Theories you Heard/Had in the past that sound stupid now
Before the episodes are released, there is speculation galore on the forums. Some of the speculation goes from reasonable such as Christa might be pregnant to bat shit crazy like Lee is in purgatory. This is one of the theories that I heard before Clem was revealed as the S2 PC. "Clementine definitely won't be the protagonists of Season 2 because TT won't want to show her getting killed every time you fuck up." Another one I heard was that Kenny was Carver(before they showed him). So, what about you guys?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
That Sarah would be the sole survivor of the cabin group, but in the end, no one did.
I wish people were right, they probably thought telltale wasnt heartless enough to do it
EDIT: due to 2 comments below me, i got reminded of the time someone thought Kenny already knew Carver before episode 2, now THAT was a stupid theory
The predictions for who would be killed in the gun fight.
Everyone wondering who would be dead just for everyone to be A-okay, after all the speculations
Imagine if Kenny was Carver...
No... what if Carver was... Kenny!
I think I saw somewhere that someone was trying to come up with a reason as to why Lee would come back in Season 2 because he wasn't really dead. Not like I wanted to admit it either, but at that point you're definitely in denial.
Kenny couldn't deal with the loss of his family so he changed his name to Carver
Lee IS alive
Lily would be at Carver's and be his second in command
There was a choice between Luke and Kenny.
We would go to the town in Episode 5.
We could kill Arvo in or after the shootout.
That Eddie would be in Amid The Ruins.
Lee is alive.
You could name the baby.
400 Days characters will have major role. (Nate, Eddie, everyone not Bonnie.)
That the 400 Days characters would play a major role in S2
If you save Sarah at the trailer then Jane would get grabbed instead.
But my personal favorite is when I first saw Arvo limping towards the deck...
I thought he was Christa.
That Nick was Kenny in the first trailer and that Season 2 would really focus on Clem and Sarah's relationship.
Someone in the group would die in the shootout.
XD
Kenny dying
Funny, I thought I was the only one who considered that possibility. Even so, I never posted it on account of it being so implausible.
Speaking of which:
Mind you, I still think these are better ideas than what Season 2 actually gave us!
Lee would be the, "I thought you were dead."
I remember this when the season 2 trailer was released, people where comparing different pics of Kenny to a 1 second scene from the trailer CSI style :P.
that was stupid to begin with though
Somebody thought that Andy St. John would have been the guy to return in Episode 2. Disregarding that, y'know, he died in virtually everyone's playthrough.
When I saw the "In harm's way" trailer I thought Carver was gonna kill Kenny with the Walkie-Talkie at that point.
Also in the trailer, when I saw the herd coming I thought Carver was gonna teach Clem how to shoot an assualt rifle ......(I thought they were gonna develop a father/daughter relationship)
Remember when everyone thought Carver was Steve?
I thought it was him
That's such an old theory, the nostalgia is coming back lol.
Thinking back, I think the season might have been better if Carver was Steve.
Exactly.
....That Telltale would explain how Kenny survived the herd in later episodes beyond just "I got lucky. Real lucky."
That was deliberate. Telltale talked about how "Kenny's fate will be explored" prior to the trailer's release, and deliberately included a shot of Nick from the back to evoke player memories of Kenny's initial appearance.
Hell, I wonder if Nick was really intended to be a "sneak peek" of Kenny and if that was why he was tossed aside like trash once Kenny entered the picture.
There is significance in the fact that Carver introduces himself as looking for "seven people." Included in that group were "a teacher and his wife" and "a girl [around Russell's age] and her dad."
Remember when the Season 2 trailer came out and we all thought Pete was Kenny?
that matthew actually survived the fall and bullet to the neck and was actually found and tortured by carver and that is how they knew the group was at the ski lodge omg that was bad
oh and every theory about lee being alive
Not in mine...
When he yelled for me to get back there and finish him.
I wasn't giving him the satisfaction.
Maybe Pete used to tell everyone he was a cop...
Kenny is a good character.
honestly most of the returning character theories from episode 2 were stupid glenn, andy, danny, some even said lee and were dead serious about it
You know, I always thought Nick looked like Kenny.
Ummmmm, about that.......
Glenn, really...
Someone said that?
oooooooo shots fired haha