Is Clem Afro-Asian( black and asian)?

2

Comments

  • edited January 2017

    I would say Clementine looks half white half black getting most traits from her mother. She seems she's got light hazel eyes which came from her mother's side.

    Telltale seems to like female black characters overall since they put a lot of them central to the story.

  • Really? She looked like a light shade of African to me. Maybe mixed between white and black.

    Aerie88 posted: »

    Well, imo, the family photo of Clem and her parents always looked to me like Clem's father was black and her mom was Asian of some sort...even when TTG said that she was only black, she always has looked to me like she mixed.

  • If both your parents are black and you come out with asian complexion, then it's pretty fucking weird. People are just questioning how that happened; I think they have a right to.

    there76 posted: »

    It's what people are implying. Both her parents are black, but somehow she is magically Asian and the only reason people say that is because her skin color is apparently not black enough for people.

  • Clementine's complexion is not the same as Chris Brown's or Beyonce's, though. It would be a fair argument if it was, but the reason why this topic keeps coming up is because many people share the same view, that Clementine has an unusual complexion for someone with 2 black parents. I don't think it's a case of ignorance.

    People who keep saying her mom looks "asian-ish" have obviously not been around many black people. African Americans come in every shape

  • DeltinoDeltino Moderator

    For what it's worth, the game's art director is Asian, and he based Clementine's character design in part off of his own daughter. As a result, she has some Asian features.

    Telltale has said African-American in the past, but I believe they've also said mixed, and now Melissa has said Afro-Asian. Truth be told, I don't think anyone over at Telltale ever decided what the hell race she actually is. They probably just said "Clementine is Clementine, end of story"

  • And the picture of her parents are black people

    bloop posted: »

    I thought it was obvious she is black. Just that she is a lighter black compared to Lee. I also think TellTale confirmed that she is when Season 1 was coming out or finished. Why would most confuse her for being Lee's daughter if she wasn't black?

  • I didn't understand how this was a question.

    Lee picks up a pic of her parents in the first episode and it's clearly a black guy and an asian chick.

  • edited March 2017

    Melissa Hutchison confirmed in a podcast that Clementine is a mix of African-American and Asian.

  • Clementine is definitely African-American, perhaps mixed. I actually really like this post someone made comparing Clem to her mother: Clem definitely has her skin tone and her natural hair.

  • I don't get why people are packing a tanty over her ethnic identity... it may be a bit of a shocker to you but just get over it

  • Here's the link confirming her ethnicity again

    http://the-walking-dead-interviews.wikia.com/wiki/Jessica_Brezzo_Interview?_ga=1.86854362.374252603.1347438274

    And if you're too lazy to click the link here's the quote itself

    Question

    "What ethnicity is Clementine?"

    Answer

    "African American"

    Jessica Brezzo Lead Animator

  • One says African Asian and the other says African American wtf do they not communicate?

    Here's the link confirming her ethnicity again http://the-walking-dead-interviews.wikia.com/wiki/Jessica_Brezzo_Interview?_ga=1.86854362.

  • I see no Asian in her or her mother.

  • If you don't mind me asking do you know who said she was African-Asian? Because I've seen a lot of people say a staff member said so but they haven't been able to give any sources.

    hesif posted: »

    One says African Asian and the other says African American wtf do they not communicate?

  • Melissa Hutchinson said so

    http://fanfest.com/2017/01/03/walking-dead-cast-247-the-walking-dead-a-new-frontier-melissa-hutchison/

    Listen to the audio she says it at around the end I think. Not entirely sure

    If you don't mind me asking do you know who said she was African-Asian? Because I've seen a lot of people say a staff member said so but they haven't been able to give any sources.

  • I have seen lots of people like Clementine with origins from the Carribeans.
    But they usually had a mixed family from African, Native American, Chinese, and very little bit white ancestry.
    Clementine looks like a mixed girl of all.

