What if You Had To kill Clementine OR Javier for the sake of others?
It just past through my mind that in episode 5 of The Walking Dead: A New Frontier we may find ourselves in this position. To kill Clementine or Javier for the sake of their group. What would YOU do if you Had to Take this hard decision??
What I would do: I would save Clementine from death rather than Javier because we have just met Javier in Season 3 and I'm not saying that he deserves to die or something like that but I know Clementine for a WHILE AGO I wouldn't like to see her dying in this season.
What would be YOUR DECISION on this issue??
(P.S. This All just a theory of mine)
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Sorry for my bad english at some points...
I would save Clem over any other character that has or will ever show up, period.
Lol sorry Javi you gotta go
That's not a hard decision. 95% of everyone would save Clementine, as would I. And that's regardless of who the other character is, Javier or anyone else.
Well, this will be the easiest decision of my life.
[Kill Javier]
[I do not mind to kill his entire family if you want to]
i agree haha.
It depends. If Clem turns into a hopeless little shit, while Javier is fucking Jesus (got it? no...?), then I wouldn't be sure I would choose our little girl.
Would kill Javier, I hope Clementine is always a part of the Walking Dead telltale games
i would save javier. he has more to live for (his family)
Well, I guess for me depending on how well Javier is done, it could either be an easy or a hard decision to kill Javier. But he's dying in that situation regardless. I chopped my arm off and slashed my way through a street of walkers for that girl.
Kind of a lame decision to be honest. Trying not to be rude here but come on. Barely anyone would save Javier so it's not really a choice. I really hope they don't go down this route because it would be pointless.
Clementine is the real answer. Javier is not.
I consider it a ridiculousness to do this question at this point.
Not only because Javier and Clementine are on unequal ground, but also because it prompts users to go into A New Frontier with the idea that they will pick Clementine over Javier no matter what happens, effectively creating a subconsciously-internalized bias against the latter.
Praise to you and @RavenSnowstorm.
just like "barely anyone would kill kenny" in season 2 ended up being more than 80% saving jane instead.
we will be playing as javier most of time, and if shes being a bitch to him (which will most likely depend by your previous choices) i wouldnt be surprised if majority save him instead of clem.
and i hope its not a choice. whats the point of a new protagonist if hes just gonna die again?
I don't see how this question would prompt people to do anything that wasn't already their intention lol. It's extremely doubtful TT would present a dilemma like this in a new protagonists game, though.
i agree. and i think hardcore clem fans are NOT doing her a favor by obsessing over her and wanting everyone around her to die.
That may be the easiest decision in game history, wait no, it falls to #2, only behind asking to leave with Mike lmao.
Wait, when was that the consensus? Wasn't the fan base pretty divided over Kenny in both seasons, where as Clementine has been generally well received through both?
Agreed. That's silly to want everyone around her to die. I'm fully intending to continue doing what I've done since I started playing 4 years ago, and that's to keep her alive.
Clem.
At this point, Javi is still Walker bait in my eyes, so yeah he dies. There is nothing Telltale could ever do to make me kill off Clem willingly.
I have to admit I always felt like the Kenny-lovers were a very vocal minority.
Um clem or javier, not really that hard to pick. I'd kill javier of course. Clem is the only reason I play TWD.
First I would play the gameplay till finale then I would be more ready to decide I know Clem is what we call the x factor of the series but who knows what Javier has in store for us he is a family man!
Not to everyone.
Bad example. Because its not a true example. People either love kenny or hate him.
same with clementine
Uh? What? What did I do now?
Difference between that is the majority loves Clementine. Probably over 90 percent of players. With Kenny its 50/50.
It's not about wanting other characters dead, it's about giving Clem priority in a "her or someone else" scenario.
Yes, to everyone
No really, just read the comments, there would be a very tiny amount of people that would choose Javier, the same ones that never liked Clem to begin with, they are there.
You and a bunch of people are not everyone.
thats cuz in s1 she was little and innocent. in s2 we were ones controlling her. but in s3, once you have no control over her and shes acting rebellious & bitchy towards javier (who were playing as) people will change there minds about her.
You realize that opinions are never rigid.
The extreme ones are. But the statistics for the Season 2 endings show that many people are pro Kenny at the very least.
If I had to give one of them up, neither.
I've lost too many good people in this series already.
This isn't a fair question to ask right now. The game hasn't even come out yet and no one's even had a chance to get to know Javier. I love Clem with all of my heart but if something happens in the story where i get connected to Javier i'll then have to make that decision. No way should anyone make that decision before the story even starts.
A redundant choice. Even if Javier and his family turn out to be saints and it's revealed that Clementine worked with the bad guys all along and got dozens of people killed, the majority of this fanbase would still choose her over all of them combined because she's Clementine.