before leaving it behind for good as signified by Sarah's death.
I've noticed he does stuff like this.
Seriously don't know why he's not banned.
He has countlessly insulted other members directly...Yet the mods move my interactive story the same day it was created...Yes I am spiteful about that.
I wouldn't blame you.
Just flag his comment, I'm sure the mods will see it ten go to his profile and see all the unneeded hate he's been giving.
Every post I've seen by him are just completely rude. And he's been a complete jerk to me before.
Its a miracle he's not banned yet.
Yeah others have been up for weeks...I'm pretty pissed...But I won't do or say anything.
I asked Blind why he moved it...He said it got enough attention...I said it was created just today...He never responded.
Yeah, I don't know why he hasn't.
I've reported him.
I'm probably going to go PM the mods about him.
yus pls.
Depends on what it was about, really.
It was a Forum Rebellion, Kind of role playing.
It makes me mad...but i'll just sit here...writing for the story and sometimes advertising it.
Maybe it's just my memory of the 15-year-old girls I grew up with. Teenagers are a pretty cynical, tryhard bunch. :P
I'd take too much time figuring out different item combinations, but I like the idea of the variation that would come with prioritizing certain supplies (Even if I'd feel bad having to explain why we needed a canteen more than a fantasy novel).
Ouch. I'm a sap that likes to imagine a positive outcome for Sarah, but the idea of sitting it out with her as she slowly deteriorates could have had some heavy impact on me. Apart from Lee, and the few minutes you can sit with Pete, we haven't really talked to someone who knew it was only a matter of time after a bite.
What if Sarah didn't fully know that her wound was fatal, and Clementine had to go about explaining it? Easing her into the idea, or avoiding the topic while Clem tries to keep her composure playing a game or while reminiscing about random hobbies they had in the past. Staving off reality for however long you're able to give each other, and trying to smile despite the inevitable.
Not all teenagers. But I can tell you that I'm much like Becca,
Whos baby is it?
Would I prefer a happy Clem? Yessir. Is there any reason after all she has through to he happy? Nope.
Carvers?
You sure.
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
I... don't know?