I agree that the game has flaws and issues. But that doesn't change the fact that I enjoyed playing as Gared, Ethan, Mira, Asher and Rodrik. Some more than others, but I still love the character interaction and how my playstyle change every time we switch POV. I love this season and I hope we get Season 2 quickly (Not using the s-word...)
I can just ask one question to everyone.... ok yes I have defended this game saying It was good. But I also think there where issues with it… more as well.. but my question to EVERYONE we are telltale fans right? Hence why we are on here... so the important question is.... did we have fun playing the game? I mean that's why we bought it right? For enjoyment? I for one will say yes there are problems.. gerads story.. i hated it. Felt it was pointless.. BUT! Regardless I loved feeling like I was part of the story.. regardless if my actions mattered or not.. because it felt like I was apart of a show. I had fun! And thars the important thing when PLAYING A GAME my 2 cents.
Yeah, at least I'm glad that there are still people that love the series like I do.
But for me, it seems like the majority didn't like th… moree series because of the finale. They say that the series feel unfinished because of the ending and that it makes it an obvious set up for a second season, if you know what I mean, at least from what I've seen.
I had fun. I love trying to think ahead of what would happen when deciding on a choice, even if it's a choice that seems inconsequential. Telltale are amazing at getting me/the community to think like that. GOT is perfect for this kind of thing as well. So as always, bravo TT.
I can just ask one question to everyone.... ok yes I have defended this game saying It was good. But I also think there where issues with it… more as well.. but my question to EVERYONE we are telltale fans right? Hence why we are on here... so the important question is.... did we have fun playing the game? I mean that's why we bought it right? For enjoyment? I for one will say yes there are problems.. gerads story.. i hated it. Felt it was pointless.. BUT! Regardless I loved feeling like I was part of the story.. regardless if my actions mattered or not.. because it felt like I was apart of a show. I had fun! And thars the important thing when PLAYING A GAME my 2 cents.
To be fair, it seems people have turned on the series as a whole after season 5. It was all rather sudden, it went from "Hurah! GOT is awesome!" To for god knows why, "The series is overrated, it never was that good." What the fuck happened? So what if season 5 wasn't the best season, it had a lot of great moments, and what, are people allowed to make zero mistakes in this day and age? You must be perfect, or you will be burned at the stake? I don't care, I love this series then, still do now, and all that applies to the game as well.
Because I do not like MCSM at all. The graphics, the story, the characters, the humor, none of it feels right to me. And I doubt Episode 3 will be something else entirely, so...I almost surely will not like it.
There's a difference between a cliffhanger (Tales, TWAU, TWDS1 had a cliffhanger) and an incomplete ending (can't even compare it, first game with no ending)
So every to series that ends on a cliffhanger between seasons fails to tell a story?
This is a common story telling device. It is very rar… moree that any episodic story wraps up by seasons end, unless it is a single season event. It is a story telling device to get you to return next season. And if you're annoyed at telltale for using the same method, just look at TWD, TWAU, TTFB, even JP. Not one of these is resolved by the end of the game. Their stories are left open...so we may return!
And if they don't return, it leaves it open to interpretation. Again, a common method of storytelling in television and movies. Just look at the ending of Gone Girl, or A History of Violence. 2 films that will never, ever have a sequel, yet the endings left us on a cliff hanger and were extremely ambiguous. But they were great films.
Hey man don't worry ! most of the people likes this game , it's even my favorite ttg game (as well as my favorite show and books ) .The negative minority is just being loud and shouting in corridors that's all , what iam gonna say doesn't mean much , but just look At your thread , it reached more likes , than all the others negative threads about the last episode of got . The majority of people like the game but just stay silent on the matter .I remember these forums when the last episode of s1 walking dead came out .A lot of complains about the fact that lee was dead .That your choice couldn't save him and all ...but in the end , but it became one of the best sellers oof the yeaar
Hey man don't worry ! most of the people likes this game , it's even my favorite ttg game (as well as my favorite show and books ) .The ne… moregative minority is just being loud and shouting in corridors that's all , what iam gonna say doesn't mean much , but just look At your thread , it reached more likes , than all the others negative threads about the last episode of got . The majority of people like the game but just stay silent on the matter .I remember these forums when the last episode of s1 walking dead came out .A lot of complains about the fact that lee was dead .That your choice couldn't save him and all ...but in the end , but it became one of the best sellers oof the yeaar
I just think ppl shouldn't be bashed for having different opinions. I know that I loved the game and enjoyed it because I'm critiquing it and asking for more.
We can argue, but let's not name call based on our opinions
I can just ask one question to everyone.... ok yes I have defended this game saying It was good. But I also think there where issues with it… more as well.. but my question to EVERYONE we are telltale fans right? Hence why we are on here... so the important question is.... did we have fun playing the game? I mean that's why we bought it right? For enjoyment? I for one will say yes there are problems.. gerads story.. i hated it. Felt it was pointless.. BUT! Regardless I loved feeling like I was part of the story.. regardless if my actions mattered or not.. because it felt like I was apart of a show. I had fun! And thars the important thing when PLAYING A GAME my 2 cents.
It's a reference to The Office
Or maybe our negativity is perfectly reasonable to us and that's all that really matters
But then again, I brought up great points to support my claim, about the plot and about the company's track record.
Me reading this comment:
It's a reference to The Office
Ok, I didn't catch that and should feel bad about myself.
Or may… morebe our negativity is perfectly reasonable to us and that's all that really matters
Fine, I can get behind that. He probably has a point, we should just accept the opinion of each other
But then again, I brought up great points to support my claim, about the plot and about the company's track record.
goddamnit
I really don't want this forum to become toxic.
