Who's a better Survivor Clementine or Carl?
Personally, I believe Carl would definitely win in a firefight and a actual fist fight against Clementine. He's just a ruthless boy, who can take out his own mother and shoot unarmed boys in cold blood, dark.
But on the other hand, Carl will not be able to survive on his own. He's always under the protection of Rick.He have not been shown to melee walkers or killing them without the use of a gun. He can't last one day alone without almost being killed twice by walkers.
Yet, Clementine have been surviving all this time with no one genuinely protecting her,expect, lee. She spends days alone in her tree house before lee found her. She's gets her group out of tight situations, does recon;and she survives 9 day plus days with a baby, and stitches her own arm.
But still, she is not a killer;She does have a lack of experience,when it comes to firefights. And her kind heart gets in the way.
Comments
A very biased place to ask this but anyway in order of survival
Comic book Carl: "Hi YOU DIE NOW"
Clementine: "Hey, Arh you shot me, oh well I'm clem I'm cool"
Tv show Carl: "DERP DERP DERP, Im cool, now Im cold now I;m cool , Now im cold"
Duck/Mika/Sophia/Billy "Lets run... and yeah were cool oh wait no were not"
Sarah "Im gonna sit here and die"
6.Lizzie/Comic Ben "Walkers are our friends, People are our enemies, Oh LOL no their not and they just ate me oops..."
CORAL?!!!!
I like both characters but I think Clem would be better in certain areas that Carl lacks in.
oh boy this is what the 3rd clem v carl thread this week?
depends which carl we are talking about here comic carl is less of a idiot and more of an actual survivor with issues while tv carl is just coral so i would say comic carl and clem are on the same level of survival and tv show carl is the worst
agree
I'm so sick of these comparing threads.
TV Carl can't do shit. Comic Carl and Clem are on the same level, both doing whatever they need to do in order to survive
Thats so hard to anwser... O_0 But if i had to choose i would probably go for Carl. Yes, Clem is downright badass but she lacks in some strength too. Emotional strength i mean..
Soooo many of these threads. I think Carl is more useful when it comes to having to fight people/ in an actual war. Whereas I think Clementine has a better chance of surviving through scavenging/ camping and all.
Both are still alive...thus it could be said they are both reasonably effective at 'surviving.'
ok but jane sucked and she died in all games.
I don't know...
you
tell
me
I bet Luke appreciated her sucking...
Clementine. She doesn't need to depend on anyone else to survive
y u do dis?
I'll let this answer your question.
you
tell
me
She is more mentally stable than most of the adults in her series. And the tears she sheded, those were some MANLY TEARS! Anit nothing cowardly about them.
That's comic book Carl. I was ripping on TV show Carl.
It's funny, he's such a poor actor, you can see how he decides to change his position while on the ground to a more "fatal" position, what a dumbass.
I didn't, Jane's the one that sucks.
Clemintine by far! Carol sucks
do we even need this thread? Carl. No offense clem, but Carl is way more of a badass, TV show and Comic
You should mostly blame the director for that. The director tells the actors what to do and HOW to do it. The director most likely told him to do it like that and when Chandler did that the director accepted this take. The actor is still partly to blame but director is more to blame for the take as there might've been more takes which were better for this scene but were not used.
Well the actor is shit and the director is stupid enough to use his shit.
Depending on how the player chooses to characterize her, I'd say Clementine is the winner, if only because she's able to retain her humanity. Carl, on the other hand, has become increasingly desensitized and sociopathic with each new issue, IMO.
Did you watch the episode?
Which is kind of ridiculous in my opinion. She hasnt been alone for more than a few hours until that 9 day epilogue where she goes off with AJ. Nobody survives the apocalypse alone, especially a little child with a little child.
Yep, I follow the show, why?
I like to call comic book Carl 'Lil Governor' (Eyepatch eh?)
I personally think if they got stuck in a room that they would become friends with Clem bringing back some of Carl's humanity while Carl would toughen up Clem a bit. I actually think they would become more than friends but I try not to think about it.
If I remember correctly, the way he fell seemed more like he was collapsing in frustration. A character choice.
I never thought of it in a way that they are two different types of survivalist. Clem is a resourceful and witty type of survivor.While Carl is more like a manic , kill who you can , type of survivor.
I still think carl from the comic and clementine will make a hell of a team. and can learn form eachother
Well, it's the same in the gif lol, you can clearly see through his acting and how the fall wasn't realistic at all.
It seemed like he was too much of a pussy to take a little hit so the shot would have been convincing, so he landed gracefully, what a weakling xD
And Becca?
Clem by far for being able to survive alone where Carl relies on his dad and their group for survival
Well, I can see there's no getting past your hate, lol
Goes to show how unrealistic the comic is even for a zombie universe.
No... I don't hate him, I hate his acting.
You know, there's more to TV shows and acting than "he sucks" and "he's amazing", there's always place for improvement.
I'm just saying that I think his acting is horrible, and I think season two proves it most (his horrible spazz after getting shot & his acting arm at the last episode of the season when he and Rick are on the road with Hershel).
Well.... on the flip side, Lee, Kenny and their group would've made it out of Savannah together if Clem hadn't run off. So its not like she's on her own by choice.
honestly who cares if it is unrealistic do you think this is any better? cause this was bullshit