What would Gared think of House Forrester when he finds out that they killed his Uncle?
JonKnowsNothing
Banned
I always wondered if Gared was going to find out about how Duncan got executed by Rodrik and to know he is also a Traitor.
I don't think Gared would be angry at Rodrik, but I think he would rather not speak with him anymore. But to also know that his last Family member is gone forever is just heartbreaking ;_;
And I think Rodrik executing Duncan could stop Gared from searching for the North grove, but I doubt that will happen since Gared has no way to find out about his Uncle's death.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
It'll be interesting to see how he would react, Duncan was the only family he had left.
"No..UNCLE DUNCAN!"
If you let Rodrik survive and Asher stay behind.
"WHY did you do this Rodrik!? Uncle Duncan was my only Family left!" In an Angry tone
"He was a bloody Traitor, Gared! He revealed our plans to House Whitehill!"
"A Traitor..?"
"We had to do what was right, Gared."
"THEN WHY DID YOU KILL HIM IF YOU WANTED TO DO THE RIGHT THING?!"
"ENOUGH, GARED!"
He will never find out if he dies. Or should I say, when he dies.
I'm hoping Gared lives.
I'm hoping we as the player get to choose, like either have Gared be furious or be understanding. I won't have this problem anyway because I spared him
It doesn't matter, if he ever returns to Ironrath I'll kill him too for desertion.
Would that technically be suicide?
Probably.
Wow - now that you point it out, that's a really interesting dynamic that could come out of player choice. I don't know if Telltale will go that far, but it would be neat to get some dialogue or a special scene with that interaction.
Will he ever? Probably. Will he in this season? Probably not
I thought about that at first while writing out my post, but I figured it would be kinda redundant to have Gared's plot in the game if he doesn't somehow at least make it very close to Ironrath if nothing else. Lots of people thought the same of Asher in Episode 5, but he was able to make it back. Granted, he had a ship, but my point is I have a feeling Telltale will surprise us with Gared like they did with Asher last episode.
I bet he'll react like Luke did when he heard about Nick dying in ep4.
I think he would be upset and angry, but would understand
He is honorable and holds the honor of the Forresters very high. I think he will be surprised but after that furious at his uncle who helped the guys who killed his sister and niece just because he wasn't rewarded a shiny badge. He not only betrayed the Forresters who Gared owed a lot too, but his own family too. He was sent to the wall for avenging his family , by his uncle and the moment he is gone said uncle helps the enemy. Gared would probably kill Duncan himself if he is alive at that point.
I don't think Gared has it in him to kill his own uncle, his last surviving family member, even if he did betray the very house he owed his allegiance to. But I don't think he would hold it against Rodrik.
I think Gared would be more surprised to find out his uncle was even a traitor in the first place than if he was killed for it.
Nice job, I even read with their voices. :P
But Gared has a wall full of men that want his head... Is it really possible?
Haha, I tried my best but I think It's pretty good to me.
I think you forgot that this is Game of Thrones.
I think that's impossible, unless Gared meets someone from Ironrath that eventually tells him what happened to Duncan or Royland and depending on who is the Traitor and who got executed.
If you let Asher survive and Rodrik stay behind
"No..UNCLE DUNCAN!"
"Why did Rodrik do this?! Uncle Duncan was my only family left!" In an Angry tone
"I think it was because Duncan betrayed our House.."
"He betrayed us? but he sent me to the Wall!"
"Look, your Uncle was a good man but I lost Rodrik too. So consider this even."
"Yeah, I s'ppose."
The last photo, lmao xD
lmao
A man can dream.
If he is informed of the fact that his uncle was working for the Whitehills, whose men killed Gared's father and little sister, I think he will understand.
Yes, a man can certainly Dream..
Mind fades away into a fan fiction of where Rodrik and Asher survive and kill all the Whitehills and takes the Iron Throne
It wouldn't matter if the Forresters saw him they'd kill him immediately. He'd be distraught and probably have resentment for them. He'd still continue the hunt for the North Grove for his uncle
I like Gared's last line. It had me bawling.
Or ever thought that he would never return?! No doubt. He'd either die or stay in the North.
I felt like telltale were lazy with how they made luke react about Nick. I actually found it even more hilarious that he was screaming to Sarah when she fell and then a few seconds later he forgets about it.
Seeing as it varies who The Traitor is. Gared will probably still look for The North Grove, Dead uncle or not.
Yes, I think so too. I didn't promise Lord Forrester for nothing qq.
The North Grove will turn out to be able to resurrect all dead Forresters.
I don't think that would make sense.
I mean, we're talking about game of thrones here.
"If you kill off a character and then bring him back that basically destroys the point that they are actually dead." - George R.R Martin
I was joking.
This is why I picked Duncan as my sentinel so I didn't have to deal with this, he is the logical choice. Royland I feel just makes poor reckless decisions that Jeopradize the lives of the people in the house. Sure he wants to be active and fight back to show strength but at what cost? Duncan can be cowardly at times but at least he doesn't try to Jeopradize the lives of the people in the house by showing strength they don't have.
Yeah, well. This is Game of Thrones so you're gonna have to act strong and evil and shit so George R.R Martin won't kill off your character.
I think Royland knows he is in a universe with a fat man that enjoys killing people.
He'd understand because he's loyal to house Forrester I mean risking his life beyond the wall with wildlings and the white walkers that's definitely loyalty.