It doesn't REALLY show them how we feel. It shows how a few select people feel. MOST of us love this game. Most of these comments aren't even constructive, not giving any details on how to improve.
I think the thread should exist, it shows Telltale just how we feel about the game.
I's annoying for me, because I loved the books and show… more, and the game just doesn't meet those levels. Unlike TWD S1 which is on par with the comics. I think since episode 2 I have critized the game, it suffers from quite a few problems as I've already stated, but I could go into more detail if you want
Long story short: every episode has been well received except Episode 5. (which was still well received by critics) So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it. I wish Telltale fans alike could just... get along. sigh
So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it.
I don't think that's the reason. I do think Telltale fans do compare GOT to TFTB a lot when they're talking about them, but I don't think them being more of a fan of the other is the reason.
Long story short: every episode has been well received except Episode 5. (which was still well received by critics) So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it. I wish Telltale fans alike could just... get along. sigh
Yeah I should have put some instead of us, and not everyone has the time to write a full paragraph of constructive critism. If you want, I could do one tmoz?
It doesn't REALLY show them how we feel. It shows how a few select people feel. MOST of us love this game. Most of these comments aren't even constructive, not giving any details on how to improve.
No, of course. I'm sure everyone has a reason. I've just seen some who haven't even played it or watched it, and yet say that TFTBL is better. It's understandable that they're compared, being the two current games, but some fans take it too far.
So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it.
I don't think that's the reason. I do think Telltale fans do compare GOT to TFTB a lot when they're talking about them, but I don't think them being more of a fan of the other is the reason.
Episode 5 had serious issues that were already extensively discussed, and it is the whole reason I think the game missed way too many opportunities. But yes, the other episodes were pretty good IMO. I loved episode 4, and I hope episode 6 will be great too. Maybe episode 5 was so short because some stuff was pushed to episode 6 (hopefully Gared and Mira's story lines, which were too neglected on episode 5), and that it will be a longer episode so that the story can be wrapped-up in a satisfactory way. If they can pull that off, people will eventually forget how bad episode 5 was and just look at the game as a whole. I kinda wish there were at least three more episodes to be released before it is over, as I am expecting the season to end with Tyrion's escape or right after it.
Long story short: every episode has been well received except Episode 5. (which was still well received by critics) So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it. I wish Telltale fans alike could just... get along. sigh
It never ends does it, the constant parade of people having their heads up Tales' ass. I fell in love with GoT from day one. I found it's characters interesting, it's plot interesting, and the decisions you make within the world interesting.
I actually found Tales to be dry, and one-note, and deffinitely predictable. I knew that Vault Key was fake from the get-go. And oh look, the whole of Episode 2 is a search for the Atlas place, then they get captured. And oh look, the whole of episode 3 is a search for another facility, and then they get captured. Hell, the only reason they're telling the whole story to begin with, IS BECAUSE THEY'VE BEEN CAPTURED! Plus, all anyone can talk about on its forum is "shipping". Shows the level of it's story, and by extensions, most of its fan...
But GoT is predicatble? Lol give me a fucking break. The Wolf Among Us was excellent, even if it's later episodes never matched it's first one. The Walking Dead Season 1, a classic everyone knows that. But Game of Thrones? Depending on how good the finale is, I can easily see it outranking The Wolf Among Us and even being close to WD Season 1. But Tales? It's simply alright. It's funny and enjoyable enough, but it neither has the compelling characters, fascinating plot that the aforementioend games do. And I can't say, I'm that excited for Episode 4 of it. Whereas for all the others, I literally couldn't wait.
People who actually think Game of Thrones is poor, and Tales is great, are people I'm getting bored of seeing. It just seems, GoT can do no right in the eyes of most people here--but Tales, it's the opposite, it can do no wrong. Boo hoo, episode 5 of GoT was dissapointing, therefore the entire game sucks, and that predicatcble, haven't-I-done-this-ten-times-already, ship-fest Tales is the bestest thing evarrrrr. Rhysa! Rhyiona! Rhysa! Rhysa! Bro, bro, thats bro, broooo.
How do we have our heads up their ass? Alot of the comments on here are people who are not enjoying the game and are expressing that.
I've critized GoT since episode 2, I think it's suffers from a lot of problems that people have already stated, myself included. If you want, I could write a huge paragraph for you, with full critque and improvements?
It never ends does it, the constant parade of people having their heads up Tales' ass. I fell in love with GoT from day one. I found it's ch… morearacters interesting, it's plot interesting, and the decisions you make within the world interesting.
