Which characters, out off all the games would make the best functioning group, in the apoacalyps.
So which, characters out off all TWD games, we have met so far would have the biggest chance of surviving, the zombie apoacalyps as a group in your opinion.
This is what i think, would have been a very good functioning group.
Lilly / As the leader, she is smart has good survival skills, and knows how to keep a group together.As seen by her teaching everyone how to shoot a gun, and making sure everyone got a fair share of the food ration.
Vince / As second in charge, since we know he was the leader, of the 400-days group. And he seems to be the type of guy to me.
Thats just demands respect out of others.
Katjaa / As the medic, she is a very good natured person, has medical skills.
Doug / He is a intelligent dude, knows how to fix things, has a sense of humor just a very good member, to have in a group.
Jane / She might, not be a group type of person, but i think she would make for a good, supplie runner if she would be in a group.)
Pete /Michonne series / Always good to have someone, to be the moral-compass of the group.
Wyatt / He would be the guy, that makes everyone laugh, always good to have.
Samantha / She is willing to save other characters at, a huge risk, as seen by not escaping the burning house herself, but instead sticked around when Michonne is in a hallicunation, and her trying to escape the storage-room, to save Greg.
Pete/S2 / He knows how to hunt, and fish also he seemed like a very cool guy in my opinion.
Shell / I think she seems like a level-headed person, which would be good for the dynamic of the group.
Well i think this would be the best functioning group, to have a chance to survive in a world like TWD.
I would, like to see all the diffrent opinions/groups that you all come up with 
Comments
I agree with all of that except Vince, Jane, and Wyatt. I think Carley and Christa would be just as dependable as the rest of them. I feel iffy about Samantha, but if she can pull off stealing supplies, it might be worth having her along.
I would prefer Molly over Jane as the supplies runner. She survived in Savannah for a while on her own and if someone is going out alone or in a small group for supplies, then I have more confidence in Molly with Hilda than Jane. There is always a chance she could leave the group but the same can be said of Jane too.
I didn't really like Molly's additude, but she would be a good supplie-runner to indeed
But i personally, would trust Jane allot more to stay, and bring back supplies then Molly.
Honestly, it would be good to have both. Better to not go out alone if possible. As Jane said, "Sometimes it's nice to have someone watching your back".
Really we are doing a zombie survival group in TWD section lol.
Leader...Lee
Lieutenants...Carley,Lilly and Pete
Medics...Carlos and Katjaa
Scroungers...Jane,Molly and Luke
Scout....Molly
Rest of the group.. Doug, Clem, Vince, Omid and Crista
What i mean to with this topic which characters would make a, strong group together that dont get destroyed like the S1/S2 groups.
And which characters would have the best group dynamic.
And i just think its fun to see, which characters people name and what in there opinions, the reasons are these characters would make a good group together, that would have the best chance to surive the apaocalyps.
They would be conveniently settled down at a supermarket on the side of a highway, barricaded with trucks, cars, and planks of wood. The make-shift fortification would have several ladders leaning against it as exit in case of emergency.
Norma would make a good de facto leader for this crew. She strikes me as a diplomatic, reasonable, ground-to-earth, and level-headed woman.
Lilly would be put as the right-hand woman, and the head of the security crew.
Uncle Pete would regularly go out fishing to a nearby stream and go hunting in the surrounding woods, because the group is only consuming the canned goods as last resort.
Well, scrap that. He was a serious douche, and I totally forgot about Vernon. I want him on this group.
Carley and whoever was sniping at Michonne from a mile would be the rest of the security crew. The three people take turns to be on watch.
Boyd inspires the rest of the group to act morally. And he prepares one hell of a soup, with fresh vegetables from his garden!
Other useful background characters to make the camp look full.
Other useful background characters to make the camp look full.
They could use watch-dogs, like in Shell''s story
That reminds me of a fan villain I'd make for Season 3. The villain would work around walkers and purposely kill victims but not the brain to use them as watch dogs. That also reminded me of a villain from a movie I can't remember with man eating pigs who ended up getting betrayed and the pigs ate him alive.
Larry, Troy, Nate, Randall, Ben, Duck, and Zachary
An asshole, an even bigger asshole, a crazy guy, a crazy guy that's also an asshole, two idiots, and one sane person
Nothing could go wrong
Haha, good one
But i wouldn’t call that a good fuctioning group, but im sure all those characters would have a intressting group dynamic. xd
I agree with all of this.
trigger-happy one
@ BetterToSleep
I just noticed i forgot to add, to my post that in my opinion, you made up a really, cool group that would really have a good chance of working in the apoacalyps
Your right
Molly & Jane could, make an awesome team if they could get along with eachother.
