The Telltale forums are now read only. Past posts will stay available to browse, but new posts and replies have moved to our official Discord.

Join the conversation on Discord

James (Spoilers)

Now when you decide too spare Lilly’s life by James request , AJ hands over the gun and what really pissed me off was...WHY THE FUCK WOULD YOU TURN YOUR BACK ON THE ENEMY, even if she’s incapacitated she can still be a treat....Honestly!!??

That was dumbest move I’ve ever seen never turn your back on the enemy...EVER!!!

That’s how you can get yourself killed...

Rule #1 Never underestimate the enemy... even if He/She is incapacitated .

Comments

  • I’m guessing you trusted the enemy in the first place?

  • Yeah, I loved James this episode, his character unraveled a lot of plot and I was trying so hard to not let AJ kill. But some people just have to fucking die. James needs to understand that sometimes you gotta put a .38 in a motherfucker. It's life :lol:

  • edited January 2019

    I spared Lilly not because I trusted the ennemy, I just didn't want AJ to become a serial killer, if it was up to me I would have spared her and immediately tied her up.

    Melton23 posted: »

    I’m guessing you trusted the enemy in the first place?

  • I know, it feels like they just wanted to punish us, you know no matter what you do there are gonna be repercussions, but I feel like it was poorly made, I mean yeah first why would James turn his back on her, and why wouldn't you tie her up or something like that, I mean I never trusted Lilly, and just cause I spared her doesn't mean I did trust her, I knew she was talking crap just to save her life.

  • Same. Her killing James made me back out though. I was kind to Abel and stunned the guards, I’ll have more episode 4 opportunities to set an example. This was a one off.

    Demonarke posted: »

    I spared Lilly not because I trusted the ennemy, I just didn't want AJ to become a serial killer, if it was up to me I would have spared her and immediately tied her up.

  • Well I didn't back out, I felt like this was cheating, I was bittersweet to Abel, I bashed his face in, but let him smoke and killed him mercifully.
    I also spared all the guards, I'm curious to see what's gonna happen with Lilly, but considering her death is determinant I feel like she is just going to escape and never be seen again, or be killed early in the next episode.

    Melton23 posted: »

    Same. Her killing James made me back out though. I was kind to Abel and stunned the guards, I’ll have more episode 4 opportunities to set an example. This was a one off.

  • I sent Rosie after Abel but I on,y thought it was to scare him, I had no idea she’d maul his leg but it still satisfied me in some way...

    And idc if I cheat tbf, I like going for outcomes that would best suit me and leave me feeling for satisfied in the long run.

    Demonarke posted: »

    Well I didn't back out, I felt like this was cheating, I was bittersweet to Abel, I bashed his face in, but let him smoke and killed him mer

  • I only change my choices if I'm like "that's not what I wanted to do" because the game badly explained the choice or something like that.
    If I made a choice that seems accurate to what I would do in real life then I'm okay.

    Also you don't really know if you made the right choice yet, I mean AJ might become f in the head after that, maybe James's death was just a small sacrifice.

    Melton23 posted: »

    I sent Rosie after Abel but I on,y thought it was to scare him, I had no idea she’d maul his leg but it still satisfied me in some way...

  • I wouldn’t say I trusted her, I was mixed emotion about her reapperince considering she wouldn’t be too far gone and after playing episode 3 I have too say she really evolved into manipulative psychopath...But after what she did too Louis I really lost it....but we got too set the example that we are better and keep her captive.

    Melton23 posted: »

    I’m guessing you trusted the enemy in the first place?

  • That and too prove I’m a better at keeping my Humanity then she did.

    Demonarke posted: »

    I spared Lilly not because I trusted the ennemy, I just didn't want AJ to become a serial killer, if it was up to me I would have spared her and immediately tied her up.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.