This is like the only place that I can share the love I have with Game of Thrones, how mu… morech I loved the storyline, the characters, the art direction. And now, I fear about sharing my love with that game in this forum cause of how toxic will become (maybe) sooner or later. Ugh... Looks like Telltale couldn't please anyone with the finale. It's actually a big shame the fact they took a lot of time to do some improvements to the finale yet people many people didn't enjoy it. Not only the majority of the GoT forum but also the GoT fans outside the forum and the Telltale website in general.
I've been very careful to avoid name calling and @Telltaleguy1990 didn't either. We didn't bash anybody, we just stated our opinions of other people's opinions, and you know, that's not above criticism.
I just think ppl shouldn't be bashed for having different opinions. I know that I loved the game and enjoyed it because I'm critiquing it and asking for more.
We can argue, but let's not name call based on our opinions
I've been very careful to avoid name calling and @Telltaleguy1990 didn't either. We didn't bash anybody, we just stated our opinions of other people's opinions, and you know, that's not above criticism.
Yeah, at least I'm glad that there are still people that love the series like I do.
But for me, it seems like the majority didn't like th… moree series because of the finale. They say that the series feel unfinished because of the ending and that it makes it an obvious set up for a second season, if you know what I mean, at least from what I've seen.
I think you're right its just been a long time since one took this long to die out. TWD2 died quickly due to the Kenny/Jane forum war , MC story mode haters didn't logically understand anything about the game (some people confused it for MC itself) and Borderlands pasionists quickly ignored the haters till they left. This is just taking longer.
Hey man don't worry ! most of the people likes this game , it's even my favorite ttg game (as well as my favorite show and books ) .The ne… moregative minority is just being loud and shouting in corridors that's all , what iam gonna say doesn't mean much , but just look At your thread , it reached more likes , than all the others negative threads about the last episode of got . The majority of people like the game but just stay silent on the matter .I remember these forums when the last episode of s1 walking dead came out .A lot of complains about the fact that lee was dead .That your choice couldn't save him and all ...but in the end , but it became one of the best sellers oof the yeaar
Definitely not talking about you guys, you guys have been cool about your opinions.
I know I can do a lil better (and I know the age range is very wide here) but it's just something I wanted to post so we all remember
Comments
I agree that the game has flaws and issues. But that doesn't change the fact that I enjoyed playing as Gared, Ethan, Mira, Asher and Rodrik. Some more than others, but I still love the character interaction and how my playstyle change every time we switch POV. I love this season and I hope we get Season 2 quickly (Not using the s-word...)
Still. We liked it so we should be allowed to enjoy it amongs others. Not be shut down by dislikers and haters.
I had fun. I love trying to think ahead of what would happen when deciding on a choice, even if it's a choice that seems inconsequential. Telltale are amazing at getting me/the community to think like that. GOT is perfect for this kind of thing as well. So as always, bravo TT.
To be fair, it seems people have turned on the series as a whole after season 5. It was all rather sudden, it went from "Hurah! GOT is awesome!" To for god knows why, "The series is overrated, it never was that good." What the fuck happened? So what if season 5 wasn't the best season, it had a lot of great moments, and what, are people allowed to make zero mistakes in this day and age? You must be perfect, or you will be burned at the stake? I don't care, I love this series then, still do now, and all that applies to the game as well.
Haha wow that sounds familiar... Sounds like all the GoT hate but for a different game.
How the turn tables... turn
There's a difference between a cliffhanger (Tales, TWAU, TWDS1 had a cliffhanger) and an incomplete ending (can't even compare it, first game with no ending)
Hey man don't worry ! most of the people likes this game , it's even my favorite ttg game (as well as my favorite show and books
) .The negative minority is just being loud and shouting in corridors that's all , what iam gonna say doesn't mean much , but just look At your thread , it reached more likes , than all the others negative threads about the last episode of got . The majority of people like the game but just stay silent on the matter .I remember these forums when the last episode of s1 walking dead came out .A lot of complains about the fact that lee was dead .That your choice couldn't save him and all ...but in the end , but it became one of the best sellers oof the yeaar 
Maybe my hate for MCSM is irrational, but so is all the GoT hate.
What are you even saying?
I remember those days, its been so long, huh. I'm sure your right.
It's a reference to The Office
Or maybe our negativity is perfectly reasonable to us and that's all that really matters
But then again, I brought up great points to support my claim, about the plot and about the company's track record.
I just think ppl shouldn't be bashed for having different opinions. I know that I loved the game and enjoyed it because I'm critiquing it and asking for more.
We can argue, but let's not name call based on our opinions
Me reading this comment:
Ok, I didn't catch that and should feel bad about myself.
Fine, I can get behind that. He probably has a point, we should just accept the opinion of each other
goddamnit
Lol just wanted to troll you at the end
Yeah, I know you weren't serious, I got the unedited comment in my inbox ;P
If you liked Mira's death...then yes...it was the best story for her.
LOL the Sean Bean thing is hilarious.
I've been very careful to avoid name calling and @Telltaleguy1990 didn't either. We didn't bash anybody, we just stated our opinions of other people's opinions, and you know, that's not above criticism.
Definitely not talking about you guys, you guys have been cool about your opinions.
I know I can do a lil better (and I know the age range is very wide here) but it's just something I wanted to post so we all remember
I keep finding more people that enjoy and love it like you and me
I think you're right its just been a long time since one took this long to die out. TWD2 died quickly due to the Kenny/Jane forum war , MC story mode haters didn't logically understand anything about the game (some people confused it for MC itself) and Borderlands pasionists quickly ignored the haters till they left. This is just taking longer.
It's become my favourite Telltale game.
Aye. One of my favourites too. Way better than that mess called The Walking Dead Season 2.
It's actually my favorite Telltale game, too and favorite game in general
Thats really cool.
Just made a theory thread
Ah, I understand. We can (and should) all get along