What characters do you think should have been minor instead of major?

This question works both ways, so feel free to answer both or just one.

«13

Comments

  • Minor: Kate and Gabe ANF
    Major: Jesus ANF

  • I felt like Marlon should have took in the bigger role, I mean Mitch shouldn’t have been killed off think you should Have been kidnapped, like Omar,Aasim and Marlon major role in the episode3 and 4 on redeeming his character were selling out Tenns sisters.

  • Major: Clementine ANF

  • Minor- Definitely Gabe, urgh.
    Major - Jesus damn right.

  • edited October 2018

    Season2!Kenny.
    Oh and Tripp/Paul.

  • Minor: All of ANF's cast.
    Major: Clementine in ANF

  • I'm honestly struggling to come up with other examples, as these games's problems often have to due with most of it's characters not being important and/or explored enough.

  • minor: Arvo, so that people would stop antagonizing him for no good reason
    major: Omar, because we know nothing about him, and Mariana, because her treatment as a character (but not her character itself) is just riddled with Yikes(TM)

  • minor: Arvo, so that people would stop antagonizing him for no good reason

    The dude shot Clementine with the intent to kill and sent his men to try and kill us. I think people have a pretty good reason to antagonize him.

    minor: Arvo, so that people would stop antagonizing him for no good reason major: Omar, because we know nothing about him, and Mariana, because her treatment as a character (but not her character itself) is just riddled with Yikes(TM)

  • Actually, Arvo wasn't the leader of the group and wasn't even comfortable with what little he was told to do.

    minor: Arvo, so that people would stop antagonizing him for no good reason The dude shot Clementine with the intent to kill and sent his men to try and kill us. I think people have a pretty good reason to antagonize him.

  • Almost forgot about...

    Major: Peter Joseph Randall

  • Sure, and Lilly totally meant to shoot Doug.

    minor: Arvo, so that people would stop antagonizing him for no good reason The dude shot Clementine with the intent to kill and sent his men to try and kill us. I think people have a pretty good reason to antagonize him.

  • ^ this very much

    Almost forgot about... Major: Peter Joseph Randall

  • edited October 2018

    Minor: Luke
    Major: Nick

    Nick, although being a prick, was more interesting, and had a lot of potential for an arc. Instead that was reserved for jane, but I liked her so it’s not a complaint but more like a curious intrigue.

  • I recall seeing a few people make the argument that they probably could've just been one character.

    Instead that was reserved for jane,

    Uh, mind explaining this? Correlation wise anyway.

  • Minor definitely Kate, I can't stand that woman.

  • She was introduced as a loner who didn’t like people, then became attached to clem and luke, being apart of the group by episode 5.

    DabigRG posted: »

    I recall seeing a few people make the argument that they probably could've just been one character. Instead that was reserved for jane, Uh, mind explaining this? Correlation wise anyway.

  • Minor - gabe and luke
    Major - mariana and ava

  • What the heck happened with my comment?

    She was introduced as a loner who didn’t like people, then became attached to clem and luke, being apart of the group by episode 5.

    No, I meant what does she have to do with Nick?

    She was introduced as a loner who didn’t like people, then became attached to clem and luke, being apart of the group by episode 5.

  • Im not sure about Minor but as for major id say Mitch would be my pick.

  • Because Jane was the only side character to have one. Where Season 2 gives us a character that changes through experiences. Nick lost Pete and wanted to step up to help the group more but then died.

    DabigRG posted: »

    What the heck happened with my comment? She was introduced as a loner who didn’t like people, then became attached to clem and luke, being apart of the group by episode 5. No, I meant what does she have to do with Nick?

  • Minor - Gabe I was not a fan.
    Major - Nate he was quite the character.

  • Kenny in Season 2. Really hate how forced he is in the story.

  • I literally just realized that the OP says it can be the other way around as well.

