Probably Sarah's reaction? Maybe not, she'd probably just cry really loudly and scream out Lee's name. Maybe not as death-like like Sarah did. But her little squeal, you know?
Watching Kenny kill Carver, killing The Stranger, killing Duck, not picking up the gun, staying with Kenny, feeding Clementine, making Clem curse and drink, and killing Larry.
Wow, talk about a backstep.
Saying that Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten but previously saying that he had failed at not getting eaten and being killed. Logic?
By your logic, Carlos should've known a random bullet was coming at him, but then you might change your opinion again.
Lee could've gotten eaten had she left him on the streets when he collapsed (something Sarah would do) but no she pulled him into the shop. I think we all can say that Clem is strong minded where as Sarah is not, but people will always make excuses for her.
Wow, talk about a backstep.
Saying that Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten but previously saying that he had failed at not getting eat… moreen and being killed. Logic?
By your logic, Carlos should've known a random bullet was coming at him, but then you might change your opinion again.
Lee could've gotten eaten had she left him on the streets when he collapsed (something Sarah would do) but no she pulled him into the shop. … moreI think we all can say that Clem is strong minded where as Sarah is not, but people will always make excuses for her.
When did i ever say people don't make excuses for Clementine? Im talking about the 2 situations i.e Clem saving Lee from the walkers when he collapses and Sarah running away when something bad happens.
When did i ever say people don't make excuses for Clementine? Im talking about the 2 situations i.e Clem saving Lee from the walkers when he collapses and Sarah running away when something bad happens.
Lee could've gotten eaten had she left him on the streets when he collapsed (something Sarah would do) but no she pulled him into the shop. … moreI think we all can say that Clem is strong minded where as Sarah is not, but people will always make excuses for her.
Lee could've gotten eaten had she left him on the streets when he collapsed (something Sarah would do) but no she pulled him into the shop. … moreI think we all can say that Clem is strong minded where as Sarah is not, but people will always make excuses for her.
Giving shit to the stranger. I don't know why so many people tried to be nice to him. Even if you didn't steal, he still acts like a idiot a… morend causes the deaths of Ben, losing Kenny and Lee.
But the best choice is when his giving his life story about what happened to his family
* Lee : "You fucked up".
* Lee: "I'm bitten, and i'm going to make sure you end up the same way"/
Lee could've been very much the same hence when he said "They would've chewed me up".
Lol yes, but when i said "Sarah running away", that was directed to the fact that Sarah when in danger runs away or in ATR, just shuts down. Clem, could've left Lee but she managed to pull him inside a shop and close the roller door despite the fact that there were hundreds of walkers and her 2 parents who were killed she just saw.
Oh fuck no, that bitch is crazy. Saw her youtube where she would scorch any Kenny fan haha. But that thread that ID did about Luke being on the dlc or whatever because his voice actor tweeted a voice recording session, is pretty creepy lol, not too mention majority of her posts are about Luke.
Well it's a bit hard to talk shit face to face when i don't even know you, but trust me if i did, i wouldn't waste a second doing it.
If i was in a situation like Sarahs and i knew my old man wasn't getting out, i'd focus on the number 1 priority. Myself. I'd mourn his death after i'd got to safety. Why stand their a scream and bring walkers on yuorself or your group? Stupid.
If it's so absurd, why did telltale put that in? You sound like i was the one who put in that scene lol.
As Crawford would say, that reaction is by a weak person. But then again being hidden away from what the ZA was by her father caused that.
His an idiot. You could do EVERYTHING right and he'll still say you did something wrong. Not too mention he caused the death of the main character and others, i don't see why people should be nice to him.
Same here. I did my best to be a good guy throughout the season, but once that loser touched Clementine he was already dead to me.
Leaving his corpse to reanimate was pretty satisfying.
The saying "A dog's bark is bigger than its bite" applies to all the tough-guys in this fandom. I'm pretty sure you'd fall to pieces when faced with certain death - saying otherwise is only being in denial.
Well it's a bit hard to talk shit face to face when i don't even know you, but trust me if i did, i wouldn't waste a second doing it.
If i … morewas in a situation like Sarahs and i knew my old man wasn't getting out, i'd focus on the number 1 priority. Myself. I'd mourn his death after i'd got to safety. Why stand their a scream and bring walkers on yuorself or your group? Stupid.
If it's so absurd, why did telltale put that in? You sound like i was the one who put in that scene lol.
As Crawford would say, that reaction is by a weak person. But then again being hidden away from what the ZA was by her father caused that.
