I don't understand why this is so unspeakable. This is not Cluke, not a grown man having a relationship with an 11 year old, it's just a you… moreng girl having a crush on an older guy. Which is completely normal. Based on the game's dialogue, Luke's pretty good looking, so why is it such a taboo for Clem to have a small crush on him?
A kid thinking a teacher's hot is completely normal, and there is a big difference between believing Clem had a crush on Luke, and advocating "Cluke". The former simply means Clementine found Luke attractive, and what's wrong with that? The latter implies a romantic relationship, which I do find rather disgusting.
Lee and Kenny were (possibly) seen as father figures to Clementine, and I don't think Luke really fit that role. A guardian? Yeah. Father? No. Besides, though he is an adult, Luke is younger than both of those characters.
11 years is not "too damn young to have the slightest inkling of a clue about attraction". That would fit a 5 year old maybe. 11 years is actually a normal year for a girl to begin puberty, which, like boys, would mean she is beginning to have feelings of attraction. That occurs naturally. People who say Clem hasn't had "the talk" yet, it doesn't fucking matter. People have "the talk" in most cases because they are developing feelings of attraction.
You strike me as someone who was raised sheltered from the world and didn't realize what it was to find another person attractive until you were 16. I'm sorry about that.
Have you had a crush on a teacher? Weird.
It still makes no identifiable sense whatsoever. Plus this whole "Clementine has a crush on Luk… moree" thing has been talked up enough by this point to know that many people don't think it's logical. Except the Luke fan girls that loves his Bill Maher nose.
Ah, it's just that a lot of young guys here are hilariously awkward when it comes to considering that young girls may have sexual feelings. As though 11-year-old boys were paragons of purity...
A kid thinking a teacher's hot is completely normal, and there is a big difference between believing Clem had a crush on Luke, and advocatin… moreg "Cluke". The former simply means Clementine found Luke attractive, and what's wrong with that? The latter implies a romantic relationship, which I do find rather disgusting.
Lee and Kenny were (possibly) seen as father figures to Clementine, and I don't think Luke really fit that role. A guardian? Yeah. Father? No. Besides, though he is an adult, Luke is younger than both of those characters.
11 years is not "too damn young to have the slightest inkling of a clue about attraction". That would fit a 5 year old maybe. 11 years is actually a normal year for a girl to begin puberty, which, like boys, would mean she is beginning to have feelings of attraction. That occurs naturally. People who say Clem hasn't had "the talk" yet, it doesn't fucking matter. People have "the talk" in most cases because th… [view original content]
In my experience both sexes are pretty awkward about "relationships" I just have moments in my head picturing Clem and a male character scouting for food and she says something embarrassing and blushes.
Ah, it's just that a lot of young guys here are hilariously awkward when it comes to considering that young girls may have sexual feelings. As though 11-year-old boys were paragons of purity...
You strike me as someone who was raised sheltered from the world and didn't realize what it was to find another person attractive until you were 16.
Exactly right. I'm actually in a small Amish commune living in rural Wyoming.
...Or, could it be I've just never contained much of a sex-drive as a teen? Even then, it's hard for me to accept that this ridiculous "Clementine has a crush on Luke" theory is anything other than young girls projecting their attraction onto a fictional adolescent. I think I'll say Clementine has a "crush" on Mike, it makes about as much sense.
A kid thinking a teacher's hot is completely normal, and there is a big difference between believing Clem had a crush on Luke, and advocatin… moreg "Cluke". The former simply means Clementine found Luke attractive, and what's wrong with that? The latter implies a romantic relationship, which I do find rather disgusting.
Lee and Kenny were (possibly) seen as father figures to Clementine, and I don't think Luke really fit that role. A guardian? Yeah. Father? No. Besides, though he is an adult, Luke is younger than both of those characters.
11 years is not "too damn young to have the slightest inkling of a clue about attraction". That would fit a 5 year old maybe. 11 years is actually a normal year for a girl to begin puberty, which, like boys, would mean she is beginning to have feelings of attraction. That occurs naturally. People who say Clem hasn't had "the talk" yet, it doesn't fucking matter. People have "the talk" in most cases because th… [view original content]
You strike me as someone who was raised sheltered from the world and didn't realize what it was to find another person attractive until you … morewere 16.
Exactly right. I'm actually in a small Amish commune living in rural Wyoming.
...Or, could it be I've just never contained much of a sex-drive as a teen? Even then, it's hard for me to accept that this ridiculous "Clementine has a crush on Luke" theory is anything other than young girls projecting their attraction onto a fictional adolescent. I think I'll say Clementine has a "crush" on Mike, it makes about as much sense.
This again?
Clementine doesn't have a crush on Luke people. That makes no sense whatsoever. I guess the "implication" is that because Luk… moree is conventionally attractive, that means we can pervert Clementine and make her seem like having a "harmless wittle crush" on Luke is okay. What's to say she doesn't have a crush on Kenny, Sarah, Mike, or Arvo? She could be cordial to all of them. So, why not say Clementine has a crush on Lee then? Cause that would be gross, right? Same thing with her having feelings toward a 20-something year old man.
Just another example of people wanting Clementine to be a passive participant in their own selfish fantasies. The fact is that Clementine is too damn young to have the slightest inkling of a clue about attraction yet.
Give her a few more years, then pervert her sexuality all you want. Weirdo's.
