Dumbest moves by any TWD characters (show or game)

Jane hanging herself. I'm a big Jane fan, but doing this in secrecy just galled me. If she had it in her head to do this, she could have a) told Clem about it and give her a heads up b) talk to Clem about it. Was there another way of getting rid of the baby?

«1

Comments

  • Beth stabbing Dawn. Complete ludicrousness.

  • I'm not a Sarah fan, but I didn't like that "second" death. Was the wreckage too heavy for her and does that mean that Clem would have been trapped in the same scenario?

  • The Arvo gunfight was terribly written, and let's just say, Arvo hiding the drugs in that spot, was also terribly written.

  • Ben working with the bandits. Who did Ben think was alive? His reasoning for working with them made no sense.

  • Rick leaving Sophia alone to fend for herself when there were only two walkers to deal with.

  • Yes.

    The Arvo gunfight was terribly written, and let's just say, Arvo hiding the drugs in that spot, was also terribly written.

    He was looking for a safe enough spot to stash the medicine long enough to go get his sister. The bag didn't fit though, so he was about to go find somewhere when he finally notices Clementine watching him.

    Ben working with the bandits. Who did Ben think was alive? His reasoning for working with them made no sense.

    Actually, that's makes perfect sense from his perspective: The bandits had been terrorizing him, his classmates, and his teachers for a quite a while, gradually picking them off both figuratively and literally. He and Travis just got lucky enough to be led in escaping with Mr. Parker as long as they did once they saw an opening.
    And then those same bandits not only start attacking his new group at their distinct location(that includes even younger kids), but also claim they're still keeping one of his friends alive? Of course he's gonna be willing to strike a deal with them.
    And even once he realized they were [technically?] lying, they were still promising to leave the Motel Group alone as long as he keeps providing them with a protection package every once in a while.

    Torridd posted: »

    I'm not a Sarah fan, but I didn't like that "second" death. Was the wreckage too heavy for her and does that mean that Clem would have been trapped in the same scenario?

  • In the games ?

    Jane killing herself in S3 without writing a note or telling Clem or whatever,
    has to be the dumbest thing ever,for sure.

    I'll always blame the writers for that shit anyway,there's no way someone like Jane would do this,but that's just my opinion i know many people would disagree with me about that.

    In the show ?

    Beth trying to kill that cop with those scissors in season 5 is literally the worst thing i've ever seen,like,holy shit Beth what the fuck were you trying to do here,and her plan was so fucking stupid too,a lot of people could have died,good job you fucking idiot.

  • Game: Lilly shooting Carley/Doug without a valid reason and/or any proof at all. Another one would be Ben getting the hatchet that was sealing the door at Crawford. Jane hanging herself was just bad writing and Ben handing supplies to Bandits was understandable for him, stupid but understandable.

    Show: I'd go with Daryl trying to fight Negan after Abraham's death while being outnumbered and unarmed. Second one would be Beth trying to stab Dawn, some things are just not worth the risk.

  • S1 Ben removing that hatchet which was preventing all those walkers to enter inside the building in Crawford.
    S2 Arvo shooting Clementine.
    S3 Clementine killing Eli to prove her point, you don't pull the trigger so casually.
    S4 Probably Mitch going full Leeroy Jenkins against Lilly.

  • Beth stabbing Dawn
    Andrea not killing The Governor
    Shane betraying Rick
    Daryl punching Negan after he killed Glenn
    Helicopter fuckers taking Rick Grimes

  • Sarah talking while Carver was monologuing. That was so dumb, I wanted to slap her.

  • Willingly leaving and destroying in the process a safe and well supplied community only to spend the next two episodes complaining, struggling and dying because they don’t have a safe and well supplied community.

  • Pretty much every game since S2 in a nutshell right there. ^^

  • He thought it was the only way to keep the group alive. Remember they were fighting the bandits for about 2 weeks. Ben thought he was keeping the group safe. And he was until Lee found the meds. If Ben hadn't stolen the meds the bandits would've attacked the motor inn anyway

    Torridd posted: »

    Ben working with the bandits. Who did Ben think was alive? His reasoning for working with them made no sense.

  • S2 Arvo shooting Clementine.

    If you were cooperating with Mike, definitely.

    S3 Clementine killing Eli to prove her point, you don't pull the trigger so casually.