I have nothing to hide or fake about, im saying what i'd really do, you want to believe it or not, i can't change the way you think.
And im, not trying to be a tough guy, when did i ever say that? I said the way Sarah acted was weak and it is a like they say "Moment of weakness".
Like Luke with his "moment of weakness" when he was suppose to be watching for walkers but decides to go fuck Jane instead. If you want to go fuck someone, do it when you're not assigned a task to do. That's weak minded pal.
The saying "A dog's bark is bigger than its bite" applies to all the tough-guys in this fandom. I'm pretty sure you'd fall to pieces when faced with certain death - saying otherwise is only being in denial.
It's not Sarah's fault she reacted how most people would, right? She can't help it, just like Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten.
Carlos getting shot by stray bullet says nothing of his character; Sarah making noise whilst standing beside you (which she was doing before her father was shot, by the way), then screaming and running in a freaking zombie horde speaks to her ineptitude, which was shown time and time again.
[Sit With Luke]
I love Kenny just as much as Luke and if it was between those two and who I was to save it would be Kenny, but I accidently chose Luke the first time and the disappointment on Kennys face was fucking hilarious.
Criticising Sarah for being noisy in a zombie apocalypse is a weak argument when practically every other character were louder than her, including Bonnie who was firing an AK-47 in the crowd and somehow did not get bit by walkers behind her.
And running past the zombie hoard was a safer option than just standing there screaming and crying for her dead father, as evident by Luke and Nick (temporarily) doing the same thing by running after her.
It's not Sarah's fault she reacted how most people would, right? She can't help it, just like Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten.
… more
Carlos getting shot by stray bullet says nothing of his character; Sarah making noise whilst standing beside you (which she was doing before her father was shot, by the way), then screaming and running in a freaking zombie horde speaks to her ineptitude, which was shown time and time again.
Other characters acting stupid does not invalidate my criticisms of Sarah. You're analysis is wrong anyway as Bonnie only fired her gun to save the people who the walkers were attacking because of Sarah's screams.
And if you believe that running and bumping into walkers in massive walker horde is safer than calmly walking through them, then I don't know what to say.
Criticising Sarah for being noisy in a zombie apocalypse is a weak argument when practically every other character were louder than her, inc… moreluding Bonnie who was firing an AK-47 in the crowd and somehow did not get bit by walkers behind her.
And running past the zombie hoard was a safer option than just standing there screaming and crying for her dead father, as evident by Luke and Nick (temporarily) doing the same thing by running after her.
Expecting a fifteen year old girl to not scream after seeing her father die in a brutal manner is unreasonable, even in a situation where she's expected to be quiet such as the mass amount of walkers she has to sneak by. It's human nature to react as such when a loved one passes away in a brutal fashion, unless one were sociopathic who doesn't care about others.
Blaming her for the walker attack is also unreasonable, as the reason why she screamed in the first place was because Carver's goons shot him down by sheer bad luck and she had to watch her father being torn apart by the walkers. And if we were to go back a few scenes, she wouldn't even have to be out there in the first place if the group weren't so adamant about leaving the place so hastily while the hoard was still around. The entire group, sans Sarah and Clementine, were responsible for the risk of going out when they could have gone another night or so for the hoard to go away.
In the end Sarah did manage to escape from the hoard all by herself with no problems, as did Luke and Nick (determinant). Walking by the walkers calmly and quietly wasn't an option for her due to the circumstances, and yet she still managed to escape the hoard without a scratch.
Other characters acting stupid does not invalidate my criticisms of Sarah. You're analysis is wrong anyway as Bonnie only fired her gun to s… moreave the people who the walkers were attacking because of Sarah's screams.
And if you believe that running and bumping into walkers in massive walker horde is safer than calmly walking through them, then I don't know what to say.
I never said that I didn't "expect" her to not scream or run, just that her doing so was another non-thinking, careless act to add to the growing list of careless things she had done that make up her personality.
I don't see what's controversial about my comments, at all. Sarah was a burden and I, personally, did not want to waste time, energy and resources on such an unable person. That's it.
Expecting a fifteen year old girl to not scream after seeing her father die in a brutal manner is unreasonable, even in a situation where sh… moree's expected to be quiet such as the mass amount of walkers she has to sneak by. It's human nature to react as such when a loved one passes away in a brutal fashion, unless one were sociopathic who doesn't care about others.
