Telltale should have had some fun with Sarah

You know instead of killing her off the way they did they could have really made her interesting. I could see little hints being dropped like Clementine walking in on her and finding her talking to herself. Throughout the game weird things start happening. Clem would notice it, but if she speaks up the others tell her to leave Sarah be, she just lost her father. In the finale you find out she's straight up insane, and responsible for at least one member of the group being killed. She doesn't die, but ends up escaping and you never see her again.... Or maybe in season 3.

«1

Comments

  • I'm glad she got killed off.

  • They sure had fun when they had that interview with Greg Miller about Sarah...

  • Because you're a racist.

    I'm glad she got killed off.

  • Racism is hatred against other races, wishing Sarah to die is sadism. And impatience.

    Kennyftw posted: »

    Because you're a racist.

  • I saw the title and thought 'what the hell, this guy is sick' but it wasn't so bad, lol.

    I guess I agree with you though?

  • True.

    Kennyftw posted: »

    Because you're a racist.

  • That was a good interview.

    TheMPerson posted: »

    They sure had fun when they had that interview with Greg Miller about Sarah...

  • Sounds better than that atrocious deck death scene. Her screams still haunt me to this day.

  • lol. awesome. Sarah, and Luke's deaths in particular seemed rush, and a waste.

    Crips posted: »

    I saw the title and thought 'what the hell, this guy is sick' but it wasn't so bad, lol. I guess I agree with you though?

  • I was just joking lol

    Crips posted: »

    Racism is hatred against other races, wishing Sarah to die is sadism. And impatience.

  • I just wish there more scenes of Clem and Sarah being kids, just hanging out or playing.

  • Screams that were glossed over by the entire group.

    NOHATCLEM posted: »

    Sounds better than that atrocious deck death scene. Her screams still haunt me to this day.

  • I think Sarah should've lived until the end of the Season, would've liked to have a best friend around.

  • Then you and Greg deserve to be fired

    That was a good interview.

  • I wish she lived through the entire season.

  • I tryed to save her but I mean she was kinda dumb so I don't really mind her dying

  • edited January 2016

    They definitely could have done more with Sarah's character. I think they should have made her crazy like Lizzie in the TV show. The episode "The Grove" is probably the most powerful episode of all.

  • deserve to be fired

    Fired for what?

    AronDracula posted: »

    Then you and Greg deserve to be fired

  • I kind of wish her second death, had also been more her own doing. Such as again she refuses to move, I get what they were trying to do with the character but the final scene was just badly done.

  • edited January 2016

    Greg Miller is a heartless bastard. Sorry if he is meant something about Telltale

    deserve to be fired Fired for what?

  • Unfortunately she just kind of shut down. It would have been interesting dealing with someone that had mentally snapped (not in the pissed off way). It looked like Sarah's character was heading that way.

  • Greg Miller is a heartless bastard

    For liking that a fictional annoying little girl got killed off? Well I guess I'm a heartless bastard too, and proud of it.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Greg Miller is a heartless bastard. Sorry if he is meant something about Telltale

  • Her first death was fine, but her second death did come off as sloppy.

    I kind of wish her second death, had also been more her own doing. Such as again she refuses to move, I get what they were trying to do with the character but the final scene was just badly done.

  • Greg Miller was happy that Sarah- a fiction character- got killed off. Now all the Sarah fans are pissed off and hate him now.

    deserve to be fired Fired for what?

  • Her death makes no sense. Don't care what you have to say, her death was bull***t written.

    Greg Miller is a heartless bastard For liking that a fictional annoying little girl got killed off? Well I guess I'm a heartless bastard too, and proud of it.

  • Let's say, she did Luke's job instead

    I kind of wish her second death, had also been more her own doing. Such as again she refuses to move, I get what they were trying to do with the character but the final scene was just badly done.

  • Don't remind me of that girl, I think she lost it much more. She never wanted to learn about walkers which are not "pets' lol, she also killed her own sister for no good reason.

    ClemRanger posted: »

    They definitely could have done more with Sarah's character. I think they should have made her crazy like Lizzie in the TV show. The episode "The Grove" is probably the most powerful episode of all.

  • I always thought she would commit suicide, seeing that she's thinking of jumping of the roof at howes

    DoubleJump posted: »

    Unfortunately she just kind of shut down. It would have been interesting dealing with someone that had mentally snapped (not in the pissed off way). It looked like Sarah's character was heading that way.

  • I wish she was in more scenes :|

  • The thought always came to my mind. Why exactly did she walk towards the edge of the roof like that?

    I always thought she would commit suicide, seeing that she's thinking of jumping of the roof at howes

  • edited January 2016

    k

    AronDracula posted: »

    Her death makes no sense. Don't care what you have to say, her death was bull***t written.

  • Like Sarah would survive five minutes out on her own.

  • The Stranger did alright. Clementine has. We saw a weak, and limited Sarah. If she turned out to be a raging psychopath with a high IQ she could be pretty dangerous

    Like Sarah would survive five minutes out on her own.

  • Sarah was probably the biggest waste of potential in season 2. A character that could've been an emotional centerpiece for the game.

    But alas TellTale never made her even remotely interesting and instead opted to make her an implausibly naïve moron with little to no character.

  • I think the most wasted one was Reggie because he was nothing in Season 2. At least Sarah saved Clem's life in episode 1

    Sarah was probably the biggest waste of potential in season 2. A character that could've been an emotional centerpiece for the game. But

  • edited January 2016

    she could be pretty dangerous

    I doubt that. She never killed anyone. That's my thought

    Kennyftw posted: »

    The Stranger did alright. Clementine has. We saw a weak, and limited Sarah. If she turned out to be a raging psychopath with a high IQ she could be pretty dangerous

  • You can't waste something that never had any potential in the first place. Reggie was a lot like AJ, just a plot device to show how evil Carver was.

    AronDracula posted: »

    I think the most wasted one was Reggie because he was nothing in Season 2. At least Sarah saved Clem's life in episode 1

  • Uh did you read the topic? In it I laid out the plot on her going insane, and killing someone. I was saying what telltale should have done.

    AronDracula posted: »

    she could be pretty dangerous I doubt that. She never killed anyone. That's my thought

  • Reggie's voice didn't even seem to match his body.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.