I don't know what to tell you. Some people understand certain things better than others and I happen to understand TWD and Clementine better than most people here. You might not like it, and it might make me sound arrogant, but it is true.
You're just stating something in order to push your narrative of "me being right and you all are wrong".
because nobody influenced her to be that way
Maybe, but there's something that influenced her. Like, losing everyone she loves; being left alone with a baby as a 14 yo girl and losing him. She was also a part of New Frontier that could influence her. All this is in the game.
Lee, Carley, Christa, and Jesus
They all had someone or something to live for. For Lee: Clementine ; Carley: Group, Lee(maybe) ; Christa: Omid; Clem; OJ; Group ; Jesus: Hilltop. Clem in ANF got none of that. She is alone and (probably) desperate to get AJ back.
I get why you think this way and TellTale could do a better job with Clementine, but her behavior is not completely baseless. Maybe you should stop with your edginess before it's too late?
Well since you didn't watch the video, I'll just repeat what I said in it. Unless you raised Clementine to be like Jane, I don't see how you… more can be happy with how she turned out in this game. Clementine turning out the way she does in this game makes no sense because nobody influenced her to be that way. It wasn't Lee, it wasn't Kenny, and it wasn't Jane either. And it doesn't make sense for alone Clementine because in that case there was nobody to influence her. A lot of people will give reasons that are never stated in-game to justify the change, but the problem with that is that it invalidates all our choices regarding Clementine, and it doesn't justify her change because you don't need to be an asshole to survive the zombie apocalypse. Plenty of other competent survivors didn't have to be edgy dicks just to survive, such as: Lee, Carley, Christa, and Jesus. Making Clementine the way she is in this season is nothing but pure fan pandering.… [view original content]
You're just stating something in order to push your narrative of "me being right and you all are wrong".
No, you clearly didn't watch my video, because if you had, you would've seen that I actually gave reasons for why Clementine's """""character development""""" makes no sense instead of just saying "it's bad and unexplainable" without giving an explanation why.
As for the rest of your post, none of that stuff is reason for Clementine to turn into a lying, edgy, pissed off bitch with no regard for human life. If anything it would make emotionally broken and/or traumatized. Kenny had nothing to live for once he lost his family, but his personality largely stayed the same, and he's still the same after we see him again in season 2. So having nothing to live for is not an explanation for Clementine being the way she is. I'll give you that with three episodes left there's still time for us to be given a proper explanation why Clementine's so different now, but that doesn't seem likely for a few reasons. 1, Telltale isn't going fix something that the fanbase doesn't have a problem with, even if it is in actuality damaging to the quality of the work. And 2, Telltale seems to be more concerned with using the flashbacks to show how Clementine joined the New Frontier, rather than give her proper character development and even then, five minutes isn't enough time to give proper character development. If we're just to supposed to assume that Clementine is changing just because of the setting of the story, but without showing or even explaining anything beyond that, then I'm sorry, but that's not good storytelling. It's also pure laziness on their part because it means they would rather we come up with our own reasons for why Clementine is the way she is, instead of doing part of their job which is tell a fucking story.
stop with your edginess
Ha ha ha ha ha ha! Holy shit that's rich, that's fucking rich!
Well since you didn't watch the video
You're just stating something in order to push your narrative of "me being right and you all a… morere wrong".
because nobody influenced her to be that way
Maybe, but there's something that influenced her. Like, losing everyone she loves; being left alone with a baby as a 14 yo girl and losing him. She was also a part of New Frontier that could influence her. All this is in the game.
Lee, Carley, Christa, and Jesus
They all had someone or something to live for. For Lee: Clementine ; Carley: Group, Lee(maybe) ; Christa: Omid; Clem; OJ; Group ; Jesus: Hilltop. Clem in ANF got none of that. She is alone and (probably) desperate to get AJ back.
I get why you think this way and TellTale could do a better job with Clementine, but her behavior is not completely baseless. Maybe you should stop with your edginess before it's too late?