It's not perverted if Clementine has the crush. I'm not sure if you know anything about puberty or not, but it's common and normal. You just need to hope that the older person doesn't take advantage.
She's too young to kill people.
She's too young to drink.
She's too young to smoke.
She's too young to see people die.
She's too… more young to be smarter than everyone else.
She's too young to know anything about sexuality.
She's too young to know anything about anything.
Now what were you saying again? It's the apocalypse, opinions from this generation don't matter in a world where zombies walk the earth, and humans kill each other all the time.
She's too young to kill people. No In ZA you kill or be killed.
She's too young to drink. Yes its always bad for you to drink especially … morein her age.
She's too young to smoke. Yes same as with drinking.
She's too young to see people die. No In ZA people die all the time
She's too young to be smarter than everyone else. TTG logic...
She's too young to know anything about sexuality. No. I knew everthing already when I was 6 years old.
She's too young to know anything about anything. No.
I'm only saying that she shouldn't drink or smoke.
You strike me as someone who was raised sheltered from the world and didn't realize what it was to find another person attractive until you … morewere 16.
Exactly right. I'm actually in a small Amish commune living in rural Wyoming.
...Or, could it be I've just never contained much of a sex-drive as a teen? Even then, it's hard for me to accept that this ridiculous "Clementine has a crush on Luke" theory is anything other than young girls projecting their attraction onto a fictional adolescent. I think I'll say Clementine has a "crush" on Mike, it makes about as much sense.
I'd be cute to see her having a crush on someone as long as he's/she's around her age, simply because we're all human and have feelings. It's totally normal and I don't really see a problem with it, except if she's starting to do 'kissing stuff'. She's WAY too young for that stuff. But otherwise, I'm not against it.
Comments
Didn't say it was wrong. I just don't see it. I think they were just friends, that's my opinion.
A kid thinking a teacher's hot is completely normal, and there is a big difference between believing Clem had a crush on Luke, and advocating "Cluke". The former simply means Clementine found Luke attractive, and what's wrong with that? The latter implies a romantic relationship, which I do find rather disgusting.
Lee and Kenny were (possibly) seen as father figures to Clementine, and I don't think Luke really fit that role. A guardian? Yeah. Father? No. Besides, though he is an adult, Luke is younger than both of those characters.
11 years is not "too damn young to have the slightest inkling of a clue about attraction". That would fit a 5 year old maybe. 11 years is actually a normal year for a girl to begin puberty, which, like boys, would mean she is beginning to have feelings of attraction. That occurs naturally. People who say Clem hasn't had "the talk" yet, it doesn't fucking matter. People have "the talk" in most cases because they are developing feelings of attraction.
You strike me as someone who was raised sheltered from the world and didn't realize what it was to find another person attractive until you were 16. I'm sorry about that.
I wouldn't want to control her speeches then lol... Girls are complicated what would i know :P
Ah, it's just that a lot of young guys here are hilariously awkward when it comes to considering that young girls may have sexual feelings. As though 11-year-old boys were paragons of purity...
In my experience both sexes are pretty awkward about "relationships" I just have moments in my head picturing Clem and a male character scouting for food and she says something embarrassing and blushes.
Speaking of crushes...
Guys, I think there might have been something going on between Carly and Lee.
Exactly right. I'm actually in a small Amish commune living in rural Wyoming.
...Or, could it be I've just never contained much of a sex-drive as a teen? Even then, it's hard for me to accept that this ridiculous "Clementine has a crush on Luke" theory is anything other than young girls projecting their attraction onto a fictional adolescent. I think I'll say Clementine has a "crush" on Mike, it makes about as much sense.
Only young girls, eh?
"I'd come back for you...you know what I mean."
Sounds like somebody's in denial and projecting their own thoughts.
luke: -is hot-
majority: "omg so wat if she has a crush"
other character: -is ugly-
majority: "ew no tats pedophilia"
It's not perverted if Clementine has the crush. I'm not sure if you know anything about puberty or not, but it's common and normal. You just need to hope that the older person doesn't take advantage.
where have you been
Pfft. Love is overrated anyway. Life is all about killing, sleeping and eating. No room for fun or having kids!
Puberty is one hell of a mind-drug.
This dude be using Internet Explorer here.
What?! your just now realizing that?! Where have you been?! with doug?
You sound like Carlos! xD
[removed]
That fucking starchild????
Shepard is not happy about this..
She's too young to kill people. No In ZA you kill or be killed.
She's too young to drink. Yes its always bad for you to drink especially in her age.
She's too young to smoke. Yes same as with drinking.
She's too young to see people die. No In ZA people die all the time
She's too young to be smarter than everyone else. TTG logic...
She's too young to know anything about sexuality. No. I knew everthing already when I was 6 years old.
She's too young to know anything about anything. No.
I'm only saying that she shouldn't drink or smoke.
Well I think its a little bit too early.
I was just kidding about that, a bandits life would probably be like that.
o yes she does.
really? you've read it that way?
also a little bit too early to kill huh?
hehe.
Clem killing a person is determinant.
holyshitididntseethatcoming
I'd be cute to see her having a crush on someone as long as he's/she's around her age, simply because we're all human and have feelings. It's totally normal and I don't really see a problem with it, except if she's starting to do 'kissing stuff'. She's WAY too young for that stuff. But otherwise, I'm not against it.