    I think Telltale used the American 'one drop rule' race classification, wich means one drop of African blood makes you African American. No matter there is Asian or white ancestry, with one small drop African blood you will be totally classified as Afro American.

    For example: Tiger Woods is half Afro American, half Thai. His mother is a full Thai woman.
    He is never described as Asian American, Blasian or Afro Asian, but Afro American!

    And no matter you are 25% African and 75% European for example, in the USA you will be classified as black or Afro American.

    Most of the Afro Americans are mixed anyway. None of them is 100% African.
    The more light skin they have, the more mixed ancestry they have from Europeans, Asians or Native Americans.

  • edited March 2017

    Clementines Mother looks like a mix between Africans and Filipino's to me.

  • That's not true, the more light doesn't equal the more white, Africa is a very diverse continent with many different colors and skin tones, a black person doesn't need any amount of whiteness to be lightskin

    Bonbon80 posted: »

    I have seen lots of people like Clementine with origins from the Carribeans. But they usually had a mixed family from African, Native Ameri

  • edited March 2017

    Sorry to tell you, but very true. Just do a study about the genetics of Afro Americans.
    You can find academic studies about this on the internet. None of them is 100% African.
    The average is 80% African, 20% European. Some have higher or lower amount of white blood and some have significant amount of Asian or Native American blood.
    But this is a different topic:)
    And Beyonce has confirmed distant French and Native American ancestry by herself before...there you go with her light skin!

    Clementine is just confirmed African American with pressumably some Asian blood.
    Anyway, who cares what she is.
    Clementine is cool anyway.

    That's not true, the more light doesn't equal the more white, Africa is a very diverse continent with many different colors and skin tones, a black person doesn't need any amount of whiteness to be lightskin

  • People do realize that Melissa has zero creative input right? I mean she didn't help design Clem did she?
    No. She's just a voice actress that happens to work with telltale. So what Melissa says about Clem's race is entirely her opinion and not a fact.

    hesif posted: »

    Melissa Hutchinson said so http://fanfest.com/2017/01/03/walking-dead-cast-247-the-walking-dead-a-new-frontier-melissa-hutchison/ Listen to the audio she says it at around the end I think. Not entirely sure

  • It could've also been in audition notes like Lilly's last name and the idea of her being abused.

    People do realize that Melissa has zero creative input right? I mean she didn't help design Clem did she? No. She's just a voice actress th

  • edited March 2017

    'Telltale seems to like female black characters overall since they put a lot of them central to the story.'

    Wow is this bad?
    I see Telltale likes Ethnic diversity.
    At the beginning a black protagonist, second season a mixed race child, third season a Hispanic man.

    As far I know the characters from most of Telltale games are white. Just the walking dead series has all different ethnicities from the world.
    Perhaps in the next season we will play an Arab or Scottish person :)

    The bunch of game characters are white anyway.
    We already have dozens of Lara Croft look a like women.

    I would say Clementine looks half white half black getting most traits from her mother. She seems she's got light hazel eyes which came from

  • I guess we would have to ask Sean about it then.

    DabigRG posted: »

    It could've also been in audition notes like Lilly's last name and the idea of her being abused.

  • UGH who cares its clementine thats all what matters

  • the shape of her eyes and the way her mother looked in the photo on the mantle made me think that maybe Clem's mother was Filipino or something or possibly central or south american.

    Now, I do i agree with you that she looks mixed. I just happen to think that she is either mixed with Asian or central/south american.

    Really? She looked like a light shade of African to me. Maybe mixed between white and black.

  • "This led to changing Clementine's race from white to African-American, as to give her the appearance of possibly being Lee's daughter to other characters.[1]"

    Source: Wikipedia (http://www.gameinformer.com/b/features/archive/2012/12/26/creating-clementine.aspx)

  • Nope. Looks Korean to me. I'm mix myself and I can tell you IF she is part asian she has more Korean features.

