Good Sheriff or Bad Sheriff?
With the bigger choices, there’s always a mercy option or a violent option. For example, first encounter with Bloody Mary, you got Dum pinned against the wall, you can either let him go or rip out his throat. Many, if not all the choices in this game were something like that, spare or kill.
My question to you is, what choices did you make? What kind of Sheriff did you turn Bigby into? Were you merciful, or did you stoop to their level?