More impact? Kenny's comeback in Ep 2 or Lilly's in Ep 2
Both characters came back in Episode 2 of a season, but who's left more impact on you in the trailers? Seeing Clem's reaction "I thought you were dead" or seeing Lilly in the end of the trailer
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Those weren’t even the same scene tho so it isn’t her return scene
deleted
Lily, because it’s been years since last saw her. And in those years, we were all talking about Kenny, Lee, Jane, AJ Clementine, and Christa, without much leftover concern to Lily’s fate. For all we know Telltale could have been planning this from the beginning.
Lily, simply because she went rogue and hasn't been seen since season 1, but suddenly returns after 8 years.
Kenny left more of an impact if we're strictly speaking how the trailers made an impact. It was unexpected, whereas I've been anticipating the arrival of either Christa or Lily in TFS. I have been wondering what happened to her since the achievement was switched from Woodbury as she officially had to deviate from her original design after the book was released though.
Kenny
Mostly because I didn't have any suspicions Kenny would come back at all
But they've shown Lilly in the trailer and she was the only one that you get choices for in the character generator so pretty obvious she's coming back
The obvious answer is Kenny. Although many guessed he would make a comeback, there was still a wonder. I don't think Lily should have been revealed because as far as I knew, it was another character returning. But that shock of her return has been taken away from just about everyone that's paying attention to this game. The scene or scenes may still be good, but still - terrible decision imo to reveal her in the trailer.
Uh, this doesn't work yet because
a. Kenny himself wasn't shown in the Next Time segment or the trailer for the episode.
b. Lilly's role in Suffer the Children is [being made look] far more pivotal than Kenny actually was in A House Divided.
But for the sake of an answer, if the trailer has half the accuracy it probably doesn't to the actual episode, Lily will have the bigger impact.
Long run, Kenny definitely had more of an impact. Lily, I don't see having that much long term effect other than being Lily and back.
Hard to say...hopefully her return will not screw up the last half of season 4 like Kenny did season 2
Gonna go with Kenny. Mostly because it was kinda obvious Lily would return, then leaks happened, but even without leaks it seemed obvious Lily would come back, also revealing her in the trailer lessens the reveal in game. You could say Kenny returning was obvious, but it wasnt as obvious as Lily, at the time it could have been Kenny, Lily, or Christa, so there was a good chunk of people to choose, also the fact nothing leaked nor did Telltale show off Kenny in the trailer.
Maybe her in game reveal will be really good, but I feel like it will 100% be less effective than Kenny's because we know for a fact she shows up.
I agree 100% with the trailer reveal. It sucks things leaked which is probably why they revealed her in the trailer, but I still think they shouldnt have done it. For one it kills the reveal for people who werent already spoiled. Just such a big reveal shouldnt have leaked, this trailer probably spoiled the most out of any other trailer.
Lilly i think
Kenny because I honestly thought they wouldn’t bring him back. The ‘surprise’ factor of his return really got me. Lily’s return is definitely really cool, but it definitely wasn’t a suprise.
give up on kenny ffs
Lilly's seeing as for years I never expected her to ever return, much less revealed to be returning in a trailer
Kenny's return actually did leak after episode 1 came out, but it didn't get spread around as much as Lilly which was almost impossible to avoid
Please, you have to let Kenny go.. it has been 4 years.. ANF wasn't your fault ;-;
That was just a rumor, it wasnt a real model of Kenny found in the files it was fan made.
Too early to say, but for me when Clementine met Kenny again at the Ski Lodge was one of the best moments in the game.