I think it would make people more comfortable that Lee would speak of it. Rather than having someone expose is much wrose, I mean when you told Kenny he thought you were a child rapist which was quite funny.
Honestly I never understood the Carley thing. Seriously it's the apocalypse, who we were before it is of minor importance, it's the decisions you make in the present that are of any relevance
I'm not sure if I assumed she had been killed too or not when I played. But Lee did also say she was in Virginia in-game. I guess it's up for everyone themselves to decide, in the end.
Those kinds of double-murders have happened quite a lot, though. Not saying that they're common, but there are countless cases if you go back just a century or two.
Didn't know that happened.
I remember I chose to save Carley, but in the following episode, for whatever reason, I had Doug instead. Guess I should be glad.
Kenny does care, though, if you don't get tell him yourself. He is shocked and even brings up the fact that Lee was around a little girl all… more those months of keeping his secret of being a killer. He also gets pissy that you kept secrets from him while he's being honest about Duck. He wouldn't say all that, even if you're on good terms with him, if he didn't care about it.
Also regarding the "3 months" thing, that was Carley's point. Waiting to do it would only make it worse because that would mean the deception went on longer. Kenny even straight up says that if you keep it from him. "Were you ever going to get around to telling us that?" Carley was right in that regard. It's just that Kenny lost his family right after that, so it stops mattering to him (like most things), as he says on the train.
Honestly I never understood the Carley thing. Seriously it's the apocalypse, who we were before it is of minor importance, it's the decisions you make in the present that are of any relevance
As a female who has been beaten and hurt by a male before, for no reason, I would disagree...
My aunt was in an abusive relationship too; her now ex-husband was always sober. He never drank. So yeah, I care to disagree. Unless in self defense, niether gender should be physically hurting the other!
You're right I sounded very ignorant I'll retract that statement, I can't expect everything to be accurate. But yes, no one should hurt another unless in self-defense.
As a female who has been beaten and hurt by a male before, for no reason, I would disagree...
My aunt was in an abusive relationship too;… more her now ex-husband was always sober. He never drank. So yeah, I care to disagree. Unless in self defense, niether gender should be physically hurting the other!
Carley told Lee to do that because if he tells, they won't get mad, but if they find out from Lilly, some of them will get mad.
And indeed that is what in fact happens. When he tells, none of them get mad at him, but if he doesn't tell then some of them do.
In addition to that, her prediction of the eminent discovery comes from the fact that Larry's death would make a mentally unstable Lilly blurt out the secret. And indeed a mentally unstable Lilly does end up blurting out the secret. Carley has been right about nearly just about everything she said.
It would depend on why they did it and how they felt about their actions. As long as they seemed trustworthy, and regretted their actions and/or had a justifiable explanation, I would trust them. Plus as Kenny said that kind of experience could actually be useful in the apocalypse (forget the exact quote).
Lee explained what he did and why. Nothing horrendous compared to the shitty situation they're in. Wouldn't be a wise idea to kick him out anyway. Hell, they probably couldn't if the group wanted to. Lee's a bad ass if you hadn't noticed.
Comments
Thanks.
I haven't replayed the game in years and I've never picked the option to keep her in the group.
I think it would make people more comfortable that Lee would speak of it. Rather than having someone expose is much wrose, I mean when you told Kenny he thought you were a child rapist which was quite funny.
True
Deanna Monroe disagrees.
Actually, I think somebody confirmed that Lee's wife was killed too in an interview. I'll try to find it.
Well he can also lie about plenty in dialogue . I think he killed her as well
I wish Carley had been a bit more slutty.
Sorry. I meant to reply to richwalk, not you.
Well, you mean a good person right? Because men physically harm their wives commonly.
yeah
I'm not sure if I assumed she had been killed too or not when I played. But Lee did also say she was in Virginia in-game. I guess it's up for everyone themselves to decide, in the end.
Most likely drunk I guess. Usually these days if the woman is asking for it then yeah. Other than that nah. It would be rare in my opinion.
Those kinds of double-murders have happened quite a lot, though. Not saying that they're common, but there are countless cases if you go back just a century or two.
Didn't know that happened.
I remember I chose to save Carley, but in the following episode, for whatever reason, I had Doug instead. Guess I should be glad.
Both die in respective episodes. It's how Telltale works. Choices don't matter!!
I wonder if he would not trust Lee if Duck didn't get bit.
She actually steals the R.V. if you keep her in the group.
Um , I assure you , Domestic Violence exists.
Holding onto his Ace , most likely.
"The world is ending out there. who cares who I am"
Of course a persons history matters. If you knew someone was a murderer would you be like "It's the apocalypse, fresh slate, I trust this person now"
I can't remember, but I don't think this was dialogue he chose. You might be right though.
As a female who has been beaten and hurt by a male before, for no reason, I would disagree...
My aunt was in an abusive relationship too; her now ex-husband was always sober. He never drank. So yeah, I care to disagree. Unless in self defense, niether gender should be physically hurting the other!
You're right I sounded very ignorant I'll retract that statement, I can't expect everything to be accurate. But yes, no one should hurt another unless in self-defense.
Carley told Lee to do that because if he tells, they won't get mad, but if they find out from Lilly, some of them will get mad.
And indeed that is what in fact happens. When he tells, none of them get mad at him, but if he doesn't tell then some of them do.
In addition to that, her prediction of the eminent discovery comes from the fact that Larry's death would make a mentally unstable Lilly blurt out the secret. And indeed a mentally unstable Lilly does end up blurting out the secret. Carley has been right about nearly just about everything she said.
Maybe her CORPSE is in Virginia Mwahahah! In all seriousness he totally didn't kill her.
It would depend on why they did it and how they felt about their actions. As long as they seemed trustworthy, and regretted their actions and/or had a justifiable explanation, I would trust them. Plus as Kenny said that kind of experience could actually be useful in the apocalypse (forget the exact quote).
Lee explained what he did and why. Nothing horrendous compared to the shitty situation they're in. Wouldn't be a wise idea to kick him out anyway. Hell, they probably couldn't if the group wanted to. Lee's a bad ass if you hadn't noticed.