    What makes it even better is that she was there because she thought the bullets wouldn't work in the first place.

    Gauss99 posted: »

    S1 Ben removing that hatchet which was preventing all those walkers to enter inside the building in Crawford. S2 Arvo shooting Clementine.

  • Kate and Gabe running out to a gunfire to pick up Marianas dead body.

    1. Bonnie blaming Clem for Luke's death
    2. Mitch charging Lilly WITHOUT A FUCKING WEAPON! Violet said he was good in a fight; guess not.
    3. Beth trying to kill Dawn was actually smart. She left the show before it went down hill. But how do kill someone by stabbing them in the fucking shoulder?
    4. Not killing all the Saviors when they surrendered. I get that it's Jesus' character but he had no problem killing the Saviors in the outpost with Rick. Attacking the outpost was Jesus' idea.
    5. Carol killing people then not wanting to kill then go back to killing. Same thing with Morgan. Carol staying in that fucking house for half of season 7 was so dumb too.
    6. Morgan is strangling Richard AND NO ONE STOPS HIM?!
    7. Everything Henry does
    8. Whenever someone cries except Daryl. It's so fake and dumb sounding. Sucks the sadness right out of the mood with bad acting. Ex. Maggie when Glenn died. Maggie when Rick let Negan live. Her crying is so bad. It was only good for S2 and for Hershel. Rick's crying is always bad. S3, and especially S7 with that snot bubble. Holy fuck has no one heard of retakes?

    I could go on and on but I'm tired

  • Yeah that always bothered me.

    Torridd posted: »

    Rick leaving Sophia alone to fend for herself when there were only two walkers to deal with.

  • Never...ever no matter fucking what...even if you may be stupid...never fucking disturb a villain when they are in full speech mode.

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    Sarah talking while Carver was monologuing. That was so dumb, I wanted to slap her.

  • first couple did not work....not a good record for those bullets...fuck Eli.

    DabigRG posted: »

    S2 Arvo shooting Clementine. If you were cooperating with Mike, definitely. S3 Clementine killing Eli to prove her point, you

  • He was just trying to run a business(?) and it's implied that Tangerine there had caused a fair amount of scuffles during her previous visits. Being skeptical and/or sticking to your business model on supposedly faulty merchandise is understandable.

    Besides, as I point out, he assumed they did work and that she was trying to force him into trading them back, but she thought they all didn't and came there to get him to replace them. Which is exactly why she repeatedly threats him, the weapons dealer, with said blanks.
    ...Wait.

    first couple did not work....not a good record for those bullets...fuck Eli.

  • Javi not running out of Richmond with Joan's chocolate cake. Had he done that, I wouldn't have taken a massive shit on ANF.

  • In my mind, She only got her point across when a bullet entered his skull ? ??

    Unfortunately, the bullet was the last thing to go through his mind. ??

    DabigRG posted: »

    He was just trying to run a business(?) and it's implied that Tangerine there had caused a fair amount of scuffles during her previous visit

  • edited November 2018

    Even if you weren't cooperating with Mike it doesn't even matter because in the end Clementine just gave her gun to Mike.

    DabigRG posted: »

    S2 Arvo shooting Clementine. If you were cooperating with Mike, definitely. S3 Clementine killing Eli to prove her point, you

  • When Kate forgot she's in TWD and not GTA while driving that truck.

  • To be fair, she was rushing in to rescue the others from the riot and Jagger threw a molotov at her windshield, forcing her to jump out since she couldn't see.

    Nyxeris posted: »

    When Kate forgot she's in TWD and not GTA while driving that truck.

  • she was rushing in to rescue the others from the riot

    ?

    threw a molotov at her windshield

    ?

    forcing her to jump out

    Sounds a lot like GTA Online?

    DabigRG posted: »

    To be fair, she was rushing in to rescue the others from the riot and Jagger threw a molotov at her windshield, forcing her to jump out since she couldn't see.

  • She should have tested them out beforehand. It's pretty obvious that she never used them.

    first couple did not work....not a good record for those bullets...fuck Eli.

  • ...Did you even watch the episode?

    Sounds a lot like GTA Online?

    Ch'yeah, I bet. :lol:

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    she was rushing in to rescue the others from the riot ? threw a molotov at her windshield ? forcing her to jump out Sounds a lot like GTA Online?