I actually found Tales to be dry, and one-note, and deffinitely predictable. I knew that Vault Key was fake from the get-go. And oh look, the whole of Episode 2 is a search for the Atlas place, then they get captured. And oh look, the whole of episode 3 is a search for another facility, and then they get captured. Hell, the only reason they're telling the whole story to begin with, IS BECAUSE THEY'VE BEEN CAPTURED! Plus, all anyone can talk about on its forum is "shipping". Shows the level of it's story, and by extensions, most of its fan...
But GoT is predicatble? Lol give me a fucking break. The Wolf Among Us was excellent, even if it's later episodes never matched it's first one. The Walking Dea… [view original content]
Because, no matter what happens in Game of Thrones, people line up to complain. To hate on it. Though, not everyone feels the same, despite so many people trying to desperately present that as being the case.
Meanwhile, while Episode 3 of Tales comes out, basically the exact same template as 2, people just can't wait to sing its praises, and herald it as the greatest thing ever, despite the fact the only evidence they back it up with is pointing to character shipping, or a joke. Tales relies on the dynamic between four characters, which is fine, but Game of Thrones relies on the relationship and status of an entire House, admist an entire fantasy world as its backdrop, filled with great characters, such as Tyrion and Cersei Lannister etc.
Tales is a nice enough sandwhich, but Game of Thrones is an awesome pizza.
How do we have our heads up their ass? Alot of the comments on here are people who are not enjoying the game and are expressing that.
I've … morecritized GoT since episode 2, I think it's suffers from a lot of problems that people have already stated, myself included. If you want, I could write a huge paragraph for you, with full critque and improvements?
For me nothing will beat S1 of TWD. but TWAU and GoT. are both great games!
I don't think they are weak. maybe the fact that TT now has many projects being produced at the same time, may have reduced slightly the overall quality. but they are still great!
"It shows Telltale just how we feel about the game."
No it doesn't. This thread shows just how YOU feel about the game. There is a difference, you know. I, for one, and I know I'm not alone in this, love the game... Remember that.
I don't have a problem with people not liking the game, but I do have a problem when they try and pass of the notion that nobody likes it as gospel, or that everyone agrees with their view on it. Guess what? They don't...
I think the thread should exist, it shows Telltale just how we feel about the game.
I's annoying for me, because I loved the books and show… more, and the game just doesn't meet those levels. Unlike TWD S1 which is on par with the comics. I think since episode 2 I have critized the game, it suffers from quite a few problems as I've already stated, but I could go into more detail if you want
Game of thrones in my opinion is better than the wolf among us for a few reasons
The story is much more compelling and actually feels like a game of thrones game while the wolf among us is basically a straight forward Sherlock story with fairy tales in it
lol My bad about the misspell, with those kinds of names I can never remember if it's a K or a C.
Oh no I completely agree about TWD S1 not being perfect at all, but it's issues didn't pop up enough for me to start going "Really?", the worst complaint I have about S1 comes from the car battery's light weight and it not mattering whether you cut the arm off or not. It wasn't any single thing that hurt me on S2, just too many little things I couldn't overlook. My suspension of disbelief just goes out the window with how many times Clem has to solve the problem, I get that she's reliable, but I'd expect a group of adults to be able to handle themselves just as much too.
Guess 400 Days is going to have to be your call really if you let it be a knock or not. I'd love to ignore it, but I just can't. I was wanting so much more from the 400 Days characters but oh well.
1) I completely agree with your first point. Omid's death was just ridiculous. I never liked or cared about Krista (Christa?), at all, so ge… moretting rid of her was quite welcome.
2) Not straight away, they sort of learn quickly that Clementine can handle shit. From what most of them can see this is a little girl who has survived on the road by her self. With Kenny, they're unfamiliar with him whereas Clem has a history with him and it's obvious that he cares about her so he's more likely to listen to her. That's the way I saw it. As for Bonnie we know she's two faced, it wasn't that surprising that she'd cover her own ass and throw Clem under the bus, that's her character. The Russians, yeah I agree that was just stupid. But for me it's not enough to ruin the series as it's only a tiny part of the story. And it's not like S1 was perfect, didn't have plot holes, made sense at all times. All TT games suffer from this, but I think most of us giv… [view original content]
Long story short: every episode has been well received except Episode 5. (which was still well received by critics) So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it. I wish Telltale fans alike could just... get along. sigh
Okay cool you don't like Thrones. Want to complain about the series there are literally hundreds of threads hating on Episode 5 go hate there. We have enough hate threads as it is.