    Ok that was just Melissa's guess. I would say she is of mixed heritage...I looked up Blasian in the ole Google and came up with pictures of

  • Her small mouth is typical East Asian.

    Ok that was just Melissa's guess. I would say she is of mixed heritage...I looked up Blasian in the ole Google and came up with pictures of

  • She is a light skin black girl. I have seen many of them, hell even dated a few. But if she is Asian than she looks like she has either more of Korean or Chinese features. But I heard that the guy who designed was Asian and based Clem off his daughter. So anything goes lol.

  • edited May 2017

    I'm suprised by these comments. It seems that nobody has seen a light skinned black girl before. Judging by these comments a black person needs to be extra crispy to be black lmao.

    Guys she's a light skinned black girl get over it.

  • She has no creative input and many people in TellTale constantly said she was African American.

    Mojazz22 posted: »

    Melissa Hutchison confirmed in a podcast that Clementine is a mix of African-American and Asian.

  • So you're saying a black girl can't be light skinned? I have met many who are.

    NorthStars posted: »

    I think point is you just choose what race you imagine clem to be. She seemed white in s1, Asian/white season 2, and Idk season 3. They say

  • The person who design Clem's character was asian and based her off his daughter. Maybe that explains her features.

    Douug posted: »

    If both your parents are black and you come out with asian complexion, then it's pretty fucking weird. People are just questioning how that happened; I think they have a right to.

  • You're grasping at straws mate.

    Aerie88 posted: »

    the shape of her eyes and the way her mother looked in the photo on the mantle made me think that maybe Clem's mother was Filipino or someth

  • She has no creative input so you can take it with a grain of salt. Reason she looks asian is cause the guys design her character was asian and based her off his daughter.

    Yes, it's true she said it in an interview, I would suggest listening to the whole thing because there is a lot of important information abo

  • edited May 2017

    Hong, a lot of Afro Americans appear light skin because they are mixed. They all have white blood from slavery times.
    And many blacks have Chinese genes from long ago. Because in the past many railroad workers were Chinese men without women and not be able to have relationship with white women. So many of the Chinese men got relationship with black females or creole women.
    Lot of Afro Americans aren't even aware of this anymore.

    dr_hong10 posted: »

    The person who design Clem's character was asian and based her off his daughter. Maybe that explains her features.

  • Thank you that's the point I was trying to make lol

    dr_hong10 posted: »

    I'm suprised by these comments. It seems that nobody has seen a light skinned black girl before. Judging by these comments a black person needs to be extra crispy to be black lmao. Guys she's a light skinned black girl get over it.

  • edited May 2017

    Mixed girl you mean.
    I am mixed Asian myself and I see lots of common features inside Clem with East Asians.

    Clem looks like a Carribean mixed girl with Afro, Chinese, Spanish/Portuguese and Native American blood.
    I have seen many of Clem's type in this area.
    But people always talk about being black, if you have a small single drop of Afroblood. Even if just 30% African genes, people still call you black.

    Tiger woods is an example. He is always called afro american in media, but the fact is he is Blasian. His mom is Thai, his dad is Afro American.

    Like we are doomned to be called black with just small amount of real Afro genes according to the outdated racist American one drop rule.

    dr_hong10 posted: »

    I'm suprised by these comments. It seems that nobody has seen a light skinned black girl before. Judging by these comments a black person needs to be extra crispy to be black lmao. Guys she's a light skinned black girl get over it.

  • Maybe so, but the entire point of this discussion thread is to discuss what we think Clementine's ethnicity is.

    dr_hong10 posted: »

    You're grasping at straws mate.

  • I believe this one more than I believe the blasting thing, I know the wiki isn't the most reliable source but they always update the site when new info is leaked and clem is still down as African American and ed is still down as her real father.

    Here's the link confirming her ethnicity again http://the-walking-dead-interviews.wikia.com/wiki/Jessica_Brezzo_Interview?_ga=1.86854362.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.