Theories you Heard/Had in the past that sound stupid now

2

Comments

  • edited February 2015

    not just someone, a lot of people said it even though we would show them why that can't happen

    Glenn, really... Someone said that?

  • Mike is Ralph

    This was actually supposed to happen, but due to time constraints, it was removed.

    JakeSt123 posted: »

    * Luke’s name is ‘Nick’ * Nick is Kenny * Omid & Christa will live for a decent amount of time * Victor/Christa/Vernon/Lilly/Molly/Le

  • I guess they were all people that don't read the comics.

    Jewfreeus posted: »

    not just someone, a lot of people said it even though we would show them why that can't happen

  • i'm guessing only a few of them were considering some didn't change their mind once we showed them he died in the comic

    I guess they were all people that don't read the comics.

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator
    edited February 2015

    I don't remember anything about time constraints. Where'd you hear that?

    Mike is Ralph This was actually supposed to happen, but due to time constraints, it was removed.

  • i think he means non-determinantly

  • that isnt a theory you silly willy goose, thats an opinion

    Gary-Oak posted: »

    Kenny is a good character.

  • It was probably for the best. We can't have people in denial.

    Jewfreeus posted: »

    i'm guessing only a few of them were considering some didn't change their mind once we showed them he died in the comic

  • -Rebecca is Lee's ex wife

    -the 400 day characters ended up in Wellington instead of Howe"s

  • A good opinion. :^)

    colgato posted: »

    that isnt a theory you silly willy goose, thats an opinion

  • http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/71545/details-that-people-might-forget-don-t-notice-or-just-don-t-know-about/p140

    AndWeAllFallDown said that he/she interviewed Dan White and asked him why it was removed and that's what he said. He/she has posted other information on Mike and other characters in the past as well and has even posted Dan White audition tapes I believe as well. Granted I'm not sure how reliable since he/she could obviously be lying, but I think he/she is telling the truth.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    I don't remember anything about time constraints. Where'd you hear that?

  • Alt text

    Gary-Oak posted: »

    Kenny is a good character.

  • Arvo is a middle aged drug addict

    Alt text

    JakeSt123 posted: »

    * Luke’s name is ‘Nick’ * Nick is Kenny * Omid & Christa will live for a decent amount of time * Victor/Christa/Vernon/Lilly/Molly/Le

  • Andy's death was even more strongly implied than Kenny's was. The guy's broken, surrounded by zombies, and his brother is at best one-legged bait. If anything, electrocuting him was actually merciful compared to letting him get eaten alive.

    Not in mine... When he yelled for me to get back there and finish him. I wasn't giving him the satisfaction.

  • Rebecca is Russell's grandma

    Courtesy of TVTropes.

    Yo-da-Man posted: »

    -Rebecca is Lee's ex wife -the 400 day characters ended up in Wellington instead of Howe"s

  • Yep, that's why I marched my ass out of there and let him be. Especially when you see him sulking and Walker Brenda is shuffling out of the house.

    Bokor posted: »

    Andy's death was even more strongly implied than Kenny's was. The guy's broken, surrounded by zombies, and his brother is at best one-legged bait. If anything, electrocuting him was actually merciful compared to letting him get eaten alive.

  • Just let it go man, no need to bring back a stupid argument over a difference in opinions.

    Gary-Oak posted: »

    A good opinion. :^)

  • Maybe he got "really, really lucky"?

    ....That Telltale would explain how Kenny survived the herd in later episodes beyond just "I got lucky. Real lucky."

  • Hahaha, that theory was disproved about a year ago!

    Gary-Oak posted: »

    Kenny is a good character.

  • edited February 2015

    Ehhhhhhhh sorta.

    Saying Kenny is poorly written is less of an opinion than saying he's a nice person, certainly. It is based on factual critique.

