Ranking the villains in terms of evil

I thought it would be interesting to give my thoughts on each villain. Note this will not involve central character ex: Kenny, Jane etc. Only characters have proved a direct legitimate obstacle on the protagonist's life

1. Danny St. John: This guy like I've said in a previous thread is the worst of all because he takes the most pleasure in raping, murdering and cannibalism

Alt text

2. Crawford Oberson: Even though a minor character most people get the message. He killed the old, sick and even children and thought nothing of it. He had enough guilt to hang himself

Alt text

3. Save- Lots Bandits: These guys were straight up animals. They were thugs, rapists, killers and even murdered their own people and raped a girl hardly older than Clementine.

Alt text

4. Carver: People often say he was the worse but he at least offered a reason for what he did. His reasoning for things is delusional and he's a thug with no moral standards. He uses manipulation and black mail to hurt people and likes it

Alt text

5. The Russian Group: We don't know much about them.but from what we can assume they're bullies and thieves and since they were willing to shoot an entire group with two children shows just about how ruthless they are

Alt text

6. The Stranger: Not a villain in my eyes but was an unstable danger to Lee and a kidnapper. He's the lowest on this list because he's more or less broken and trying to substitute his dead family with Clementine

Alt text

Comments

    1. Carver
    2. The St. John's
    3. The Stranger
    4. Arvo, Mike, and Bonnie
    5. Michelle (killing Omid automatically makes you a villain)
    6. Larry (then again, he's more of an antagonist than a villain)
    7. Save Lots Bandits
    8. Winston
    9. Russian Group
  • this is the kind of stuff that's going to cause people to get upset, it almost feels like a trigger to make people feel upset.

    1:

  • edited February 2015

    It is an arguable position.

    colgato posted: »

    this is the kind of stuff that's going to cause people to get upset, it almost feels like a trigger to make people feel upset.

  • You forgot a few,

    Alt text

    Alt text

    Alt text

    How many people died over this plot device?

  • The bandits raped a little girl and were about to kill two children how is Larry worse?

    * Carver * The St. John's * The Stranger * Arvo, Mike, and Bonnie * Michelle (killing Omid automatically makes you a villain) * Larry (then again, he's more of an antagonist than a villain) * Save Lots Bandits * Winston * Russian Group

  • Um, Aj definitely does not count as a villain.

    If causing death indirectly makes you a villain then Clementine's a villain.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    You forgot a few, How many people died over this plot device?

  • Why not? Aj was the reason why Season two was such a letdown imo. I'm blaming him for something.

    Flog61 posted: »

    Um, Aj definitely does not count as a villain. If causing death indirectly makes you a villain then Clementine's a villain.

  • edited February 2015

    Because villains do their bad deeds on purpose.

    A baby isn't capable of performing 'bad deeds'.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    Why not? Aj was the reason why Season two was such a letdown imo. I'm blaming him for something.

    1. The St. Johns
    2. Carver
    3. Save-Lots
    4. Stranger
    5. Russian Group
  • TWDG is so unrealistic, it is funny. That newborn would of died before Rebecca in RL. So i don't really use the realistic sense of the word villain, just someone to point the finger at for all the letdowns and disappointments that came with Season two.

    Flog61 posted: »

    Because villains do their bad deeds on purpose. A baby isn't capable of performing 'bad deeds'.

  • The russians weren't really evil because you determinately start it by stealing from them.

  • Larry

    Finally! Some human notices that he had to go! I did you all a favor! :P

    * Carver * The St. John's * The Stranger * Arvo, Mike, and Bonnie * Michelle (killing Omid automatically makes you a villain) * Larry (then again, he's more of an antagonist than a villain) * Save Lots Bandits * Winston * Russian Group

  • I'm not denying they are evil, but it seems that their only purpose for being in the game was to get us to leave the Motor Inn. The St. Johns were keeping them at bay from attacking us before and we never saw any of the other bandit attacks on the Motor Inn. Other than the last attack, they were always just kind of there, an over looming threat that didn't really do anything. Larry, on the other hand, threatened to tell everyone about Lee's past, will always act like an asshole to you no matter what you do, and pretty much blames you for everything. It was an ordeal putting up with him for 2 episodes.

    Clemenem posted: »

    The bandits raped a little girl and were about to kill two children how is Larry worse?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.