Blaming her for the walker attack is also unreasonable, as the reason why she screamed in the first place was because Carver's goons shot him down by sheer bad luck and she had to watch her father being torn apart by the walkers. And if we were to go back a few scenes, she wouldn't even have to be out there in the first place if the group weren't so adamant about leaving the place so hastily while the hoard was still around. The entire group, sans Sarah and Clementine, were responsible for the risk of going out when they could have gone another night or so for the hoard to go away.… [view original content]
A careless act that ended up saving her from the walkers. Even if she calmed down shortly after seeing her father die, the walkers would have been onto her since she had no weapons as she was never given one. She had to run, it was the only option given to her if she wanted to survive. If continuing to say quiet and keep moving slowly after the commotion was what she was supposed to do, then she would have been killed by the walkers she inadvertently attracted or from the gunfire from Carver's goons.
And I would say that browbeating a young girl with PTSD and anxiety issues, and judging her based on how she can be of use to you rather than as a human being, is a mighty big controversial statement that won't gain you any sympathy points here.
I never said that I didn't "expect" her to not scream or run, just that her doing so was another non-thinking, careless act to add to the gr… moreowing list of careless things she had done that make up her personality.
I don't see what's controversial about my comments, at all. Sarah was a burden and I, personally, did not want to waste time, energy and resources on such an unable person. That's it.
Go with Nick at the end of episode 1. 'Cause we got to know a lot more about Nick, and his dialogue doesn't appear at a random moment. xD
Look away instead of shooting Kenny, too. Not like I really LOVE that choice but you know, I'm with Kenny. XD
And I would say that...judging her based on how she can be of use to you rather than as a human being, is a mighty big controversial statement that won't gain you any sympathy points here.
DUDE. It's the zombie apocalypse. Of course I'm looking out for how people can be of use to me. Seriously. Why would I just go around letting uncapable people drag me down?
You know, for all the sympathy you're oh-so happily dispensing onto others you are forgetting to give some to Clem, because to make her stay with people like Ben & Sarah is like putting a 50kg weight around her ankle.
A careless act that ended up saving her from the walkers. Even if she calmed down shortly after seeing her father die, the walkers would hav… moree been onto her since she had no weapons as she was never given one. She had to run, it was the only option given to her if she wanted to survive. If continuing to say quiet and keep moving slowly after the commotion was what she was supposed to do, then she would have been killed by the walkers she inadvertently attracted or from the gunfire from Carver's goons.
And I would say that browbeating a young girl with PTSD and anxiety issues, and judging her based on how she can be of use to you rather than as a human being, is a mighty big controversial statement that won't gain you any sympathy points here.
The choice of whether or not to kill Andy. The presentation is just ingenious in its simplicity, the path of the killer or the path to your friends and your own redemption, coupled with the amazing rainy atmosphere, music, and voice acting. You really feel the impact of your choice. As for what I personally choose, I'll typically choose to kill him because the looks of shock and fear on everyone's face, especially Clementine's look of almost terrified confusion, just adds even more power to the moment. Carley's sad shake of her head when you kill Andy is also one of my favorite subtle character actions because it's only seen for a second, but communicates such a strong sense of failure to see the one person who has always been encouraging to Lee despite his past actions show disappointment in his current actions and the path he has chosen.
Lee could've gotten eaten had she left him on the streets when he collapsed (something Sarah would do) but no she pulled him into the shop. … moreI think we all can say that Clem is strong minded where as Sarah is not, but people will always make excuses for her.
There was no way she could even save Carlos? You're acting like she could have done something, when in reality, she couldn't. It's called being in the heat of the moment.
When did i ever say people don't make excuses for Clementine? Im talking about the 2 situations i.e Clem saving Lee from the walkers when he collapses and Sarah running away when something bad happens.
Lee could've been very much the same hence when he said "They would've chewed me up".
Lol yes, but when i said "Sarah running away", that … morewas directed to the fact that Sarah when in danger runs away or in ATR, just shuts down. Clem, could've left Lee but she managed to pull him inside a shop and close the roller door despite the fact that there were hundreds of walkers and her 2 parents who were killed she just saw.
If you didn't realize, I was being sarcastic. I was saying something exactly how you were saying it, it's called mocking. Please read a dictionary. And by your logic, Sarah was supposed to know that her father was going to be eaten alive and shouldn't have done anything about it.
Wow, talk about a backstep.
Saying that Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten but previously saying that he had failed at not getting eat… moreen and being killed. Logic?
By your logic, Carlos should've known a random bullet was coming at him, but then you might change your opinion again.