    For example, having him return to repeat his exact season 1 arc was poor writing, and was part of him not being a good character.

    colgato posted: »

    that isnt a theory you silly willy goose, thats an opinion

  • But isn't it opinionated if someone is well written or not? I think Kenny was masterfully well written in both seasons, he just hogged a lil too much time in the 2nd

    Flog61 posted: »

    Ehhhhhhhh sorta. Saying Kenny is poorly written is less of an opinion than saying he's a nice person, certainly. It is based on factual c

  • I remember a theory for Amid The Ruins where:

    • "Arvo" was a pseudonym for Nate, who would try to rape Clem
    • Sarita would get a hook for a hand at a pirate exhibit
    • The 400 Days survivors who didn't go to Howe's would show up at Parker's Run
    • Rebecca would get eaten by zombies and you'd decide whether shooting her was worth it or not
    • The ending would have taken place at a church, as the final achievement implies i.e. before Telltale rewrote everything
  • I heard one that luke and nick are secretly together
    ..but that always sounded stupid.

    oh oh, there was this really stupid one on the walking dead wiki's forums
    "i bet lee and mike are long lost brothers and they just dont know it."
    ooh, and this one: "i think that if you let andrew st. john live he'll come back for revenge at the end of season 2"

    • Omid was going to come back in Amid the Ruins
    • Rebbecca was Becca
    • AJ wasn't Alvin's or Carver's, he was Luke's
  • and we all thought Pete was Kenny?

    How DARE you mix up Uncle Pete and Nick..........I can't even talk to you, You know what? I'm not even gonna Saltlick you...Not worth my time.....

    :P

    Alt text

    TWD_25 posted: »

    Remember when the Season 2 trailer came out and we all thought Pete was Kenny?

  • That Troy was Daryl Dixon....

  • Wasn't it because it 'drew attention away from other characters'?

    Mike is Ralph This was actually supposed to happen, but due to time constraints, it was removed.

  • edited February 2015
    • That every supporting character would die by the end of season 2 or become determinant with only Clem left to live like last season... oh wait...
    • That Clem would loose her mind and start going crazy from all the violence she has seen.
    • That Troy would try to R@pe clem.
  • You can also get an option to shoot him if you do certain things.

    Bokor posted: »

    Andy's death was even more strongly implied than Kenny's was. The guy's broken, surrounded by zombies, and his brother is at best one-legged bait. If anything, electrocuting him was actually merciful compared to letting him get eaten alive.

  • Omid's catOmid's cat Banned
    edited February 2015

    I remember a channel on youtube with predictions and theories. Forgot the user name. It was before second season. Anyway, most of theories were complete BS even then. Here's one:

    Katjaa survived. She only wounded herself. Tavia was nearby, heard the gunshot, found her and took to the community.

  • That's batshit crazy.

    Omid's cat posted: »

    I remember a channel on youtube with predictions and theories. Forgot the user name. It was before second season. Anyway, most of theories w

  • Shock value?

    You mean...aftershock? XD

  • When a writer has a limited amount of time to fit in a certain amount of the story into an episode, the writer will tend to focus more on what has to be done and focus on the major characters, causing minor characters to be ignored and potential storylines to be dropped. That's the problem with shorter episodes, writers need to cram what they need into an episode but minor characters or storylines can't be put in as a result. If you took an episode like Starved for Help from the first season and forced the writer to make it an hour and a half like Season 2 episodes were, think of all the things that would be taken out of the game as a result. That's basically what happened in Season 2, things had to be taken out so they could focus on the main story. And one of those things taken out, Mike's storyline as one of the bandits in the woods.

    JakeSt123 posted: »

    Wasn't it because it 'drew attention away from other characters'?

  • Luke as Carver's son.

  • CrazyGeorgeCrazyGeorge Banned
    edited February 2015

    Season two has more plot holes than the moon.

    Alt text

  • edited February 2015
    • Mike is Lee's brother

    • Lee is on the slide of EP5 and will return in it as a zombie

  • edited February 2015

    Arvo would turn out to be a somewhat developed character instead of a plot device with like, only three lines in the last episode. I had so many theories and ideas about him before No Going Back came out.

    Alt text

    This is a lie. I am bitter as...a bitter melon.

  • edited February 2015

    I made a thread called "Small Things Mean Big Changes" where we found a bunch of Amid the ruins slides that were different, and thought depending on season choices and who you saved in 400 days made a huge change to your game....

  • Sarah and Clementine would be partners for life

  • Realism

    dinofire posted: »

    Arvo is a middle aged drug addict

Sign in to comment in this discussion.