Bonnie was never at the Ski Lodge
Soooo hypothetically speaking...
Bonnie never finds the cabin group at Kenny's Ski Lodge in episode 2. That means Carver and his people never show up and the zombie attack on the Ski Lodge is handled with no incident. Now after all this, Walter tells the truth to everyone about what happened to Matthew and Kenny demands the Cabin group to leave. You are Clem and have to choose. Stay with Kenny at the Ski Lodge for the time being or hit the road and head out with the Cabin Group. Both obviously have advantages and disadvantages, but I would like to hear your opinion on who you would choose and why?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
The Cabin Group! Because they're my favourite characters in Season 2 and I had decided at the time if there was a choice I would go with the Cabin Group because I wouldn't just leave the people that had become friends with Clementine despite having such a bad start. Also I never trusted Kenny and didn't like him that much in episode 2.
The Cabin Crew!
Because... Luke!;D
In all seriousness though, I really wanted Clem to stay with the Cabin Crew because they seemed like nice, level headed people ( sure they may have locked her in the shed but I can't blame them, after bringing in someone with a bite who actually turned into a walker I understand why they wanted to be sure about Clem.)
Cabin group because they had a medic
the cabin group lel
Seeing that we just saw Kenny again, and having a bad start with The Cabin Group. I would've most likely stayed with Kenny.
Stay with the lodge group. It had Kenny, Walter was a nice guy and also one of my favorite characters, and they were planning on moving up to Wellington. Plus, the cabin group was being hunted, even if Bonnie didn't show up, that doesn't mean that Carver wasn't still tracking them. With the lodge group, I don't have to worry about being captured.
The ski lodge group. I never got over the fact that the cabin group locked Clem away in that shed with winter temperatures, injured, and walkers near by. Kenny knew Lee and Clementine and was well armed. Walter weren't bad either and Sarita was nice. They were planning on moving up to Wellington, which Christa had told Clementine about. Also, I prefer the smaller groups.
I would have to stay at the lodge. I told Kenny and Walter that I wanted to stay there. I didn't want Clem to have to run anymore and with Carver after them I didn't want to stay. Kenny mentioned Wellington and that's where Christa and Clem were headed
Id probably stay at the lodge, at that point the only character I liked from the Cabin group was Luke
Fuck the cabin group I'm staying with Kenny.
A lot of people don't understand that the people we were just with just locked us into a shed forcing us into desperate measures with Clementines' arm, I get that they were trying to keep safe and locking an 11 year old defenseless girl in the shed is the best possible situation right now, but seriously? Also, I knew as soon as I saw the cabin group that they didn't have their shit together, with Rebecaa being pregnant and worried about Carver finding them and with Nick still probably being depressed about his mothers death which I don't blame him for but not a good situation to be in.. Carlos locking his child inside and keeping her from the outside world and seeing walkers and shit. The only real sane people were the two original people that I liked in the group, Luke and Uncle Pete. Then Uncle Pete died and their were all these other people and the only person I liked in the group was Luke, I didn't mind Alvin but everyone else I didn't like at all.
Then we get to the lodge and their is Kenny, which I was so fucking happy about, his girlfriend and what would have been two men together in a stable relationship. They had their shit together, 4 people which had food, guns, ammunition, power and were at the top of a hill so they could see the incoming from down below.
So yes I would have stayed at the lodge with Kenny and shit because they had their shit together unlike the other group, which I was not comfortable with Clem being around, and I felt so much more safer with Kenny and Walter and shit. Have a nice day
Yeah, locking her her in her in the shed is unnecessary; 6 adults couldn't take on a kid should they need to? They could've secluded her in the house and restrained her overnight. Waiting til morning is a possible death sentence
Cabin group, I can't stand Kenny.
I'm not going to be one of those people that just says "fuck the cabin group because they locked Clem in the shed" because I have seen those types of people and they are annoying, I do understand why they did lock her in the shed, but they should have at least disinfected it or something I mean come on.
True, I did not rule out that Carver was still looking for them.
sigh Luke is definitely the person that has me doubting to stay with Kenny or not. Although in my play-through the whole cabin group seem to get along with Clem like one of their own.
That feel when I'm one of those people... lol
I'd stay with Kenny obviously. Walter and Sarita were nice too. I found the cabin group pretty annoying, even Luke...
Relationships aside, Kenny does have his shit together. That zombie attack may have been a fluke and even so the house still stands and no one died. Safety would be an important concern and the Ski Lodge may be the lesser evil. Although the conversation with Kenny mentions heading to Wellington at some point with his people and that may be the same as going with the Cabin group. The thing is, is that Sarita or Walter or maybe even Matthew knew exactly where Wellington is in relation to the Ski Lodge so chances of making it their with no trouble would be greater, but who knows it's all speculation.