Comments
TOP favourite: Letting Kenny kill jane
Other choices
1. Not leaving Sarah behing
2. Hugged Kenny ( 3 times)
3. Stopped Kenny from shooting Alvin
4. Left Lilly behind
5. Saving Carley
6. Letting Kenny beat Arvo
7. Helping Duck
8. Helping Kenny
9. Giving food to Clem, Kenny, Carley, Duck
10. Trusting Carley
It's not Sarah's fault she reacted how most people would, right? She can't help it, just like Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten.
I was thinking ,
What would be Clem´s reaction if Lee got eaten while escaping the Marsh House?
Probably Sarah's reaction? Maybe not, she'd probably just cry really loudly and scream out Lee's name. Maybe not as death-like like Sarah did. But her little squeal, you know?
Watching Kenny kill Carver, killing The Stranger, killing Duck, not picking up the gun, staying with Kenny, feeding Clementine, making Clem curse and drink, and killing Larry.
Wow, talk about a backstep.
Saying that Carlos couldn't help getting shot/eaten but previously saying that he had failed at not getting eaten and being killed. Logic?
By your logic, Carlos should've known a random bullet was coming at him, but then you might change your opinion again.
Lee could've gotten eaten had she left him on the streets when he collapsed (something Sarah would do) but no she pulled him into the shop. I think we all can say that Clem is strong minded where as Sarah is not, but people will always make excuses for her.
Maybe in their heads, every characters have the spider man 6 sens power.
[removed]
And people make excuses for Clem too
When did i ever say people don't make excuses for Clementine? Im talking about the 2 situations i.e Clem saving Lee from the walkers when he collapses and Sarah running away when something bad happens.
Well is you are comparing the 2 moments (Escaping the Marsh House in NTL and the herd in IHW) Carlos was already eaten alive :P
Sounds like projection lol. You seriously comparing her to crazy pedophile Lexie? There's zillions of "[Character I Like] Isn't Dead" threads
[removed]
[removed]
Same here. I did my best to be a good guy throughout the season, but once that loser touched Clementine he was already dead to me.
Leaving his corpse to reanimate was pretty satisfying.
Lee could've been very much the same hence when he said "They would've chewed me up".
Lol yes, but when i said "Sarah running away", that was directed to the fact that Sarah when in danger runs away or in ATR, just shuts down. Clem, could've left Lee but she managed to pull him inside a shop and close the roller door despite the fact that there were hundreds of walkers and her 2 parents who were killed she just saw.
Oh fuck no, that bitch is crazy. Saw her youtube where she would scorch any Kenny fan haha. But that thread that ID did about Luke being on the dlc or whatever because his voice actor tweeted a voice recording session, is pretty creepy lol, not too mention majority of her posts are about Luke.
Well it's a bit hard to talk shit face to face when i don't even know you, but trust me if i did, i wouldn't waste a second doing it.
If i was in a situation like Sarahs and i knew my old man wasn't getting out, i'd focus on the number 1 priority. Myself. I'd mourn his death after i'd got to safety. Why stand their a scream and bring walkers on yuorself or your group? Stupid.
If it's so absurd, why did telltale put that in? You sound like i was the one who put in that scene lol.
As Crawford would say, that reaction is by a weak person. But then again being hidden away from what the ZA was by her father caused that.
His an idiot. You could do EVERYTHING right and he'll still say you did something wrong. Not too mention he caused the death of the main character and others, i don't see why people should be nice to him.
The saying "A dog's bark is bigger than its bite" applies to all the tough-guys in this fandom. I'm pretty sure you'd fall to pieces when faced with certain death - saying otherwise is only being in denial.
I have nothing to hide or fake about, im saying what i'd really do, you want to believe it or not, i can't change the way you think.
And im, not trying to be a tough guy, when did i ever say that? I said the way Sarah acted was weak and it is a like they say "Moment of weakness".
Like Luke with his "moment of weakness" when he was suppose to be watching for walkers but decides to go fuck Jane instead. If you want to go fuck someone, do it when you're not assigned a task to do. That's weak minded pal.
Carlos getting shot by stray bullet says nothing of his character; Sarah making noise whilst standing beside you (which she was doing before her father was shot, by the way), then screaming and running in a freaking zombie horde speaks to her ineptitude, which was shown time and time again.
[Shoot Kenny]
[Sit With Luke]
I love Kenny just as much as Luke and if it was between those two and who I was to save it would be Kenny, but I accidently chose Luke the first time and the disappointment on Kennys face was fucking hilarious.
