Why did Mike carry A.J across the lake?

2»

Comments

  • Didn't you know? The Walking Dead Commandments are made to be broken, not to be blindly followed.

    Third Walking Dead Commandment: thou shall not praise worthless child character in any shape or form.

  • Good thing I wasn't talking about Duck or Mariana then.

    Third Walking Dead Commandment: thou shall not praise worthless child character in any shape or form.

  • Offtopic, but why is OP banned?

  • enter image description here

    fallandir posted: »

    Offtopic, but why is OP banned?

  • edited February 2017

    Not to worry gents, only a 12 hour ban for supposedly breaking forum guidelines.
    If you check my profile you'll see an argument I had with another guy, must've been flagged by him.

    Ah well, I guess I'll never get into any heated debates anymore.

    I broke forum guidelines 1.1.

  • It wasn't related to that; you were banned for something different, if you check your PM notifications.

    ZombiePizza posted: »

    Not to worry gents, only a 12 hour ban for supposedly breaking forum guidelines. If you check my profile you'll see an argument I had with

  • I assumed I was banned because of that argument I checked the forum guidelines.
    I did no such thing, why would I even want to do that? I honestly couldn't care less about the likes I receive.

    It wasn't related to that; you were banned for something different, if you check your PM notifications.

  • edited February 2017

    Why is AJ "clearly the number one priority"? Did they say that?

  • Are you asking why a newborn baby in a group that consider themselves a family and consider the most important thing in life as family is the number one priority of that group?

    Because it's pretty obvious. They don't have to say it, that's just how it is.

    Why is AJ "clearly the number one priority"? Did they say that?

  • Ok, I see. I don't agree with the logic of carrying a baby around in a world like that so I guess it's not that obvious to me. Which is why I asked. Thanks.

    ZombiePizza posted: »

    Are you asking why a newborn baby in a group that consider themselves a family and consider the most important thing in life as family is th

  • Why did Mike carry A.J across the lake?

    Why not?

  • edited February 2017

    You clearly only read the title of this thread and not the description.

    Or you're being a troll.

    Why did Mike carry A.J across the lake? Why not?

  • Hi, I'm ECIT. You must be new.

    ZombiePizza posted: »

    You clearly only read the title of this thread and not the description. Or you're being a troll.

  • Relatively new, why are you some sort of notorious troll I should be concerned about,
    or is this your attempt at making an Introduction?

    Hi, I'm ECIT. You must be new.

  • Perhaps it's both... or neither...

    ZombiePizza posted: »

    Relatively new, why are you some sort of notorious troll I should be concerned about, or is this your attempt at making an Introduction?

  • Haha, okay. Nice to meet you anyways.

    Perhaps it's both... or neither...

  • You're absolutely right, if Sarah had have taken Bonnie's place it would have made more sense. Instead of Bonnie being reckless and under pressure wanting to save Luke it could have been Sarah as she would probably consider Luke to be her guardian as he was the only surviving member of the cabin group and her father seemed to think quite highly of him.

    She would probably have been frozen in fear and Clem would have to either urge her into helping Luke while she covered her or Clem tries to save Luke herself, more or less the same way as the original scene with a few minor dialogue changes. If Clem covered Sarah, Sarah would fall in and both her and Luke would die or if Clem fell in then Jane or Bonnie (or hell maybe even Sarah in a rare instance of courage) would pull her out and Sarah would go with Bonnie and Mike as i'd imagine they would be nicer to her than Jane and Kenny and she would feel more comfortable with them.

    In this instance Bonnie doesn't die which could mess with the fact she was originally determinent and now Sarah is determinent, but we'll probably never see her or Mike or Arvo ever again anyway.

    DabigRG posted: »

    You know, it occurs to me that, despite being past the limit most would allow, this would've been a perfect example of where Sarah would've been useful to keep around.

  • You're absolutely right, if Sarah had have taken Bonnie's place it would have made more sense. Instead of Bonnie being reckless and under pressure wanting to save Luke it could have been Sarah as she would probably consider Luke to be her guardian as he was the only surviving member of the cabin group and her father seemed to think quite highly of him.

    Uh...sure, but I was referring to the fact that she could've carried AJ if you saved her from the trailer.
    (#ThirstyLatina?)

    Sarah would go with Bonnie and Mike as i'd imagine they would be nicer to her than Jane and Kenny and she would feel more comfortable with them. In this instance Bonnie doesn't die which could mess with the fact she was originally determinent and now Sarah is determinent, but we'll probably never see her or Mike or Arvo ever again anyway.

    Honestly, I'm not really sure why they made Bonnie determinant in that scene to begin with; maybe for the sake of determinantly having Arvo on his own in the early builds of the episode?
    Also, how Sarah would've reacted to the Russian Standoff, the feud between Luke/Jane and Kenny, and Kenny's treatment of Arvo is something I've found wondering about and even going back-n-forth on.

    ZombiePizza posted: »

    You're absolutely right, if Sarah had have taken Bonnie's place it would have made more sense. Instead of Bonnie being reckless and under pr

Sign in to comment in this discussion.