But sadly i do not see that happening, if they would go on a supplie run together, but i could be wrong
Thank you! I made it off the top of my head.
Eh, Jane came back, Molly didn't.
So like most characters in the game? :P
I don't think putting Kenny, Jane, Lilly, Randall and Nate together would lead to a 'functioning group' to be perfectly honest.
Your right
I was thinking the same, that would be the most dysfunctional group in the history off, all twd groups
I could see it happening if they sympathize with each other since they both lost a younger sister. Maybe they would form a bond with each other over time. I agree they probably wouldn't trust each other at first, but given enough time, I think they could be good partners.
I don't think it's fair to compare these two situations as they are completely different. With Molly, I think she realized that the boat wasn't big enough for everyone and she was the last one to join the group. If Kenny figured it out, I'm sure Molly did too. So she decided to leave because she didn't want to be kicked out. Then, for all she knew, everyone was going to leave on the boat as soon as they could. She didn't know about Clem being kidnapped so there was no reason for her to come back, because in her mind, they already would have left. At least, that's the way I looked at it.
Jane, of course, did come back, which showed how much she cared for Clem. She says she stayed in the area, which means something (Clem) was holding her back from doing what she always did to that point. If Clem was in the group, then I would believe that Jane would be more likely to stay than Molly as Molly is not really seen as close to Clem. However, I still would appreciate Molly's scavenging talents more than Jane based on what we have seen so far.
I haven't played the Michonne series, so this will be for seasons 1 and 2 only.
I don't get why you would choose Lily. Sure, Ben turned out to be the guilty party as she suspected, but you can't just shoot someone on a hunch.
My picks are:
Lee
Clementine
Doug
Carley
Molly
Christa
Omid
Pete
Bonnie
Jane
I'll probably get flamed for the last two, but they're both tough and good with a weapon and they're actions are justifiable imo. For that same reason, I didn't include Kenny. I like the guy but he's a loose cannon and has brought dissension and inflamed tempers in every group he's been with.
From 400 days: Shel, Stephanie, and Vince.
Kenny, Jane, Lilly, Randall and Nate all sit in a room.
Kenny: Complains about way furniture was organized.
Jane: Sits detached in a corner, looking at the roof.
Lilly: Is suspicious that somebody super-glued her to chair.
Randall: Makes snarky comments about host.
Nate: Talks about Jane's chest.
Jane shoots Nate in the crotch
Oh my god... I want this DLC. Forget the other guys. Forget the zombie apocalypse even! I just want a DLC of these five sitting in a room arguing about nothing.
There is a much nicer medic than Vernon -- Jonas.
I don't get why you would choose Lily. Sure, Ben turned out to be the guilty party as she suspected, but you can't just shoot someone on a hunch.
Well, Lilly was in a dark place, when she shot Doug/Carley. If Kenny wouldn't have smashed her father's skull with a saltlick infront of her.
She would never have, attempted to shoot someone on a hunch.
So in my opinion i really dont blame her, for shooting Doug/Carley sure it was a terrible thing, to do but Kenny started a horrible chain of events when he killed Larry.
Also the reasons, why i would choose Lilly as the leader i already posted that in the topic
It's relevant to note that Molly has only stayed on the city after the apocalypse, while Jane has been on the woods for a good while, given that we know she crossed four states. I don't know if Molly would be as resourceful as Jane is on a forest. That said, I believe Jane wouldn't be as capable as Molly when it comes to quickly scavenging abandoned houses and apartments.
They're both really different in that sense. People tend to overlook that.
Hmmm, that's true, I never thought about that. Just shows how different they really are, even though people compare them as if they are essentially the same. So I guess we would decide which one to pick for the group based on what area we are in.
you forgot about Lee?
This makes my point on Kenny exactly. Rash emotional decisions without considering the others' wishes at all. Still, I wouldn't trust someone to lead a group who was in such a bad place they'd shoot and ask questions later. The leader should be able to stay calm and level-headed under pressure ie: Lee, Pete, or Christa.
I don't know if Carver would be cool with not being in charge. lol and Nate is the wild card. I could see giving Shel more responsibility, like planning.
Well Lilly, won't be in such a bad place for ever, but the mess with the bandits just started a few days after the murder of her dad, which she witnessed first hand.
I think characters you name that make a good leader, could preform an act like that to under such circumstances, Christa for example, she shot the girl that killed Omid, to without asking question's.
But i agree, im sure there are other characters beside Lilly that could make a good group leader aswell.
But im just a little biased cause Lilly is my favourite character out of all TWD franchise