To be honest I have no idea how her name is spelt either, so you may well be right. Perhaps someone with a better memory will set us straight on that one
Did you play TWD S2 when it came out? I mean one episode every couple of months? I didn't, I'm a late comer to the party. I played S1 & S2 almost back to back. I'm just wondering if that's why I have a different perspective on it. I know with GoT every little bit of an episode is analysed and picked apart while we're waiting for the next one.Do you if that's the difference?
With 400 days I kind of view it as a separate entity. I mean it's the DLC for S1 anyway. So if we were to count it against any season it should be that one.
lol My bad about the misspell, with those kinds of names I can never remember if it's a K or a C.
Oh no I completely agree about TWD S1 … morenot being perfect at all, but it's issues didn't pop up enough for me to start going "Really?", the worst complaint I have about S1 comes from the car battery's light weight and it not mattering whether you cut the arm off or not. It wasn't any single thing that hurt me on S2, just too many little things I couldn't overlook. My suspension of disbelief just goes out the window with how many times Clem has to solve the problem, I get that she's reliable, but I'd expect a group of adults to be able to handle themselves just as much too.
Guess 400 Days is going to have to be your call really if you let it be a knock or not. I'd love to ignore it, but I just can't. I was wanting so much more from the 400 Days characters but oh well.
* Walking dead and tales from the borderlands are outstanding games that surprised me
* game of thrones and the wolf among us are games tha… moret are okay and were as good as they could have been
* walking dead season 2 better than game of thrones and wolf among us but it could have been better
It ha its ups and downs like any game but the only way you can really enjoy it is to have read to have books and watched the show, its like a little side story
"Nest of vipers", in my opinion, is one of the weakest episodes telltale has ever made, but in general Game of Thrones is one of their best games so far, only beaten by TWD season 1.
"It shows Telltale just how we feel about the game."
No it doesn't. This thread shows just how YOU feel about the game. There is a d… moreifference, you know. I, for one, and I know I'm not alone in this, love the game... Remember that.
I don't have a problem with people not liking the game, but I do have a problem when they try and pass of the notion that nobody likes it as gospel, or that everyone agrees with their view on it. Guess what? They don't...
Because, no matter what happens in Game of Thrones, people line up to complain. To hate on it. Though, not everyone feels the same, despite … moreso many people trying to desperately present that as being the case.
Meanwhile, while Episode 3 of Tales comes out, basically the exact same template as 2, people just can't wait to sing its praises, and herald it as the greatest thing ever, despite the fact the only evidence they back it up with is pointing to character shipping, or a joke. Tales relies on the dynamic between four characters, which is fine, but Game of Thrones relies on the relationship and status of an entire House, admist an entire fantasy world as its backdrop, filled with great characters, such as Tyrion and Cersei Lannister etc.
Tales is a nice enough sandwhich, but Game of Thrones is an awesome pizza.
It ha its ups and downs like any game but the only way you can really enjoy it is to have read to have books and watched the show, its like a little side story
Got is the second weakest TT game for me the with TWD s2 holding the first place albeit they're close. Got is just lazy writting with the team not even bothering to hide the lack of choice and the plot holes. The scene with traitor being a cherry on top.
In what way do I antagonise other members? And I just a smiley just to show that I don't mean I say is dickish, cause it's hard to tell what attiude the person has when typing,
game of thrones is a game that has flaws but the stuff that is good is some of the best things telltale has ever done. The powerful choices, choices coming back to haunt you. This is stuff telltale should be doing.
Sorry if I seem to be coming across as rude it's just that some of your comments annoy me. Whenever a select few people disagree with you your replys just seem so condecending and the smiley face adds to what seems to be arrogance. For example: in your North grove theory discussion a large number of people disagreed with you (including me) so you called them dicks.
In what way do I antagonise other members? And I just a smiley just to show that I don't mean I say is dickish, cause it's hard to tell what attiude the person has when typing,
Okay cool you don't like Thrones. Want to complain about the series there are literally hundreds of threads hating on Episode 5 go hate there. We have enough hate threads as it is.
Don't worry man, and yeah I think I was just a little bit frustrated in that thread, cause everyone was kinda proving me wrong and I put some work into that. So I'll apologize about that. But honestly when I do smiley faces it's just because it's hard to tell if a person is being sarcastic, angry, happy or anything on the internet.
