Would you spare Eleanor's life after she sold you out too Joan???
Would you spare Eleanor's life after she sold Javier and the group to Joan? Would you forgive her and give her a second chance, or would you waste her for treason???
You decide her fate wether she's done for or redeemed so she can live another day.
To me I would forgive her (however) I would lock her up just to give her time to think on what she has done. She's not that evil she's just (desperate) she the just didn't want too leave Richmond despite what happened to (Prescott) even tho the NF destroyed her home she probably thought it would have been better stay their instead of of leaving disputes that the (walkers) were at the gates.
Tell me what you guys think , you desire her fate.
Let me know in the comment secretion bellow.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
It depends on her attitude towards Javier when facing them. If she's remorseful, I am the last person who you can't talk to. But if she's the opposite of that, or even threatens someone of Javi's group (Clem, yes even Gabe, David, etc), she'll meet the deadly end of my gun.
I definitely wouldn't trust Eleanor after that (given how we've seen things go with characters like Bonnie in the past), but if given the chance, yeah, I'd keep her alive. It's not every day that a medic lives this long.
Yes, but definitely banish and never trust her again.
Yeah, in S2, covering Luke is the better option than trying to get to him on already breaking ice. If Bonnie hadn't tried, there would've been a chance for Luke to get out. And Bonnie's pissed on Clem for the smarter choice, and tells Mike to leave her for good, while she bleeds out on the ground.
So if Eleanor is anything alike, that'd be her death sentence, even though that somewhat contradicts what I posted above your comment. Well, I'm a moody sonuvabitch.
Yes, traitors deserve to die.
Of course I would. I'm not some murderous avenger (most of the time) after all. Eleanor, much like Mike before her, has done nothing but good for the group before it could even be called one but unlike him, her actions could've benefited the many rather than the few had things played more in her favor. Her problem was likely not knowing what she was getting into making a deal with Joan, who I don't think any of us would've thought was capable of going that far. Regardless of what her naivety wrought, I believe in giving people a chance to try and make things right, a chance I definitely plan on giving her.
Incidentally, that lock up comment was actually my stance on Joan originally.
We shouldnt be criticising Eleanor, she is another victim of one of the worse diseases known to man and women called'Telltale Lazy Writing' Syndrome
She has no real character so I have no reason to want her to live in the story. Utterly worthless character
I am far more likely to end her rather than giving her another chance. I don't care what reasons she had, she betrayed us and got Tripp or Ava killed.
And Tripp does?
This is Yvette from Tales from the Borderlands all over again.
Um...when did I say he did?
Trip pre episode 4 wasnt the best but he at least had something of a character if a bit simplistic. Post episode 4 Tripp lost any character he had in the same scene as Gabe.
As such Tripp joins eleanor and most other characters in the game as people I really dont care what happens.
Yes. I didn't kill Conrad, so in my play through, she was unsure of her decision and it looked like she didn't betray me out of spite. Also, if Conrad can be redeemed, then Eleanor can definitely be redeemed.
You know, maybe that's the problem: it's not he has no character so much as it's ridiculously simple. I only really brought him up because some people alternate between who's the blandest of the two. She at least had something in the way of a purpose and reasoning for her actions, as far as I can tell.
I dont think she has anything at all, she had a character in episode 1 and then shes just... there
Pretty much.
I believe I give her slack in part because she hasn't had much screentime to confound me like he has, so I maintain a single impression of her.
If she somehow gets screentime during the chaos and confusion going around in Richmond after zombies got inside, when fire consumes the city, and everyone runs around screaming and shooting at each other? Yeah, why not. Maybe she'll get some actual development.
That's what we're hoping for, even if the betrayal part wasn't the preferred scenario.
Then shooting is good, Eleanor would be busy stitching wounds. I can already imagine the line full of people, ready to be granted with those smiley stickers you get for being brave and well-behaved.
She is basically Bonnie 2.0 now. If it wasn't for her knowledge in medicine, killing her would be the safest option.
On one hand she saved Kate and Gabe from the junkyard and is an invaluable medic.
On the other hand I wouldn't ever trust her again and if she betrayed us again that would be on me.
I can't make up my mind yet.
Hell no I will kill her
Eleanor is a Grade A SNAKE. She can kiss my ass.
I always regretted sparing her for some reason. With Doug over Carley the decision was more clear. I didn't like the betraying way Yvette's character was.. yet still rescued her.
Only sparing her if she redeems herself by doing something like saving Kate. Otherwise she's dead to me.
I don't think I would spare Eleanor. Her decision to rat us out to join gets Ava killed and even puts Tripp in danger. I don't like traitors.
However, if given the opportunity, I'd put it up to a vote ( assuming that everyone in group, sans Ava, survives. )
If I'm willing to spare Rufus and Max, I'm willing to spare her life too. I don't believe Eleanor to be a bad person.
Nah. If Kate is actually dead, I need some backup booty.
Nah, for real, if given the choice -- I'm going to spare her life. I just want to know the full reasoning behind her decision, I don't want to hear it from Joan (well, she got blasted in the face anyways) or Clint or anyone other than Eleanor.
I was kind to Eleanor and she was kind to me. I hope that still counts for something. And plus Conrad's still alive for me, so she doesn't hate my guts.
Won't kill her, but she's effectively dead to me. Want nothing to do with her. She's on her own, and she can think about how she got Tripp killed for the rest of her short days.
Not sure, 70/30 that I off her for what she did. After episode 4, I'm really looking at a lot of characters the same way.
I would not keep her close but I would spare her definitely. She did fix me up and she saved Kate's life. She'd better stay away, but she would be ok
My Javier is merciless so no I wouldn't kill that bitch EVEN THOUGH SHE GOT TRIPP KILLED
You must lack brain cells. Eleanor betrays you and you don't think she's a bad person?
I don't think you know what merciless means....
so let me get this straight Tripp lost his entire character because he was mad at you?
That is not merciless.....If I saw her tied up in a pool of water up to her nose...I would piss in the pool....now that is merciless.
Nope.
if she just don't leave our groupe, i kill her
Tripp lost his entire character by flipping out at the guy he kept calling his best friend and not allowing any explanation, then claiming he was better off with Joan. Again this is being generous and thinking Tripp had much of a character before that. However loyal and trusting reasonable guy who wants to avoid trouble all got thrown out the window.
This is the guy who sides with and calls javi the boss of the group within a day, but no now he flips out and acts deranged. His turn isnt quite as bad as gabes but still there we go.
Yes. Did anyone consider she was threatened by Joan?