Criticising Sarah for being noisy in a zombie apocalypse is a weak argument when practically every other character were louder than her, including Bonnie who was firing an AK-47 in the crowd and somehow did not get bit by walkers behind her.
And running past the zombie hoard was a safer option than just standing there screaming and crying for her dead father, as evident by Luke and Nick (temporarily) doing the same thing by running after her.
Other characters acting stupid does not invalidate my criticisms of Sarah. You're analysis is wrong anyway as Bonnie only fired her gun to save the people who the walkers were attacking because of Sarah's screams.
And if you believe that running and bumping into walkers in massive walker horde is safer than calmly walking through them, then I don't know what to say.
Okay it's not really a choice, more of an option, but... Use pillow on window
"What are you going to do with that?"
"I don't know"
That just completely ruined the moment
It was perfect
Expecting a fifteen year old girl to not scream after seeing her father die in a brutal manner is unreasonable, even in a situation where she's expected to be quiet such as the mass amount of walkers she has to sneak by. It's human nature to react as such when a loved one passes away in a brutal fashion, unless one were sociopathic who doesn't care about others.
Blaming her for the walker attack is also unreasonable, as the reason why she screamed in the first place was because Carver's goons shot him down by sheer bad luck and she had to watch her father being torn apart by the walkers. And if we were to go back a few scenes, she wouldn't even have to be out there in the first place if the group weren't so adamant about leaving the place so hastily while the hoard was still around. The entire group, sans Sarah and Clementine, were responsible for the risk of going out when they could have gone another night or so for the hoard to go away.
In the end Sarah did manage to escape from the hoard all by herself with no problems, as did Luke and Nick (determinant). Walking by the walkers calmly and quietly wasn't an option for her due to the circumstances, and yet she still managed to escape the hoard without a scratch.
I never said that I didn't "expect" her to not scream or run, just that her doing so was another non-thinking, careless act to add to the growing list of careless things she had done that make up her personality.
I don't see what's controversial about my comments, at all. Sarah was a burden and I, personally, did not want to waste time, energy and resources on such an unable person. That's it.
A careless act that ended up saving her from the walkers. Even if she calmed down shortly after seeing her father die, the walkers would have been onto her since she had no weapons as she was never given one. She had to run, it was the only option given to her if she wanted to survive. If continuing to say quiet and keep moving slowly after the commotion was what she was supposed to do, then she would have been killed by the walkers she inadvertently attracted or from the gunfire from Carver's goons.
And I would say that browbeating a young girl with PTSD and anxiety issues, and judging her based on how she can be of use to you rather than as a human being, is a mighty big controversial statement that won't gain you any sympathy points here.
Picking the rifle back up, after it knocked Clem on her ass. Then blowing a baseball sized hole in that walker's head.
Go with Nick at the end of episode 1. 'Cause we got to know a lot more about Nick, and his dialogue doesn't appear at a random moment. xD
Look away instead of shooting Kenny, too. Not like I really LOVE that choice but you know, I'm with Kenny. XD
DUDE. It's the zombie apocalypse. Of course I'm looking out for how people can be of use to me. Seriously. Why would I just go around letting uncapable people drag me down?
You know, for all the sympathy you're oh-so happily dispensing onto others you are forgetting to give some to Clem, because to make her stay with people like Ben & Sarah is like putting a 50kg weight around her ankle.
The choice of whether or not to kill Andy. The presentation is just ingenious in its simplicity, the path of the killer or the path to your friends and your own redemption, coupled with the amazing rainy atmosphere, music, and voice acting. You really feel the impact of your choice. As for what I personally choose, I'll typically choose to kill him because the looks of shock and fear on everyone's face, especially Clementine's look of almost terrified confusion, just adds even more power to the moment. Carley's sad shake of her head when you kill Andy is also one of my favorite subtle character actions because it's only seen for a second, but communicates such a strong sense of failure to see the one person who has always been encouraging to Lee despite his past actions show disappointment in his current actions and the path he has chosen.
Excuse you, what make you think Sarah would leave someone on the streets? Did you even pay any attention to her character arc at all?
There was no way she could even save Carlos? You're acting like she could have done something, when in reality, she couldn't. It's called being in the heat of the moment.
And who's to say Sarah wouldn't do the same? Take a good look at Sarah's character, because you don't seem to be doing that at all.
This ^ Haha
If you didn't realize, I was being sarcastic. I was saying something exactly how you were saying it, it's called mocking. Please read a dictionary. And by your logic, Sarah was supposed to know that her father was going to be eaten alive and shouldn't have done anything about it.
So please, grasp the basic concept of being rekt.