Sorry if I seem to be coming across as rude it's just that some of your comments annoy me. Whenever a select few people disagree with you yo… moreur replys just seem so condecending and the smiley face adds to what seems to be arrogance. For example: in your North grove theory discussion a large number of people disagreed with you (including me) so you called them dicks.
Comments
It doesn't REALLY show them how we feel. It shows how a few select people feel. MOST of us love this game. Most of these comments aren't even constructive, not giving any details on how to improve.
Long story short: every episode has been well received except Episode 5. (which was still well received by critics) So many TFTBL hate GoT for the reason of hating it. I wish Telltale fans alike could just... get along. sigh
I don't think that's the reason. I do think Telltale fans do compare GOT to TFTB a lot when they're talking about them, but I don't think them being more of a fan of the other is the reason.
Yeah I should have put some instead of us, and not everyone has the time to write a full paragraph of constructive critism. If you want, I could do one tmoz?
No, of course. I'm sure everyone has a reason. I've just seen some who haven't even played it or watched it, and yet say that TFTBL is better. It's understandable that they're compared, being the two current games, but some fans take it too far.
Episode 5 had serious issues that were already extensively discussed, and it is the whole reason I think the game missed way too many opportunities. But yes, the other episodes were pretty good IMO. I loved episode 4, and I hope episode 6 will be great too. Maybe episode 5 was so short because some stuff was pushed to episode 6 (hopefully Gared and Mira's story lines, which were too neglected on episode 5), and that it will be a longer episode so that the story can be wrapped-up in a satisfactory way. If they can pull that off, people will eventually forget how bad episode 5 was and just look at the game as a whole. I kinda wish there were at least three more episodes to be released before it is over, as I am expecting the season to end with Tyrion's escape or right after it.
It never ends does it, the constant parade of people having their heads up Tales' ass. I fell in love with GoT from day one. I found it's characters interesting, it's plot interesting, and the decisions you make within the world interesting.
I actually found Tales to be dry, and one-note, and deffinitely predictable. I knew that Vault Key was fake from the get-go. And oh look, the whole of Episode 2 is a search for the Atlas place, then they get captured. And oh look, the whole of episode 3 is a search for another facility, and then they get captured. Hell, the only reason they're telling the whole story to begin with, IS BECAUSE THEY'VE BEEN CAPTURED! Plus, all anyone can talk about on its forum is "shipping". Shows the level of it's story, and by extensions, most of its fan...
But GoT is predicatble? Lol give me a fucking break. The Wolf Among Us was excellent, even if it's later episodes never matched it's first one. The Walking Dead Season 1, a classic everyone knows that. But Game of Thrones? Depending on how good the finale is, I can easily see it outranking The Wolf Among Us and even being close to WD Season 1. But Tales? It's simply alright. It's funny and enjoyable enough, but it neither has the compelling characters, fascinating plot that the aforementioend games do. And I can't say, I'm that excited for Episode 4 of it. Whereas for all the others, I literally couldn't wait.
People who actually think Game of Thrones is poor, and Tales is great, are people I'm getting bored of seeing. It just seems, GoT can do no right in the eyes of most people here--but Tales, it's the opposite, it can do no wrong. Boo hoo, episode 5 of GoT was dissapointing, therefore the entire game sucks, and that predicatcble, haven't-I-done-this-ten-times-already, ship-fest Tales is the bestest thing evarrrrr. Rhysa! Rhyiona! Rhysa! Rhysa! Bro, bro, thats bro, broooo.
Like I said, give me a fucking break lol.
How do we have our heads up their ass? Alot of the comments on here are people who are not enjoying the game and are expressing that.
I've critized GoT since episode 2, I think it's suffers from a lot of problems that people have already stated, myself included. If you want, I could write a huge paragraph for you, with full critque and improvements?
Because, no matter what happens in Game of Thrones, people line up to complain. To hate on it. Though, not everyone feels the same, despite so many people trying to desperately present that as being the case.
Meanwhile, while Episode 3 of Tales comes out, basically the exact same template as 2, people just can't wait to sing its praises, and herald it as the greatest thing ever, despite the fact the only evidence they back it up with is pointing to character shipping, or a joke. Tales relies on the dynamic between four characters, which is fine, but Game of Thrones relies on the relationship and status of an entire House, admist an entire fantasy world as its backdrop, filled with great characters, such as Tyrion and Cersei Lannister etc.
