Which Clementine do you prefer (S1 or S2)?
We all love Clementine, but I just wanted everyone's opinion, if you prefer the younger Clementine (as seen in S1) or the older Clementine (as seen in S2), which one would it be?
I prefer the Season 1 Clementine partially because then, she was more adorable, and you had to protect her; unlike in season 2 in which she was fully capable.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I'm going to be in the minority here and say Season 2 Clementine. I loved her in Season 1, don't get me wrong, but I just love what I have made her into in Season 2. The point of Season 2 was deciding who your Clementine has become, we are given control of her character and we take her in the direction we want her to go in. Not only that, but she has become more mature and independent, which I like and I see a lot of myself in her Season 2 characteristics.
i just wish we had seen clementine 1.5 (when she was with omid and christa) we basically missed her transformation from scared little girl to stone cold badass, and i think that is why season 2 clementine is so jarring and barely believable
ZA will change you... so i'm okay with clementine...
I prefer season 1, but here I made you a strawpoll.
Which Clementine do you prefer?
I like her personailty in Season 1 better. She was just so adorable,caring, and nice. Not that I have anything against her Season 2 personality either.
Should be the third option "both".
I don't know which one to choose so I'll say both. I can't decide if I like season 1 Clementine more than season 2 Clementine or season 2 more then the other one. I think that she's awesome in both in her own way.
Clementine is Clementine in both Seasons, people just experience changes and as long as Clementine doesn't kill people for no justifiable reason or become her enemies and what she feared then I'll like her, which accounts for both Seasons. In Season 2 my Clementine managed to save people, to take care of herself, to learn how to survive with and without a group so I kind of like Season 2 Clementine more.
Or the fourth option, "neither".
Season 1 because in Season 2 she had become an absolutely cold, cruel and scary person.
.
Joking aside, my answer is S2 Clemmy, she is naturally caring, adorable and friendly while being mature & strong
They're the same person. I like them both equally but S2 Clementine's sassier, which is always funny.
True.
Season 2 because she's darker and more badass.
I like S2 Clementine.
Season 2 although I love her in Season 1 too.
Both?
Silly question. Season 1 Clem is much much better character than that boring 12 years old zombie slayer from infamous, half-baked second season.
Season 2 Clem was more awesome.
Season two Clementine...
She's basically the little girl equivalent of Ash from Evil Dead.
S1 Clem and S2 Clem are the same person. I love both equally.
season 2
She is cold, cruel and scary if you make her like this, because you play as her
Huh... Its funny cause I expect 70% of the comments would've show negative views about Season 2 Clem, saying how cold and evil she was and all that jazz. Any I prefer Season 2 Clem, but still love Season 1 Clem too. : )
Season 1 Clem: Shows you a fragile girl in the BEGIN of the ZA.
Season 2 Clem: Shows a girl, who grows up in a ZA after one year and six months. We don't know what she spent with Christa, people change, imagine in a ZA then.
No matter the Season, Clem is awesome
Neither, and that's because you actually play as Clementine in the second season so it's hard to compare.
That's my point. People always change, Clem can't be a fragile little girl forever, she's growing up.
Crescendo é pouco! Clementine já passou por tanta coisa... Enquanto isso, ninguém reclama do Carl da HQ, dos furos da série de TV... O quê eles queriam? Depois da garota ver tanta gente morrer, perder o Lee, suturar a sí mesma, ver o bebê de Christa morrer ( possívelmente ), e ela ainda mantém a humanidade. Desculpa por postar em português, mas eu precisava desabafar com você :v
I dont particularly like either of them but season 1 was better for me
Sem problemas, só daqui a pouco vem um pessoal reclamar pra gente falar em inglês kkkk.
Mas é verdade, não entendo quem quer ver ela igual em todo jogo, do final da S1 até os acontecimentos da S2 se passaram mais de 20 meses eu acho (os 16 meses + pelo menos uns 4 meses, já que a Christa já tá com barriga no início do jogo, diferente do final da S1). Seria até meio chato controlar uma Clementine frágil e infantil, ela não teria autonomia nenhuma kkk
Sim, foram 20 meses, os dois meses do Starved for Help + O pulo no começo do EP 1 da segunda temporada ( Que não é comentado, mas eu acho que são 5 ou 6 meses depois, porque Clem estava com 9 anos no final da segunda temporada e fica com 11 na segunda ) + 16 meses later. E outra, a gente nem sabe o quê ela passou com Christa! Imagine a dor de ver uma criança nascer morta ( como em Amid The Ruins, quando AJ nasce e ela fala '' De novo não '' ). Sem contar que Christa no começo da segunda temporada falava de maneira bem madura com ela: '' Você que deveria fazer isso Clem, não eu ''. Possívelmente Christa ficou de coraçaun endurecido depois da morte de Omid e Clementine amadureceu com ela. Controlar ela na segunda temporada foi bem tranquilo, pois não tinha opções badass, e se ajeitavam bem á uma criança. Sei lá, imagina se ela matasse o Carver por exemplo ._.
Simmm, as opções era bem tranquilas, ela não ficou tão fria como muita gente reclama, ela só mudou um pouco devido as circunstâncias né. O pessoal só fica se doendo porque sentem saudade daquela imagem 'fofinha' dela no primeiro jogo kkkk sem contar que isso depende também do jogador né, a minha Clementine tentou sempre manter a humanidade dela, sempre tentou ajudar quem precisava, etc :P
Ah, não vou mentir, eu falei merda para umas pessoas ali e aqui, mas tranquilo u.u
Enfim, valeu pelo papo xD
Um pouco eu também, se eu não gostava da pessoa kkkk valeu também haha