Janiacs and Kenny Apologists.....
Let us discuss those few who fail to go with benevolent Jane or that mad man Kenny....those we call the Go it Aloners.
Those people, who are they and what kind of morals do they have to drag an infant out into the cold with only an 11 year old for protection.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Title and thread dont really connect
I find the alone ending pretty ridiculous, clementine somehow keeping a infant alive by herself and then choosing to walk into a group of walkers with said infant when there is plenty of room one each side, or other directions to go in
Because I watched Jane die then shot Kenny in the face.
That is terrible from a survivalistic perspective, in my opinion.
An eleven year old is left to take care of a newborn without any supplies other than a blanket, a knife, a gun, some clothes, a jacket, and whatever they can find in the middle of an abandoned pitstop.
Its also one of the weirdest decision making processes ive ever seen.
In the words of Lee "People don't always make sense"
The thing with that particular choice is that Clementine shoots him anger, not to save someones life. she doesn't think it through.
its the best ending. that or, pointing gun at the family in howes. it shows how dark clementine becomes. i just wish there was endings where we leave the baby too. maybe use it as bait to pass that herd of walkers (instead of smearing walker guts all over) in alone endings. that would have been awesome.
Okay I'm not the biggest fan of AJ but you sound like a complete psychopath.
They probably think it's their best bet.
why? cuz i want story to be darker and more interesting? lol.
That is correct, but it doesn't make it any less impractical.
Take my like, @CrazedRabbit.
There's a line between interesting and plain maniacal. There's nothing interesting about a helpless baby getting devoured by walkers.
It's absolutelly impractical. I'm just pointing out why Clementine would do such a thing.
The kind that would rather sacrifice a slow death with a shit infant than one with a borderline mentally handicapped woman with issues not yet identified by psychiatrists or a psychotic racist dipshit with the IQ of a brick with shit on it.
Until clem gets eaten by another dog 5 minutes later
I kind of get what you mean. I too like when a story gets dark but when you word it like that it does sound pretty bad, hence @CrazedRabbit's reaction.
See what I mean?
May be go alone ending will be the reason of her missing finger. That will make her stronger they thought.
How many times within the few days Clementine and Kenny met up did his actions almost kill her again?
Plus, the dog wouldn't get Clementine, she does AJ after all.
whats difference between a baby life or grown up life? both are human. you cant complain about baby dying while having no problems with adults getting killed all the time. this game already killed kids. they also killed a dog. in comic, a newborn is crushed to death when when its mothers corpse falls on it. are u even aware of the game ur playing?
I think that given their walkthroughs they may just felt like it was time to restart, maybe because they think that both Kenny AND Jane have already lost their minds.
The 'Alone' ending is probably the worst. Clementine and AJ's fate are the left in the balance. From the looks of it, they have no food, no water, a hatchet for a weapon, possibly a pistol with limited ammunition, and no real sense of direction of where they're going, not to mention she now has no people around her. I personally like the ending as a bittersweet one, similar to how she ended up in the aftermath of The Walking Dead: Season 1, when she was on the outskirts of Savannah, except when she's looking around there will be no Christa, no Omid to come help her, she is by herself.
I did not value the baby's life over an adult's, did I ever say the opposite? You're probably the only one who values none of those lives. I merely called you out for lacking basic human empathy, a baby cannot protect itself, if you'd leave it to die "just because" then you're obviously a psychopath. I know morality isn't a big thing in the apocalypse but anyone who still hasn't gone completely insane would not leave a defenseless baby to die.
lol ur taking this video game way too seriously dude.
Wait you can do that? Never noticed....Damn now I need another play through.
Question is, why would Jane and Kenny allow this to happen. I think it is a bit out of character for Kenny to leave a kid to take care of another like that, regardless of whether the kid likes him or not.
All it takes is a simple well thought out explaination as to what happened during Clementine's alone ending and everything will be a-okay in my book. Judging from what TT says about our ending choice playing a part in S3, I don't see why this can't happen. Could be she met with new pepole in a different location or she managed to hold up in a spot with replenishable supplies. Any explaination is preferable to nothing. We fans can speculate and have our theories, but it's up to the writers of S3 (big time) for this nugget of info.
Another one of these.... can't wait...
Yeah no thanks, I'll pass on that
That kind of ending sounds like more overly nihilistic bullshit if you ask me. Same reason I don't like the ending where you let Kenny kill Jane, then kill him. Fuck that ending, fuck the horse it rode in on, and fuck its cultural lineage. Fuck most things about it. Except maybe the cinematography, because the way the shot is framed when Clem shoots Kenny is pretty neat, but fuck the rest of it. If you like that ending, fair enough, but god ALMIGHTY do I not.
Despite what some people believe, TWD is not meant to be all doom and gloom, because if it was, everyone would've gotten bored of it long ago. If it was a never-ending cascade of death, that wasn't balanced out by some semblance of normalcy, optimism and morality like it is now, just about every major event throughout the franchise-- comic, game, show, etc-- wouldn't have been anywhere near as effective as they were.
Can I just say that Janiacs is a cool word.
How come?
I know. I'm just a mini-fan of Jane so I am not worthy. They get such a cool name and I'm just a Kenny apologist. Sigh.
It's not like math, Clem. Sometimes there just isn't a right answer.
Jane and maniacs.
Honestly, I had my fill of "Kenny vs Jane" threads way back when the Season Finale rolled around, but because I feel obligated to spread the good word of Kenny, I will indulge you.
I chose Kenny, for Kenny had given his only begotten son to die for our sins. I chose Kenny, for Jane tried to make me caste down my God in favor of false idols. She sold her soul to Larry, and was appropriately delt with. When my time on Earth has passed, I will be transported to Wellington on the Holy Boat, as a reward for my faithfulness. When you die, Janiacs, you shall only feel the force of hundreds of Saltlicks crushing you.
Hail Kenny, full of boats, the 'stache is with thee. Blessed art thou amongst urbans and blessed is the fruit of thy loins, Duck. Holy Kenny, Father of Duck, pray for us shitbirds now and in the hour of our bite, amen.
IronWoodLover wonders how this comment relates to the thread's content.
BetterToSleep does as well.
It makes a cool looking off-topic comment, though.
Ah, damn it. I didn't understand what OP was saying. Thought it was discussing why we chose who we chose.
Doesn't make anything I said less true, though.
Two years and we're still at war with each other over the Kenny vs Jane feud. I'm pretty sure Kenny Apologists won and the Janiac Rebellion lost. Seriously, I never understood why fans are head over heels for Kenny, but then again my Clem was more of a loner anyway.
r u sure bout that?
Wow, do you think calling people psychopaths is a good way to prove your 'empathy' and 'moral integrity'? Cause you come off sounding extremely judgemental.
AJ is a bunch of pixels, not a real human anything. I would have left him too if they would have allowed for the option, no question about it. Who needs a crying bundle of pixels to take care of for the next 2 years? Lol.