Tales is a nice enough sandwhich, but Game of Thrones is an awesome pizza.
For me nothing will beat S1 of TWD. but TWAU and GoT. are both great games!
I don't think they are weak. maybe the fact that TT now has many projects being produced at the same time, may have reduced slightly the overall quality. but they are still great!
It is pretty weak compared to the others but I still like it.
GOT isn't the weakest. That title belongs to Borderlands until MindCrap is out.
Yes, it is the weakest. Borderlands, Wolf, and TWD hold the told 3 spaces.
No it doesn't. This thread shows just how YOU feel about the game. There is a difference, you know. I, for one, and I know I'm not alone in this, love the game... Remember that.
I don't have a problem with people not liking the game, but I do have a problem when they try and pass of the notion that nobody likes it as gospel, or that everyone agrees with their view on it. Guess what? They don't...
Game of thrones in my opinion is better than the wolf among us for a few reasons
The story is much more compelling and actually feels like a game of thrones game while the wolf among us is basically a straight forward Sherlock story with fairy tales in it
GoT is better than all.
Agreed.
even though game of thrones is not as good as walking dead. It was as good as it could have been.
lol My bad about the misspell, with those kinds of names I can never remember if it's a K or a C.
Oh no I completely agree about TWD S1 not being perfect at all, but it's issues didn't pop up enough for me to start going "Really?", the worst complaint I have about S1 comes from the car battery's light weight and it not mattering whether you cut the arm off or not. It wasn't any single thing that hurt me on S2, just too many little things I couldn't overlook. My suspension of disbelief just goes out the window with how many times Clem has to solve the problem, I get that she's reliable, but I'd expect a group of adults to be able to handle themselves just as much too.
Guess 400 Days is going to have to be your call really if you let it be a knock or not. I'd love to ignore it, but I just can't. I was wanting so much more from the 400 Days characters but oh well.
Some people simply love to compare and complain.
Okay cool you don't like Thrones. Want to complain about the series there are literally hundreds of threads hating on Episode 5 go hate there. We have enough hate threads as it is.
To be honest I have no idea how her name is spelt either, so you may well be right. Perhaps someone with a better memory will set us straight on that one
Did you play TWD S2 when it came out? I mean one episode every couple of months? I didn't, I'm a late comer to the party. I played S1 & S2 almost back to back. I'm just wondering if that's why I have a different perspective on it. I know with GoT every little bit of an episode is analysed and picked apart while we're waiting for the next one.Do you if that's the difference?
With 400 days I kind of view it as a separate entity. I mean it's the DLC for S1 anyway. So if we were to count it against any season it should be that one.
[removed]
Could not agree more.
It ha its ups and downs like any game but the only way you can really enjoy it is to have read to have books and watched the show, its like a little side story
"Nest of vipers", in my opinion, is one of the weakest episodes telltale has ever made, but in general Game of Thrones is one of their best games so far, only beaten by TWD season 1.
You do realise I actually changed my comment right?
Im on my tablet now, but when I get on my computer I'll have to write you a big paragraph
You clearly have not played Jurassic Park
I don't think that's true.
Got is the second weakest TT game for me the with TWD s2 holding the first place albeit they're close. Got is just lazy writting with the team not even bothering to hide the lack of choice and the plot holes. The scene with traitor being a cherry on top.
I love how people are painted this thread as "hate", when at least 80% of these comments are actually criticizing it
I love how you constantly antagonise other members but throw a smiley face at the end so it's okay
In what way do I antagonise other members? And I just a smiley just to show that I don't mean I say is dickish, cause it's hard to tell what attiude the person has when typing,
game of thrones is a game that has flaws but the stuff that is good is some of the best things telltale has ever done. The powerful choices, choices coming back to haunt you. This is stuff telltale should be doing.
Sorry if I seem to be coming across as rude it's just that some of your comments annoy me. Whenever a select few people disagree with you your replys just seem so condecending and the smiley face adds to what seems to be arrogance. For example: in your North grove theory discussion a large number of people disagreed with you (including me) so you called them dicks.
Why is it that people always complain about complainers in this forum? If this thread is not needed it will disappear. End of problem.
Don't worry man, and yeah I think I was just a little bit frustrated in that thread, cause everyone was kinda proving me wrong and I put some work into that. So I'll apologize about that. But honestly when I do smiley faces it's just because it's hard to tell if a person is being sarcastic, angry, happy or anything on the internet.
TWD S2 was worse IMO.