  • Javi dropping his gun for no reason in the beginning with the bandits. He could've shot them when they entered the door but nope, then we wouldn't have a plot!

    Kate running out in the middle of a gunfight to try to retrieve a clearly dead Mariana. It was so stupid. Just an excuse to give her a plot wound.

    And no, I am not letting this go: KENNY, UNTIE MY HANDS FIRST BEFORE ASKING ME TO HELP YOU FIGHT OFF ARMED MEN OUTSIDE THE TRUCK.

    The Cabin Group not locking the door when they know they're on the run and Carver could show up with his group at any time. You can't even call them out on this.

    Javi, David, Clementine, Gabe, and either Tripp or Ava could've climbed over the damn cars, instead of precariously around them with a steep fall! Seriously, what was stopping them from even trying that?

  • When Jane killed herself in S3, she does not need to write a note. The reason why she would do something like that goes back to S2, when she was chatting with Clem, about how she would rather be alone, than to have a child.

    Now some other stuffs

    • I didn't take Arvo's med and he's still mad at Clem. He got more upset when he noticed Clem had killed his sister. But he was just looking at the back of her head, while Clem sees she's turning into a Walker. Clem never got a chance to explain why she did it.

    • S1, during the part where Lee was in the sewer system and needs to climb back out. He can't even pick up a ladder.

    • For the PC version, certain parts of the game tells you to use WASD, to complete a task, but only the key that's highlighted will work.
    • Javi never got to give Mariana the chocolate bar, although there is this one part, where it lets me to click on it, but only for a split second and that was it. I was able to give her the batteries for her walkman.
  • Javi, David, Clementine, Gabe, and either Tripp or Ava could've climbed over the damn cars, instead of precariously around them with a steep fall!

    yeah that was pretty stupid?

    Javi dropping his gun for no reason in the beginning with the bandits. He could've shot them when they entered the door but nope, then we wo

  • No it isn't. Climbing on top of them, might cause it to move, taking whosever on it with them, to their death.

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    Javi, David, Clementine, Gabe, and either Tripp or Ava could've climbed over the damn cars, instead of precariously around them with a steep fall! yeah that was pretty stupid?

  • Jane's entire existence. Her neglectful murderous, abortionist villainous ways. Her self centered lack of empathy all culminating in a end where she commits suicide and homocide leaving a child to fend the world ALONE with a baby. Piece of human trash.

    With that said

    1. Lilly killing Carly
    2. Michonne endangering Sam's life for the sake of those annoying ghost pricks.
    3. Not killing Lilly during the RV scene.
  • It's hilarious that she runs over Conrad if you kept him alive and fail the QTE. ?

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    she was rushing in to rescue the others from the riot ? threw a molotov at her windshield ? forcing her to jump out Sounds a lot like GTA Online?

  • Yeah, and why the fuck did that guy throw the Molotov at Kate? She was driving a truck that belonged to the New Frontier; how did the guy know it wasn't his people? How the fuck did he know it was Kate? It was foggy from the tear gas and she was driving too fast to be recognized

    Nyxeris posted: »

    When Kate forgot she's in TWD and not GTA while driving that truck.

  • I get that Beth wanted to kill Dawn. BUT HOW THE FUCK DO YOU KILL SOMEONE BY STABBING THEM IN THE SHOULDER!? Like you said, completely ludicrous

    Torridd posted: »

    Beth stabbing Dawn. Complete ludicrousness.

  • jane hanging herself because she was prego was def the dumbest way to kill her off. she could've just got rid of the fetus thing then buried aj somewhere behind the store. there's a bunch of better ways they could've had jane die. maybe that family could've killed her while trying to rob them.

  • then buried aj somewhere behind the stor

    What?

    maybe that family could've killed her while trying to rob them.

    That's pretty close to what a lot of people speculated would happen.

    sarahsenpai posted: »

    jane hanging herself because she was prego was def the dumbest way to kill her off. she could've just got rid of the fetus thing then buried

  • I like how when you really think about it, that molotov guy did more damage and got more people killed than we did. Sure, we shoot a few guys, but this dude is the one that causes the walkers to invade Richmond.

    Yeah, and why the fuck did that guy throw the Molotov at Kate? She was driving a truck that belonged to the New Frontier; how did the guy kn

Sign in to comment in this discussion.