    In that case,
    Minor: Kenny, Nick(kinda), Jane, David, Mariana(eh, sorta), Lonnie, Badger, Tripp, jesus,
    Major: Jolene, Christa, Becca(somewhat), Michelle, Mike/"Ralph", Carlos, Sarah, Alvin, Arvo, Edith, Eleanor, Ava, Shades-Chick, Aasim, Brodie

  • Season 1:
    Minor: (honestly I can't really think of anyone here. Season One was pretty rock solid on character)
    Major: Chuck

    Season 2:
    Minor: Bonnie
    Major: Pete

    Season 3:
    Minor: Eleanor (I hate Gabe as much as you all, but he shouldn't be made a minor character, he should be made better.
    Major: Kenny/Jane

    Season 4:
    Minor: (Once again I can't think of anything. All the major characters deserve to be major.)
    Major: Aasim

  • One...arc?

    Because Jane was the only side character to have one. Where Season 2 gives us a character that changes through experiences. Nick lost Pete and wanted to step up to help the group more but then died.

  • edited October 2018

    Well..yeah? I mean, Rebecca and Bonnie too. But the main, obvious, and most centered arc that the game focus on. Like how Kenny was for season 1.

    DabigRG posted: »

    One...arc?

  • Uh huh....
    ....
    This conversation feels disjointed..

    Well..yeah? I mean, Rebecca and Bonnie too. But the main, obvious, and most centered arc that the game focus on. Like how Kenny was for season 1.

  • Shades-Chick

    This!! What's the point of showing her face so many times? Made me think she was actually on our side and was preparing an uprising for Javi and co.

    DabigRG posted: »

    I literally just realized that the OP says it can be the other way around as well. In that case, Minor: Kenny, Nick(kinda), Jane, David

  • She was apparently another friend of David's too and was indeed planning on telling people what happened between him and Joan if Javier tried to leave with Kate.

    Not to mention how oddly detailed her model was in comparison to most of the New Frontier soldiers.

    Ghetsis posted: »

    Shades-Chick This!! What's the point of showing her face so many times? Made me think she was actually on our side and was preparing an uprising for Javi and co.

  • edited October 2018

    Minor: Mike, Bonnie, Jane, Rebecca, David, Kate and Gabe

    Major: Chuck, ANF Clementine, ANF Kenny, Mariana, Nick and Sarah

  • Interesting choices, guys. Thank you for the responses.

  • Minor: lee, clementine, kenny, duck, doug, carley, lilly, larry, danny, andy, brenda, mark, christa, omid, chuck, the stranger, alvin, sarah, carlos, rebecca, aj, jane, nick, luke, pete, mike, bonnie, arvo, edith, carver, kate, gabe, javier, jesus, badger, max, david, joan, tripp, ava, elanor, conrad, marlon, louis, brody, ruby, mitch, aasim, omar, willy, violet, abel.

    Major: Rosie.

  • The Heroine we deserve.

    Auruo posted: »

    Minor: lee, clementine, kenny, duck, doug, carley, lilly, larry, danny, andy, brenda, mark, christa, omid, chuck, the stranger, alvin, sarah

  • edited October 2018

    Minor: Tripp, Gabe, And Badger in ANF. Jane in S2.

    Major: AJ and Clementine in ANF. Kenny and (I know it’s a place but) Wellington in ANF. Oh, and Alvin too in S2.

  • Minor: Season 2 Kenny
    Major: Sarita, Nick

  • Antagonising him for no good reason?? I think you need to play Season 2 again

    minor: Arvo, so that people would stop antagonizing him for no good reason major: Omar, because we know nothing about him, and Mariana, because her treatment as a character (but not her character itself) is just riddled with Yikes(TM)

  • edited October 2018

    It doesn’t matter. He was part of the group, if his sister hadn’t been shot you don’t know if he would have went along with trying to kill the others. Just because someone translated the Russian language or because a dev said so wasn’t clear enough in the game. Plus Arvo is Arvo anyway lol.

    No excuse at all. Fuck Arvo

    DabigRG posted: »

    Actually, Arvo wasn't the leader of the group and wasn't even comfortable with what little he was told to do.

  • edited October 2018

    Lilly can go fuck herself. Defending her for shooting Doug is ridiculous especially as most people chose Carley, and that death was deliberate

    Sure, and Lilly totally meant to shoot Doug.

  • ???

    Kenny in Season 2. Really hate how forced he is in the story.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.