Yeah Luke was really nice I'm gonna miss him:( He is one of the main reasons I wanted to stay with the Cabin Crew, along with the fact that we had just met them and they took Clementine in and treated her as a part of the group (maybe not right away but eventually) so I didn't want to go and sit with Kenny because I felt like it would be kind of a kick in their faces like 'Kenny's here now I don't need you anymore...' You know?
The Cabin Group, for sure. MyLee didn't see eye to eye with Kenny too often, which led to arguments in front of Clem. So I think MyClem would like to stay with Sarah and Luke. Rather than a weird acting Kenny and and an emotionally hurt Walter.
the lodge group let's be honest putting character preferences aside clem would be a lot safer with kenny considering carver was still after the cabin group plus they had food and supplies etc at the lodge
Neither. Go off on my own and get away from all the assholes and fuck-ups of both groups, maybe look for Christa?
Anything's better than what either group can give (or take).
See what I mean Bonnie fucks things up in every way you could think. That actually sounded like a fun choice to have but as usual Bonnie fucked it up like she does everything else in her sad drug addled life. She's the only character in TWD I have hated with this strong of a passion. Fucking junkie
FUCKBONNIE
Really, what about Jane?
Jane was a vindictive, lying piece of shit and died a weasel's death. As much as I hate her at least she wasn't mentally weak and stupid as Bonnie was. Bonnie was a leech that sucked on to survive (probably literal too) She depended on Dee and Leland, she depended on Carver she would die alone in a pathetic way if she wasn't always having her hand held.
Cabin group, heck, I would've stayed with Crawford if it was to get away from that nightmare of a person at the lodge.
Speaking of Bonnie, I MISS YOU.
I'd abandon both to escape the madness.
If I was playing the episode for the first time, lodge group. Kenny had, or at least seemed to, have his shit together, also Sarita and Walter had a much better first impression than the cabin group did. The only one I fully trusted at the time was Luke.
If I knew everything about what would happen if Carver did show up, then Cabin group. Because they're awesome.
Regardless of the cottage group's crappy behavior after meeting them (that jerk was no doctor because he he doesn't recognize the difference between a dog or human bite) they would've been my choice. Only had beef with Rebecca, silly doctor and Luke throwing me on the ground (Luke had to be retarded to think I was going in split seconds) and stupid Nick that shoots anything or anyone on sight. I dislike Kenny more than any of them combined... did my best to kill him in Season 1 to no avail.
lel bai kenny
I would pick the cabin group, obviously. IMO, Luke > Kenny anyday. But I really would love to take Sarita with me.
That was a good one.
Damn! So reluctantly stay with the cabin group? I guess you would look for an out from the group if it presented itself.
Cabin Group
Even if Bonnie didn´t show up that night , if we stayed Carver could come across he will recognize Clem and the we wouldn´t know what would he do. Also i think that Kenny and Sarita (and possibly Walter) were going north to find Wellington , so maybe both groups could leave the ski lodge
Kenny.
I wouldn't have cared for the cabin group back then... I don't really care about them right now after their deaths (with a few exceptions) because, you know... LACK OF CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT.
Kenny. Whatever his other failings, Kenny never locked me in a tool shed to die.
Amen. Who the hell are these people? Who was Alvin? Who was Carlos? Who was Pete? Who was Rebecca? I still couldn't really tell you beyond a very rough sketch of surface personality traits, some of which changed depending on the writer and the episode.
Kenny: Now Clementine, you're not going to abandon your dear old friend for these hitchhiking assholes now are you.
Luke: Ahem, the 'hitchhiking assholes' in question, happen to be friends of the Clementine too.
Nick: Yeah, and with our powers combine, we can summon Captain Planet!
Clem: o_O...
Luke: And we uh, have chocolate >_> chocolate is good.
Clem: =D I'll get my coat!
Sarah: Yaaaay!
Kenny: You god damn pieces of shit!
Cabin group, I love them too much XD
I know, right? I mean, when their deaths did occur, none of the other characters fucking cared! So why should I care? That's the point! Why should I care, Telltale?! I don't know, you don't give me a reason.
Not only would I stay with Kenny because the cabin group don't match up to him... It's also because he's my favourite character and I would've just gotten back with him at the time. So yeah, Kenny all the way.
It's always the chocolate!
My Clementine hates chocolate, so she's staying with Kenny.