This is just the same old whining that we have been seeing these past weeks
We have every right to complain though. It's a truly shit game and only the story is keeping it alive as far as I'm concerned. People can like it but it baffles me why they would knowing this game costs the same as S1 and heavily lacks quality in every way compared to the first game and even season 2 which i didn't even think was possible
I stopped listening when you complained about MIchonne. This is just the same old whining that we have been seeing these past weeks...and r… moreeally a YouTube vide without video..you might as well blogged about it. Sure I want more Clem...I think she is the heart and soul of the series.
You say Kirkman being involved was a bad thing...even though he was closely working with Telltale during season 1. So I have to question your understanding of season 1..let alone anything else related to the game.
You're just stating something in order to push your narrative of "me being right and you all are wrong".
No, you clearly didn't watc… moreh my video, because if you had, you would've seen that I actually gave reasons for why Clementine's """""character development""""" makes no sense instead of just saying "it's bad and unexplainable" without giving an explanation why.
As for the rest of your post, none of that stuff is reason for Clementine to turn into a lying, edgy, pissed off bitch with no regard for human life. If anything it would make emotionally broken and/or traumatized. Kenny had nothing to live for once he lost his family, but his personality largely stayed the same, and he's still the same after we see him again in season 2. So having nothing to live for is not an explanation for Clementine being the way she is. I'll give you that with three episodes left there's still time for us to be given a proper explanation why Clementi… [view original content]
Comments
About as true as me having a teakettle stuck up my ass right now
You're just stating something in order to push your narrative of "me being right and you all are wrong".
Maybe, but there's something that influenced her. Like, losing everyone she loves; being left alone with a baby as a 14 yo girl and losing him. She was also a part of New Frontier that could influence her. All this is in the game.
They all had someone or something to live for. For Lee: Clementine ; Carley: Group, Lee(maybe) ; Christa: Omid; Clem; OJ; Group ; Jesus: Hilltop. Clem in ANF got none of that. She is alone and (probably) desperate to get AJ back.
I get why you think this way and TellTale could do a better job with Clementine, but her behavior is not completely baseless. Maybe you should stop with your edginess before it's too late?
sadly you are very very right about everything.....
No, you clearly didn't watch my video, because if you had, you would've seen that I actually gave reasons for why Clementine's """""character development""""" makes no sense instead of just saying "it's bad and unexplainable" without giving an explanation why.
As for the rest of your post, none of that stuff is reason for Clementine to turn into a lying, edgy, pissed off bitch with no regard for human life. If anything it would make emotionally broken and/or traumatized. Kenny had nothing to live for once he lost his family, but his personality largely stayed the same, and he's still the same after we see him again in season 2. So having nothing to live for is not an explanation for Clementine being the way she is. I'll give you that with three episodes left there's still time for us to be given a proper explanation why Clementine's so different now, but that doesn't seem likely for a few reasons. 1, Telltale isn't going fix something that the fanbase doesn't have a problem with, even if it is in actuality damaging to the quality of the work. And 2, Telltale seems to be more concerned with using the flashbacks to show how Clementine joined the New Frontier, rather than give her proper character development and even then, five minutes isn't enough time to give proper character development. If we're just to supposed to assume that Clementine is changing just because of the setting of the story, but without showing or even explaining anything beyond that, then I'm sorry, but that's not good storytelling. It's also pure laziness on their part because it means they would rather we come up with our own reasons for why Clementine is the way she is, instead of doing part of their job which is tell a fucking story.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha! Holy shit that's rich, that's fucking rich!
We have every right to complain though. It's a truly shit game and only the story is keeping it alive as far as I'm concerned. People can like it but it baffles me why they would knowing this game costs the same as S1 and heavily lacks quality in every way compared to the first game and even season 2 which i didn't even think was possible
You're completely missing the point of my posts. Have a nice day, sir.